Disse historier er blevet sammenfattet ved hjælp af AI.
På Reddit deler folk ofte deres erfaringer på tværs af flere kommentarer eller indlæg. For at gøre denne information mere tilgængelig samler detrans.ai alle disse spredte stykker i en enkelt, letlæselig sammenfatning og tidslinje. Alle systemprompts er noteret på prompts-siden.
Nogle gange kan AI hallucinere eller angive ting, der ikke er sande. Men generelt er de sammenfattede historier nøjagtige refleksioner af de originale kommentarer fra brugere.
Resumé
Jeg er en detransitioneret/afstået person, der identificerede mig som femboy og blev trukket ind i online MTF-rum, hvor jeg lagde femboy-billeder op og modtog intens opmærksomhed og opmuntring til at transitionere. Jeg tog en måneds gråmarkedsøstrogen fra et kinesisk site i et par uger, før jeg skyllede det ud, fordi jeg ikke ønskede bryster eller sterilitet, og jeg bekymrer mig nu for, at jeg kan have skadet mit reproduktionssystem. Jeg mener, at disse fællesskaber sidestiller kønsnonkonformitet med at være trans og udøver rovdyragtig, kultlignende love bombing af sårbare mennesker. Jeg betragter mig i øjeblikket som en ikke-stereotyp kvinde og advokerer for, at man kan være kønsnonkonform uden at være trans.
Hele historien
I posted in r/detrans about how online MTF trans spaces had drawn me in. I described how these spaces give lonely guys the attention they have never received for questioning, and how that absence of attention becomes conflated with gender dysphoria. I couldn't count the number of people who told me I'd make such a pretty girl for posting femboy pics of myself in Discord servers. Those people would always project their own experience onto me, saying they were a femboy and so much happier now that they started taking E, and telling me "Hehe your egg will crack someday ^w^".
At some point someone gave me a month of grey market estrogen from a Chinese site. The packaging said "keep out of reach of parents" and "Don't look at my giant girld**k >////<" with a loli on the packaging. I took it for a few weeks because I had been scared into thinking I would lose my hair when I got older by other femboy transers. I eventually flushed it down the toilet because I realized I didn't want boobs or to be sterile, and now I'm scared that I've already messed up my reproductive system. Once I said I wasn't taking E anymore, everyone blocked me.
I described the behavior in these communities as predatory, comparing it to parents trying to live vicariously through others. I noted that going into a space like this questioning gets you showered with attention in a way you've never experienced before, and compared it to love bombing within cults, where a new "chosen family" promises to be better than the family who won't accept their daughter unquestionably. I also observed that anyone IRL, such as parents or siblings, who questions the suddenness of your transition is labeled a narcissist and a transphobe trying to force you into a mold they assigned at birth.
I also commented that it's perfectly ok to be a non-stereotypical woman without being trans, and that the conflation in the trans community between gender nonconformity and being trans is disastrous for many people who would have been better off living as a tomboy/girl. I noted that this dynamic seems much less common among transmasc communities, and that most detransitioners appear to be female. Since E isn't a controlled substance, I observed, the only barrier to entry is an internet connection, a place to mail packages, and a card, which is why grey market HRT is so rampant in the transfem sphere, with people actively promoting it on transfem subreddits through memes about ordering girl pills, to which a sea of teens reply "plz DM me." I predicted it's going to result in some crazy blowback within the decade.
I also posted that there is literally no space on Reddit for nuanced discourse on trans politics outside of r/detrans. I mentioned being banned for user harassment after a single comment replying to a particular individual, and I shared a screenshot of a comment with the URL blacked out because I didn't want to be accused of brigading.