كل القصص

عشر سنوات على الإستروجين، وما زالت تعرّف نفسها كرجل

ذكر · توقف عن التحول368
تم تلخيص هذه القصص باستخدام الذكاء الاصطناعي.

على Reddit، غالبًا ما يشارك الناس تجاربهم عبر تعليقات أو منشورات متعددة. لجعل هذه المعلومات أكثر سهولة في الوصول إليها، يقوم detrans.ai بتجميع كل تلك القطع المبعثرة في ملخص واحد سهل القراءة مع جدول زمني. يتم تدوين جميع موجهات النظام في صفحة الموجهات.

في بعض الأحيان يمكن أن يتوههم الذكاء الاصطناعي أو يذكر أشياء غير صحيحة. ولكن بشكل عام، تكون القصص الملخصة انعكاسات دقيقة للتعليقات الأصلية للمستخدمين.

الملخص

أنا رجل تحوّل قبل أكثر من عشر سنوات ليعيش كامرأة متحوّلة ولا يزال متحوّلًا طبيًا، لكنني لم أعد أعتقد أن الهوية الجنسانية حقيقية وأعرف نفسي داخليًا كرجل. تحوّلت في بداية الرشد خلال فترة من التشرّد وتعاطي المخدرات وتداعيات منزل مسيء، مدفوعًا باضطراب الهوية الجنسية طوال الحياة والرغبة في أن أكون شخصًا آخر. أنا راضٍ عن مظهري المُؤنَّث لكنني متضايق لأن عليّ الحفاظ على هوية أنثوية لا أُقرّ بها لمواصلة الحصول على الهرمونات، وأخاف كثيرًا من تغيّرات الجسد بحيث لا أستطيع التراجع طبيًا. أرى الآن التحوّل محض تجميلي، بكلفة تفوق فوائده، وأحذّر الآخرين بنشاط من التحوّل. أنا في صراع لم يُحلّ بين عدم الإيمان بالهوية المتحوّلة وبين بقاء اضطراب الهوية الجنسية لديّ، وأفكر حاليًا في خطوة اجتماعية جزئية للتراجع مثل اسم محايد جنسيًا وعلامات جنس ذكري في الأوراق.

القصة الكاملة

I am a man who transitioned to live as a trans woman, and I've been medically transitioned for over ten years. I'm fairly passable and I don't dislike how I look — in fact I'm happy with my appearance — but I've come to believe that gender identity isn't real and that I'm simply "a weird, mentally ill man" who made a decision during a vulnerable period of my life. My gender dysphoria goes back to childhood and has been present throughout my life, sometimes worse, sometimes milder. I've generally thought of myself as a mentally ill person. I transitioned at the very start of adulthood during a bad phase: I had left an abusive home, was homeless, was doing a lot of drugs, and life felt hallucinatory and unreal. Around that time, transition was becoming culturally popular in American and then British media — I mentioned figures like Hari Nef, Laverne Cox and Paris Lees as part of the cultural backdrop. I hated my life, hated myself, wanted to be someone else, and had strong lifelong dysphoria, so I transitioned. It made sense at the time, but now I feel the whole thing is a lie. The core of my current struggle is a conflict: I don't believe in being transgender, yet I still have gender dysphoria and don't want a male appearance. After a great deal of effort I no longer have one, so I can't face the thought of my body changing back. I also can't face detransitioning for social reasons. So I'm torn between "the awful lie of trans identity" and my inability to stomach my own physical sex. I've considered changing my name to something gender-neutral with a slightly feminine edge and changing my ID sex markers back to male — lying a little less — so I could be medically transitioned without claiming to be something I don't believe I am, and say honestly, "Yes I have transitioned, because I'm not that mentally well." I now perceive my transition as purely cosmetic and believe there are no real benefits to it, while the costs are immense: discrimination I face, social disruption, and emotional distress when male-pattern criminality of trans women is discussed in ways that paint everyone as dangerous perverts. I wish I had taken a less drastic approach to cosmetic femininity — for instance just taking finasteride to prevent male pattern balding — rather than ending up, in my view, "an outcast with a false identity." Taking hormone blockers and oestrogen is an enormous inconvenience and potential health risk I'll have to maintain for life unless I medically detransition, which I'm scared to do because of the disfiguring effect it could have on my now-feminised body. Access to these treatments in my country (the UK) is likely conditional on maintaining a female identity I don't actually avow, forcing me into a life of deception, and access could be taken away at any time — I noted that three quarters of people in my country believe the NHS should not fund transgender treatments at all. I've been broadly disappointed in the trans community. I've found few trans women I could be friends with who didn't seem pushy, socially unaware, self-centred and "kinda porn-sick," and I criticised trans-femme subreddits for focusing on force-femme content, being called a "good girl," and sexualised anime imagery. I also said I've often been envious of trans men, who I find more emotionally well-rounded, calm and kind, and that all the things I admire about women generally are present in trans men, while the things I'd want to escape about men are present in trans women — concluding that transition didn't stop trans women from being, in essence, "a bunch of dudes." I've said I'm happy with my body as it is but not happy being "a man disguised as a woman," and I don't yet know how to navigate that dilemma. I have not had therapy in a long time. I mentioned being interested in DBT and psychoanalysis — I liked the psychoanalytic idea that someone is "functioning at the borderline level" rather than fixed with a diagnosis like BPD, because that level can be changed. I also commented that a previous therapist I liked seemed to think I could do no wrong, and that cheerleading enablement can be grating. I've referred to myself as autistic in the context of warning someone else about the difficulties of being an autistic trans woman, and I've referenced BPD-adjacent patterns in people around me. I've been chronically online, anxiety-posting about gender repeatedly, and I described the compulsive, irrational nature of transition thoughts, urging others to build a separate life with social hobbies rather than ruminating at home on the internet. On sexuality and sexual culture, I expressed disgust at porn saturation online — that every mention of male femininity becomes femboy porn, and I referenced "groomer"-style discourse and fetishisation in the trans community. I said thinking about this kind of thing "reminds me of what I was running from in the first place," though I don't specify what that was beyond the general picture of a difficult, drug-fuelled, homeless period after leaving an abusive home. I posted a reflection comparing detrans male and female experiences, worrying society welcomes detrans women but treats detrans men as admitting to being predators, then acknowledged I was being silly and that saying fears out loud helps me see how ridiculous they sound. I also acknowledged an irrational belief that life is better for women — which I recognise is an inversion of the truth — and mocked myself for having used that belief as a reason to try becoming one. I value this detrans community precisely because everyone considering or having detransitioned can speak without censure, unlike "the other sub" which censors from the start. I've advised others considering transition not to do it, warned that transition makes problems worse, and said I would not recommend transition to anyone under any circumstances since I don't believe gender identity exists — instead I think people should realise what they want is cosmetic femininity and pursue it respectfully. As for where I am now: I remain medically transitioned, still present socially as a trans woman, still have gender dysphoria, but internally identify as a man and no longer believe in transgender identity. I've been contemplating partial social detransition — a more neutral name and male ID markers — while staying on hormones. I have not described any specific surgeries, and I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm, though my writing is frequently bleak and self-critical, calling myself broken and stupid and wondering whether people who hate people like me are right.