Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau (die sich früher als trans Mann identifizierte), die als Minderjährige mit der Unterstützung meiner Mutter sozial und rechtlich detransitioniert. Meine Transition wurde von schwerer Androphobie und sexueller Belästigung durch Männer, Mobbing durch andere Mädchen und dem Eintauchen in Trans-Kreise und Social Media getrieben. Ich bin heute Gender-Abolitionistin/Feministin, die nicht mehr an Gender glaubt, und ich halte mich weiterhin für sehr GNC, während ich eine elektive doppelte Mastektomie oder Brustverkleinerung aus kosmetischen Gründen abwäge. Ich empfinde intensive Scham, Anwälten, Lehrern und Ärzten sagen zu müssen, dass ich mich geirrt habe, und fürchte, wegen meiner Detransition Freunde zu verlieren. Ich bleibe kritisch gegenüber dem leichten Zugang zu Hormonen und Operationen, besonders für Minderjährige.
Vollständige Geschichte
I am a former trans man who is currently figuring things out, and I still consider myself very gender non-conforming. I first started binding about four years ago, and I had severe androphobia from around age 12 — an intense fear of males (I mean males, not men; I'm even uncomfortable around male dogs) driven by how sexually violent and harassing they are. My transition was pushed by sexual harassment from men: I wanted to stop looking like a woman because I thought becoming less attractive to men would stave off harassment from them. At the time I didn't recognize these reasons; I just 'felt better and happier' when I looked male, and it took time to dissect why.
I was bullied a lot by other girls because I'm ugly (not self-deprecating, just an accurate description of my looks compared to societal norms) and vaguely mentally ill, so I never connected with them. Because I didn't connect with them, I became friends with the 'weirdos,' which included a lot of trans people, and that probably impacted my thought process. I also think social media had a huge effect on transitioning, given the shift in opinion surrounding it in the past decade or two.
I have been working through my androphobia a lot. While my origins of transition started from that fear, I've moved past it. I'm currently working on feeling comfortable being around men while wearing feminine things instead of being in fight-or-flight. I've learned to deal with being a woman through radical acceptance: no matter what I do, men will harass me for my body, so why should I spend time hating it and trying to change it? Why should I give in to what they want — feeling ashamed for being female — instead of being who I am and loving myself? I don't 'like' or 'dislike' being a woman; I simply am one. It's a neutral fact about me with no inherent bearing on my personality, opinions, or thoughts.
I'm incredibly dysphoric about being perceived as a woman because of how women are treated by men. I'd considered that making myself less desirable to men might let some of it up, but you can't escape it under a misogynistic patriarchy. I'm not traumatized by a single big event, but by high, continuous stress that never gave up — I was so scared of being found out as a woman because of how men treat women.
I posted asking for scientific articles on the risks of elective double mastectomy, noting that most sources I found were biased — either fearmongering or pro-transition regardless of risks — or were written for cancer survivors. I said I have no dysphoria other than being generally uncomfortable around males, so I feel level-headed enough not to make rash decisions. I said I wanted a flat chest for purely cosmetic reasons at this point — I just like how clothes fit with a flat chest and how my body looks with one. I mentioned I might gain muscle in the future and that it's good to have fat in that area. I also noted I already have very little nipple sensation, so I'm not worried about losing it.
I posted asking GNC women if they regretted a double mastectomy, saying I'm still on the fence. I stated I have no intent on having children and am getting sterilized later this year, being very firm on being childfree for medical and political reasons. When people pushed back, I said I did not want to debate being childfree and that I think bringing a child into this world would be unethical. I said I'd wait until at least 18 because my brain hasn't fully developed and I want to stop puberty first so teenage reasoning and emotions are gone, so I can make an informed decision. I might try therapy but I'm scared to open up, having seen stories of bad therapists pushing things on clients or calling them bigots for detransitioning. An approved therapist I met with for top surgery literally told me to my face, 'I'm going to change some things about your story so you're more likely to be approved by the insurance' — I really don't think they care. I've been binding for about four years and am probably going to stick with that for a while until I do more research; I'm compiling a list of questions to ask a doctor. I've been leaning toward a breast reduction instead of a full mastectomy, to prevent as much nerve damage as possible, because people's stories here sound horrible and very common.
I broached the topic of detransition with my mom and she was supportive. I'm a minor, so I need her to handle reversing the legal things I did. I'm also not looking forward to changing all of my accounts and emails back. I know that if I come out to my friends they'll probably shun me because I'm detrans from being a gender abolitionist and a lot of them believe in gender exists and take nonbelievers as an attack.
I wrote about the shame of being wrong: I think I'm ready to start socially and legally detransitioning, but every time I think about having to tell lawyers, teachers, and doctors that I was wrong, I get an ugly feeling of shame and guilt in my chest. I was a HUGE advocate for trans people, and it feels embarrassing to say 'I was wrong, this wasn't correct, please change it back, I'm sorry.' I'm scared of the questions because I'm detrans due to being a gender abolitionist/feminist now and don't know how to concisely explain that I don't believe gender exists anymore, which is why I no longer identify as a man/boy.
I've become critical of easy access to transition: I don't think hormones or surgery should be as easily accessible as they are right now, especially for minors with underdeveloped brains, since it's an under-researched field. But I'm not entirely against gender affirmation in the medical field — gender is a belief, and something based in faith shouldn't be used as scientific proof, but I don't think it should be challenged at every turn unless the belief in gender is causing immense distress, in which case a psychologist should help them work through why their beliefs are so distressing. I compare detrans people's gender abolitionism to how Christians might get aggressive if you say 'happy holidays' instead of 'merry christmas.'
I've advised others to question what they have dysphoria over and why, walking through the chain of 'I have dysphoria over my breasts -> why? -> they make me look like a woman -> why does that make you uncomfortable?' I've suggested therapists who specialize in paraphilias for someone with autogynephilia, and noted that talk therapy can help alleviate dysphoria in some cases, suggesting therapists specializing in body identity integrity disorder (BIID) since it's somewhat similar to gender dysphoria. I told someone their worldview seems very restrictive and distressing and that a therapist might help them live happier. I've also defended that AGP exists in some MtF people. When someone said they'd never met a detransitioner who didn't end up trans, I responded that they probably don't take real detransitioners seriously or treat them like shit, and that any detrans friends they have likely don't feel safe enough to tell them.
I fried all my curls off and half my hair with bleach.