Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die ihre Transition heute auf Frauenfeindlichkeit, Trauma und eine übersehene schwere psychische Erkrankung zurückführt und die in einer staatlichen Klinik in New York State als bipolar diagnostiziert wurde, während die Ärzte mich ermutigten, meine Transition fortzusetzen, obwohl Testosteron offenbar meine manischen Episoden auslöste. Ich sehe meinen Testosteron-Gebrauch inzwischen als Steroidsucht und gehe zu AA-Treffen, wo ich die 12 Schritte durcharbeite. Anfang 2025 lebte ich in einem Frauenhaus für häusliche Gewalt in NYC, wo ich lautstark dagegen war, dass Männer mit Bart im Frauenhaus untergebracht wurden, und sie von sozial integrierten trans Frauen unterschied. Ich glaube, Geschlechtsdysphorie ist eine echte psychische Erkrankung, aber keine schwere psychische Erkrankung, und ich trete für psychiatrisches Screening auf Trauma und schwere psychische Erkrankungen vor der Transition ein sowie für Hürden, die verhindern, dass Täter und schwer kranke Männer sich als trans Frauen ausgeben.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and I first came to understand that something was wrong with how I related to my body and my social position as a girl/woman through a combination of misogyny, trauma, and undiagnosed mental illness. I now say plainly that "it was misogyny, trauma, and missed metal illnesses that made me transition." I lived for a time as a man and took testosterone, and I also did drag — I recall shaving my eyebrows for drag and learning makeup techniques from that world.
The year before I posted my "one year apart" comparison photo (January 2025) was the year I was not consistently taking testosterone, and I used that to show people that going back is possible. I have come to believe that testosterone caused me manic episodes: I was diagnosed bipolar in a New York State Hospital, and the doctors there wanted me to continue my transition even while I was having these episodes. I now think that messing with hormones can cause mania and aggressive behavior, and that excess estrogen can lower mood. Depending on state jurisdiction, I observed, they "will give hormones away like candy."
I attend AA meetings for alcohol, cocaine, and meth, and in April 2025 I publicly came to terms with the fact that my testosterone usage belonged in the category of a steroid addiction — an addiction based in physical change and body image rather than a chemically addictive substance. I noted that many people in this detransition community say they cannot or do not want to stop cross-sex hormones even though they are questioning their transition, and I told them that wanting to stop but being unable to is the sign of an addiction. I recommended open AA meetings over NA meetings, the Big Book, and the 12-step program, and I warned people not to stop hormones without a doctor's supervision because stopping testosterone on your own may trigger mania, weight loss, and other health complications. I described myself as also being an alcoholic and said AA has helped me pinpoint my resentments and let go of what people did to me and what I did at the height of my addiction.
In January 2025 I was living in a domestic violence shelter in New York City. I posted angrily that two males with full beards who claim to be women had been placed in the women's DV shelter, one of whom called a black woman the N-word without being removed. I drew a distinction between these men and the trans women already in the shelter who "bother no one," who "shave every day," who "dress like women," and who "are socially women" — I said I had no problem with trans women in the shelter, but that these two were not socially women. I also said I would not want those trans women in a male shelter because they would get hurt. I described the shelter as having no real resources — no legal help, no metro cards, no bottled water — just case workers who want you to get your voucher and leave, and men with non-violent felonies working there. On the bright side, I noted, people had stopped making fun of me and calling me a man.
I hold a nuanced position on gender dysphoria: I call it "a legit mental illness" but distinguish it from Serious Mental Illness (SMI), arguing that gender dysphoria does not impair the ability to make cognitively sound decisions or distinguish reality, unlike bipolar and schizophrenia which involve psychosis. I believe people with gender dysphoria need psychiatric care to rule out SMI and to check for underlying trauma or abuse that could cause the dysphoria, and I argued there need to be barriers in the psychiatric system to stop "seriously mentally ill men and predators from posing as trans women." I also suggested that when someone presents with what looks like social dysphoria rather than body dysphoria, they should speak to a neutral counselor about why they don't socially want to be a woman, and examine how misogyny makes them feel.
I also commented on why people transition, saying the short answer is "everyone else is doing it, and it brings a sense of instant gratification," and that the community shouts about love and community while "it's really just a business."
I am currently a detransitioned female living in a DV shelter, working through the 12 steps, and I am critical of easy access to cross-sex hormones while still being supportive of socially integrated trans women.