Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann, der von 15 bis knapp 19 als Frau (mtf) lebte, mit schwerer Dysphorie, die in Kindheitstrauma, der Misshandlung meiner Mutter durch meinen Vater und meiner daraus folgenden Ablehnung von Männlichkeit wurzelte. Nach einer zwanzigminütigen Sitzung bei einem Therapeuten wurde ich im Schnellverfahren auf Hormone gesetzt und bereute die HRT bald; im Studium detransitionierte ich nach einer selbstreflektierten Erkenntnis, dass meine Dysphorie irrational war. Meine Dysphorie löste sich, als ich Männlichkeit annahm, statt sie abzulehnen, und ich sehe mich nicht mehr als transgender. Heute setze ich mich für tiefere Selbstprüfung vor einer Transition ein und kritisiere die reflexhafte Bestätigung in der Gendertherapie.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male, and I had very severe gender dysphoria from age 15 to just over 19, including significant genital dysphoria. I also idealized being a girl — I felt it was who I was, and the only time in my life I've cried with joy was about six months into my transition, when I was finally able to pass.
My dysphoria had roots I only understood later. As a young kid I had OCD and a bad temper I got from my father, who was very abusive toward my mom — my last memory of him as a child was watching him beat my mom against a door before my older sister called the police. I concluded that anger was masculine, something boys did when misbehaving, so since I was taught never to be angry, I began suppressing my masculinity too. I wanted to never be like my dad. I grew up a feminine guy who avoided conflict and was just nice to people; my friends liked how "innocent" I was, but I was all positivity with no backbone, suppressing any "bad" thought, never standing up for myself. I also had social problems: I had friends, but I was never anyone's best friend, was always the butt of the jokes, was socially awkward, and let resentment build until I snapped at people who didn't deserve it.
Then puberty hit and I became really distressed. I saw myself becoming more masculine and became completely disgusted with myself — I began to look more and more like my father every day. The fears were concrete: losing my feminine face, getting broader shoulders, more body hair, potentially going bald. When I was 15, I saw a transition timeline on YouTube and was ecstatic because I finally had a way out of my disgust; I became immediately convinced this was what I needed. I didn't question how transition would help in any deep way — my hesitations were surface-level, like being labelled a freak and whether my mom would be okay with it. I tried for about one and a half years being "okay" with being male before transitioning; that only delayed the problem and the dysphoria got worse and worse until I cracked under the pressure, concluding transition was the only way I would ever be happy. After about a year and a half I regularly wanted to die and cried myself to sleep most nights because of how much puberty disgusted me. I finally told my mom, and because of what she'd been told about transgender people (needing to accept them, believe them), she was completely supportive of my transition.
I sat down with a therapist for about twenty minutes, said I was feeling dysphoria from an identity misaligned with my body and needed to change something, and just like that I was given a recommendation for HRT to start immediately. Two weeks later I was on testosterone blockers and a smaller dose of estrogen, and I haven't seen the therapist since. I blindly accepted that I was a "woman trapped in a man's body" simply because I had dysphoria, and eventually regretted taking HRT. I had been suicidal for somewhere between two and three years over these fears.
What finally made me decide to detransition was, in hindsight, a bit silly: a nostalgia trip where I was re-listening to Disney songs I loved as a kid, eventually getting to "Tale as Old as Time" from Beauty and the Beast, where somehow everything clicked into place and I started crying. I came to realize I was "a beast trying to look like a beauty," trying to look feminine on the outside to cover up an ugliness I had always felt on the inside. The solution was never to reject masculinity, it was to embrace it — to be a better man than my father.
I was told to seek therapy before detransitioning to make sure it was what I really wanted, but it only lasted two sessions before I decided I'd had enough. The sessions always devolved into me defending my decision to detransition while the therapist pushed me to reconsider — very nasty. I was getting better, and the person intended to help me actively did the opposite.
I also detransitioned in college. I think a lot of people assumed I was ftm trans, and unless I knew them I just didn't bother to correct it; after the semester ended I didn't see most of those people again. Most people won't understand, but those who don't generally take what I say at face value and treat me politely even if things are a bit awkward.
What quieted my dysphoria was never-ending scrutinizing: asking why I wanted to transition, why I still wanted to stay detransitioned, and where the two ideas met. I questioned why I was afraid of puberty — why a rugged face scared me, why going bald — and realized a lot of these fears came from not wanting to age at all, not just aging as a male. Estrogen had helped me keep up a young, happy-go-lucky "Peter Pan" persona that only cared about being nice to others; I liked being cute on the outside because it covered up an ugliness I felt on the inside. Through a fair amount of self reflection I came to conclude the source of my dysphoria wasn't rational, and it stopped hurting me. Most of my dysphoria came from being disgusted with my masculinity and the misalignment of being a generally feminine male; once I decided to embrace my masculinity, there wasn't a reason to feel dysphoria anymore. I no longer consider myself transgender, though I definitely was back then.
I adopted a lot of this mindset from Stoicism — instead of suppressing my dysphoria this time, I decided to let it go. I realized I had no control over myself or my emotions: even though I could pass, I would still always have that cloud of dysphoria over my head, and if someone called me "he," used my old name, or did anything to break this fragile identity I had built up, I would become insecure and upset. I saw that as a weakness. Stoicism became my source of "positive masculinity," though I don't think these ideas are limited to what sex you are.
I now believe transition isn't the only — or dare I say the best — treatment for dysphoria, though that's often hard to see for someone who's dysphoric. I advise others to be honest with themselves about the source of their dysphoria and to elaborate extensively on why it suggests they need HRT, and not to suppress it. I also think validation shouldn't be the first thing you give someone disgusted with their body; I wasn't in my right mind at that time and needed more than a twenty-minute talk. I suspect the sympathy clinicians show does more harm than good to the mental health of their patients.