كل القصص

بدت كرجل حتى لحقت بها الصدمة والتشخيص الخاطئ

أنثى · توقف عن التحول830
تم تلخيص هذه القصص باستخدام الذكاء الاصطناعي.

على Reddit، غالبًا ما يشارك الناس تجاربهم عبر تعليقات أو منشورات متعددة. لجعل هذه المعلومات أكثر سهولة في الوصول إليها، يقوم detrans.ai بتجميع كل تلك القطع المبعثرة في ملخص واحد سهل القراءة مع جدول زمني. يتم تدوين جميع موجهات النظام في صفحة الموجهات.

في بعض الأحيان يمكن أن يتوههم الذكاء الاصطناعي أو يذكر أشياء غير صحيحة. ولكن بشكل عام، تكون القصص الملخصة انعكاسات دقيقة للتعليقات الأصلية للمستخدمين.

الملخص

أنا امرأة متحولة سابقًا (من أنثى إلى ذكر ثم عودة إلى أنثى) عشتُ ومررتُ كرجل متحول لسنوات، وتحولت طبيًا عبر الرعاية الصحية العامة بالتيستوستيرون، ثم عُدت عن التحول بعد إدراكي أنني أنثى وأن تشخيصي كان خاطئًا. أقول الآن إن الزَيَق الجندري لديّ نبع من صدمة معقدة، وكراهية النساء المُستبطن، وكوني غير مطابقة جندريًا بطبعي، والتنوع العصبي، لا من زَيَق فطري. أندم على تغييري جسدي ليناسب صندوقًا آخر، وما زلت أشعر بالحزن تجاه السمات المُذكَّرة، رغم أنني أقول إنها تتلاشى مع الوقت، وإنني كنت أُمرِّر كرجل وكنت مدعومة عندما تحولت. أنا منتقدة بصراحة لسهولة الوصول إلى الهرمونات والجراحات، خصوصًا للأطفال، وأنادي باللا-مطابقة الجندرية كبديل عن التحول. أعتقد أن حياة مُرضية بعد التحول العكسي ممكنة، وأنني الآن أعيش كذاتي الحقيقية.

القصة الكاملة

I was born female and grew up in the mid-2000s, when the word nonbinary barely existed and few people had even seen trans people on television. I never had innate gender dysphoria — I felt my sex was just fine, I was female and I was a woman. But I was naturally gender non-conforming, and without any intentional effort I was often mistaken for a boy. Some girls told me they didn't feel like I was one of them; some guys straight up asked me if I was something other than a woman, some out of curiosity, some to hurt my feelings. It was a huge shame, being something completely "other" and failing to perform as who I was supposed to be. On top of that I had complex trauma and other issues, and I could never train myself to be "a lady." So I came to see a trans identity as the natural answer and salvation that would finally make me normal, that I could finally blend in. I identified and lived as a trans man for years — everybody I know thought it was obvious I was a transman, a textbook example — and I passed. My transition was 100% in public health care. I was in the trans circles for a long time, which is why I can still detect the slight effects of testosterone in my own voice. I also had support for being trans from my family and friends. Eventually I came to realize I was female and had been misdiagnosed. My body and gender dysphoria, I now believe, came from trauma and from being neurodivergent. The process of detransitioning hit me with panic and confusion when I started making decisions about it. What moved me toward detransition was healing: once I started to heal and felt safe enough to return to my body and to the present moment, I was horrified at how I had altered my very being. I hold the view that mind and body are not separate and that I cannot play with my body as if it were completely detached. Gender lost its meaning when I was united with my birth sex. Stopping taking testosterone was a key step — seeing that I didn't have to alter myself any more. The masculinized features are still there, and it is perfectly fine to feel sorrow about that; I sometimes still do, though I note they fade slowly as you get older and become part of you. People often mistake me for a trans woman now, they think I have a penis, which feels utterly absurd — failing to still be seen as who I am, just a bit differently. I have reflected a lot on what led me here. I think being trans and non-binary was just another stereotype with its own limits and struggles; I thought I could finally be free of female stereotypes, and in a way I was, but I was altering my body to fit into another box, with various traumas fueling the attempt. Trying to fit into something you are not is soul crushing when you realize how pointless and hurtful it is. I also believe internalized misogyny played a role — the whole culture fills femininity with undesirable stereotypical traits, being hysterical, dumb, passive, and so on. I have noted how many women first say they are nonbinary and/or trans and then find out they are autistic, and how often that is handled as a happy rare coincidence. I have also observed that failing to pass has been the biggest reason for many people to detransition, and that for me part of it was coming to terms with my sex rather than struggling against it. I have experienced humiliation in the early stages of detransition, but I say that people who have been skeptical about transition almost always see how painful it is to detransition and just want to make you feel comfortable. Somehow we make it through. I have given advice to others about trauma-related amnesia being a healthy coping mechanism, and about dissociation, drawing on my own experience. I told one person that I know the panic and confusion that hit me when I started to make decisions about detransitioning, and that I would stop T, take care of myself, do something daily other than wondering about gender, and give myself time. On access to medical transition, I have been outspoken. I have asked whether it is transphobic to say that people get access to hormones and surgeries way too easily, and pushed back when people say "it's their regret." I argue that if you haven't lost a body part, you shouldn't invalidate other people's pain as "that's their regret," and that detransitioned people should be given space to speak. I distinguish between desisters and detransitioners, saying the trauma of having gone through medical procedures is something a bit different, while respecting that this subreddit uses detrans for everyone. I have argued that children cannot make these decisions in a vacuum and that adults are responsible for allowing life-altering things to happen to a person still figuring out who they are, comparing it to tattoos. I have also advised a gay man that his dysphoria is caused by trauma around being a gay man and that altering his body won't take care of his hurt — he will still be a gay man after HRT and surgeries. I am critical of the transgender community but say it is not hate, just facts. I think some people do find transition a perfect solution and live happily as the gender they identify as, but I don't think there are so many who seriously need medical transition; for many it is just a phase and should be treated as such, and being gender non-conforming should be more accepted and offered as an alternative. I have praised balanced, well-written newspaper coverage of the topic. I believe it is very possible to live a fulfilled life after detransition — the process is hard and takes a while, with lots of emotions to unpack, but it is worth it because you are living as your true self. I have suggested that someone who has always felt icky about their birth name could give themselves a new female name to mark a new beginning and healing. I hold a spiritual view that body and soul are inseparable and intertwined, and that the soul is present in breath, heartbeat and walking. I also caution against obsessing over whether strangers are male or female, having witnessed a group harassing a woman with accusations of being a man in disguise when she had never touched steroids. I have advised someone considering surgery to wait and be sure, and told someone on testosterone that it would be self-harm, like alcohol, not a fix.