Disse historier er blevet sammenfattet ved hjælp af AI.
På Reddit deler folk ofte deres erfaringer på tværs af flere kommentarer eller indlæg. For at gøre denne information mere tilgængelig samler detrans.ai alle disse spredte stykker i en enkelt, letlæselig sammenfatning og tidslinje. Alle systemprompts er noteret på prompts-siden.
Nogle gange kan AI hallucinere eller angive ting, der ikke er sande. Men generelt er de sammenfattede historier nøjagtige refleksioner af de originale kommentarer fra brugere.
Resumé
Jeg er en desisteret kvinde, som i årevis overvejede at være trans og kortvarigt var på testosteron, men aldrig kom ud socialt, så jeg gennemgik en intern desistens snarere end en fuld medicinsk detransition. Jeg oplever autoandrofili, som jeg mener udviklede sig fra fejlrettet tiltrækning til mænd, plus et langvarigt ønske om at være maskulin, der begyndte i puberteten. At opgive at knytte min selvværd til mit udseende og til, hvordan andre ser mig, var det, der lod mig overvinde det meste af min dysfori, som nu er mild og sjælden. Jeg lever stadig som kvinde og finder det lettere og mere i overensstemmelse med mine værdier, og jeg fortryder ikke at have afstået fra transition. Jeg er kritisk over for nuværende transitionspraksisser, især for autistiske, isolerede eller unge mennesker med urealistiske forventninger.
Hele historien
I was born female and I've never medically transitioned, though I did briefly take testosterone at one point and never came out socially to anyone. I call myself a "desister" — I ideated about being trans for years and was on T briefly, but I never came out socially. I didn't plan to unless I stayed on T long enough to have to explain it, which I didn't. So I don't know what that makes me, but I would say I went through an internal desistance, and it wasn't a trivial one. My mental health and core identity were affected for years.
I wanted desperately to be masculine from puberty onwards. Over time that desire did make me more masculine — I got male friends and developed some hobbies more common among guys. I'm probably still read as somewhat gender nonconforming. But underneath it all I was the same girl who was stereotypically feminine as a child. Repressing my more feminine traits never made them go away. Looking back on photos and videos from when I thought I was presenting as very masculine, I'm struck by how feminine my mannerisms were, how feminine my voice was when I let my guard down. Mannerisms were actually the hardest thing for me to change — my personality, interests, and speech patterns did come across as masculine to people in my life, which required an effort that was probably unhealthy, but my mannerisms never got there. I found the experience of trying and failing to be something I was not quite painful.
I have autoandrophilia (AAP). My AAP is pretty deeply embedded and hasn't gone away even after having good relationships with men and women, but it's less prominent. AAP basically made me bisexual with a preference for women even though I was straight at the start of puberty. I still prefer to date women because that makes it easier for my AAP to fit into sex, but over time my sexual attraction has been directed more outwards, towards both men and women. I was able to intentionally alter mine by forcing myself to focus more on the other person in my fantasies. This eventually translated into real life sex. I don't think "conversion" is really possible, it's more that if you have both autosexuality and allosexuality, you can force yourself to focus on one or the other. I'm also an AAP who doesn't date cis males. I've become slightly less AAP over time by trying to redirect my focus during fantasies and sex.
When I realized the extent to which my interest in masculinity was just misdirected attraction, I felt incredibly stupid at first. Like, this is what was making me hate my body and personality all those years? But through talking to trans people, and observing detrans spaces, I've realized it's actually incredibly common. I think growing up on the internet has caused a lot of people to project their identity onto what they're attracted to, maybe especially autistic and/or socially isolated people. Acknowledging my envy of men as attraction didn't make the envy go away entirely, especially at first. But over time I was able to separate my feelings about myself from my feelings about masculinity.
Letting go of finding worth in how I look and how I'm seen was what let me move past dysphoria. It wasn't "I'm happy with my body and I want people to see me as feminine now" — it was "I no longer believe it's important how people see me, and I have other things that matter more to me than my problems with my body." Once I got to that point, I just wanted to be presentable in public and put as little thought and effort into my presentation as possible. I still don't really like how I look, but it's more along the lines of "I'd rather be taller, too bad I'm not" than severe distress. I dress in order to blend in and move through society on the path of least resistance. Personally, one thing I like about being a cis woman is that I come across as somewhat masculine for a cis woman, which makes me feel good. If I presented as a man, I would be feminine for a man and constantly feel like I was falling short of my own ideal.
I still have mild dysphoria sometimes, though it's gotten better and rarer with age. But it's easier to live as a woman and more in line with my values, so that's what I do. And even if my dysphoria hadn't gotten better, I don't think I would have gotten what I wanted from transition either.
I was in college around ten years ago and started as a true believer in trans ideology. I met some of those people at my school's LGBT org, which was full of activist types. They all had a bunch of mental illnesses they talked about constantly, and I stopped hanging out with that group after two different theyfabs started faking seizures and mass drama ensued. That demographic — feminine trans man and nonbinary activists — almost all desisted or detransitioned. My closest trans friend from college was a masculine trans man who is still trans and very binary, also a conservative edgelord so he despised the activist types. He seems quite happy as far as I can tell.
I used to work in STEM/tech as a software engineer in the United States and think I was partly trying to prove to myself that I was masculine. I didn't like it. In general, the women I know in tech don't like it nearly as much as the men who do. I became more conservative throughout my twenties and it started with my disillusionment with trans issues. But I'm still objectively not a conservative. I believe in social safety nets and dignity for all people and hate the cruelty of the Trump types. My goals/ideals more or less align with liberals and progressives, I just think they are wrong about how to get there.
I've had bad experiences with therapy too. I've also had painful periods and am considering going on birth control pills to deal with them, though I've never been on the pill before.
I'm now a desisted/detransitioned woman living as female. I have no regrets about not transitioning — I think transition would not have given me what I wanted. I'm supportive of transition only as a last resort for people with severe dysphoria who go in with realistic expectations, and I'm critical of the informed consent model and of transition being pushed on people with unrealistic expectations, autistic people, and socially isolated young people.