Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich wurde als Frau geboren, in einem halbwegs konservativen, homophoben christlichen Umfeld aufgezogen und lebte jahrelang als trans Mann, bevor ich desistierte; ich identifiziere mich heute als Butch-Lesbe und Frau und benutze they/them, während ich mich auf she/her hinarbeite. Ich hatte mit 23 eine Top Surgery mit Doppelschnitt, bin jetzt 3 Jahre post-op und bereue sie nicht – es ist der eine Teil der Transition, mit dem ich zufrieden bin –, bereue aber, mich als trans identifiziert zu haben, und habe nie Hormone genommen. Das Entwirren kam durch die Erkenntnis, dass Transition eine Bewältigungsstrategie für verinnerlichte Misogynie war, und durch die Entdeckung von wahrscheinlich nicht diagnostiziertem ADHS und Temporallappen-Anfällen (diagnostiziert in der Highschool, nachdem ein Arzt mich abgetan hatte, was ich auf Sexismus zurückführe), die meiner Meinung nach meiner Brustdysphorie zugrunde lagen. Ich kämpfe weiter mit Angst, Depression und wiederkehrenden Suizidgedanken, die mit früherem Trauma und ADHS zusammenhängen und nicht mit der Detransition selbst, und ich komme mit Krafttraining, Kunst, Musik und einer unterstützenden Freundin zurecht. Ich sehe sowohl pauschale Bestätigung als auch pauschale Anti-Trans-Positionen kritisch und glaube, dass Transition in Extremfällen hilft, aber weit überbeansprucht wird.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and grew up in a semi-conservative, semi-homophobic Christian environment where my parents never approved of me being masculine, and later that attitude morphed into outright transphobia alongside my church community. I had sexual pictures taken of me at age 8 in broad daylight on the street, and I carry a lot of internalized misogyny and homophobia from those experiences. I recall the desire to be male being present as early as age 4, and I wanted top surgery from about age 9 when puberty hit — roughly 13 years before I actually got it. I was binding unsafely for about 9 years before I got a proper binder at 18, and I lived in that binder almost constantly, only taking it off to shower, sometimes sleeping in it when the dysphoria was unbearable. My top dysphoria was a very specific sensory/body-mapping issue rather than a social one.
I came up with the idea of transition on my own before I was really exposed to feminism or actual transition communities. I socially transitioned and lived as a trans man for a period, and I had a therapist during that time who was never pushy and respected my boundaries. I resisted hormones — I never took testosterone — and I'm glad I held off on everything except top surgery. I got double-incision top surgery at age 23, and I'm now 3 years post-op (so around 26 as of these posts in 2022). I don't regret the surgery at all; it's the one thing from my transition I'm happy about, and most of the time I forget I even had it. I do have some residual numbness under my arms and occasional brief nerve pain near where the nipple was severed, worst in the first 6 months, but nothing I'd call chronic.
What made me think I was trans included body-mapping/kinesthetic issues with my chest, being masculine in interests and aptitude, being attracted to women, significant distress over sex characteristics, enjoying being viewed as male, and a history of anxiety, depression, suicidal ideation, self-harm, and suicidal behavior during menstruation. What made me realize I wasn't included the predatory sexualization at age 8, being raised in a misogynistic/homophobic religious environment with sexual shaming, the fact that gender dysphoria didn't account for all my mental health issues, and an unexplained hesitation about pursuing further transition.
The unraveling happened gradually. Once I started disconnecting myself from the label of woman and female, I realized I had a great deal of hidden hatred toward women, and that it had originally been turned inward. I came to see being trans as a coping mechanism — a way to step out from under crushing negative emotions. It started to truly unravel when I realized I could never be a biological male, that transition would just be an imitation, and that there was no end point: I wanted T, bottom surgery, and even leg lengthening, and any difference I found became a new source of insecurity. I also realized I most likely have undiagnosed ADHD, present since elementary school, which explains a huge range of my symptoms — anxiety, depression, suicidal behavior, self-harm — that had been overshadowed by the dysphoria. I was diagnosed with temporal lobe seizures in high school after needing to see two neurologists; the first claimed I was lying, and I believe that misdiagnosis was connected to my being female. My seizures are located next to the area that processes physical sensation, and I now speculate my top dysphoria was connected to the ADHD and seizures — some crossed or scarred signal alienating physical sensation.
I desisted/detransitioned and now identify as a butch lesbian woman. I currently go by they/them pronouns but am working up the nerve to go back to she/her. My girlfriend is supportive; her younger sister once assumed I was non-binary because of my masculinity, top surgery, and pronouns, but I corrected her that I'm just a butch woman. I have a wonderful girlfriend now after a past relationship with an ex who violated my boundaries, cheated, and hurt me — damage to my trust I'm still working through. My parents were never accepting of my transition, my gender nonconformity, or my being gay, and I feel very lonely in real life with no one who fully understands what I'm going through; I don't want to burden my girlfriend or friends with constant talk of it. My best friend is a trans man who transitioned around the same time I did, and I consider him a brother.
Mental health-wise, I still experience emotional pain, anxiety, and depression, but I attribute that to my past and the undiagnosed ADHD rather than to transition/detransition, which has let me view that period of my life more neutrally. I've had suicidal periods — in March 2022 I described it as coming and going, sometimes 'insanely suicidal,' somewhat better than during transition because I was no longer lying to myself about why I felt bad, but more intense now because I feel there's no real solution, worsened by the state of the world and rising sexism. I also mentioned feeling suicidal lately over the direction of global sexism. I manage dysphoria practically: I weight train 4 days a week because weakness makes me dysphoric, and I carry pepper spray and a pocket knife because feeling vulnerable makes me dysphoric. I collect pocket knives. I use art and music to cope — I listen to Deaf Havana and rock music, collage my journal, and sketch.
I'm skeptical of both blind affirmation and blanket anti-trans positions. I think transition has a place for extreme, unrelenting dysphoria but is far overused, and I compare it to how ECT was once used broadly and has been scaled back. I'm critical of the medical community's erosion of fail-safes, the heavy overlap of ADHD/autism with trans identities going undiscussed, and the speed-push toward medicalization. I also worry about eugenics-adjacent patterns and historical sterilization of institutionalized and low-IQ people. I don't align with any political ideology — I'm a staunch individualist. I've advised others to look inward rather than adopt labels, to give themselves permission not to have an answer, and to step away from all gendered content (trans, cis, detrans) for a while, which helped me enormously. I've also cautioned younger questioners not to rush, to unpack hesitation, and to try non-medical approaches first. I don't regret top surgery even though I regret identifying as trans.