Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau (FTMTF), die 2019–2020 mit 28/29 über informierte Einwilligung in Kanada 11 Monate lang Testosteron nahm und 2021 aufhörte, als mir das Durchgehen als cis Mann klarmachte, dass ich einen riesigen Fehler gemacht hatte. Später wurden bei mir Autismus Level 1, ADHS und BPS-Züge diagnostiziert, und ich verstehe heute, dass ich autistisches Maskieren und meine autistische Wahrnehmung von Geschlecht mit „Trans-Sein“ verwechselt habe – ich hatte nie echte körperliche Dysphorie. Der bleibendste Effekt ist meine Stimme, die männlich absank und trotz jahrelangen intensiven Stimmtrainings und natürlicher Erholung nur teilweise heller geworden ist; dazu kommen Restgesichtshaare, lockigeres Haar, Wachstum im Genitalbereich und erhebliche Gewichtszunahme. Ich erlebte schweres Leid mit chronischer Suizidalität und einer Zeit, in der ich „sehr suizidal“ war, blieb aber sicher und verletzte mich nicht, und ich sagte, mein ursprünglicher Plan sei gewesen, mich umzubringen, bevor ich einen anderen Weg fand. Fünf Jahre später ist mein Leben größtenteils wieder normal – ich bin in einer guten Beziehung, Leute behandeln mich als Frau, und ich habe mich sowohl von radikaler Trans- als auch von gender-kritischer Ideologie gelöst und setze mich stattdessen für mehr Forschung, nicht-bejahende explorative Therapie und Selbstbestimmung ein.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and grew up in Canada. Looking back, I was an autistic kid who masked heavily from a young age — I 'learned how to mask my traits at a young age' and would 'just smile and nod a lot,' and I now describe the experience as not feeling like other female dogs so I tried to be a male dog, only to realize I was 'actually just a cat all along.' I never had true physical gender dysphoria; what I had was social dysphoria and a feeling of not belonging with other girls. I got deeply involved in Tumblr-era queer/SJW culture, pro-ana-style aesthetics, anime/yaoi fandom, stoner/hipster subcultures, and radical online trans spaces, and I policed other people's pronouns as a they/them, believing that not using my pronouns was 'an act of violence.' I identified as nonbinary for about five years before medical transition.
I medically transitioned at 28 (I was 29 when I started HRT, in 2019–2020). I got testosterone through informed consent in Canada — I told my doctor I had been identifying as nonbinary for five years, and dysphoria was never discussed. I was on a low dose for 11 months, with blood tests every three months. I had a hormonal IUD placed while on T, which was 'the most painful experience of my life.' I never had any surgeries — I 'almost had top surgery before I woke up' and am very thankful for my breasts. On T I had horrible acne on my arms, shoulders, back, and forearms, was very sweaty, had a puffy face initially, and my voice dropped into a clearly male range. I also developed bottom growth.
The turning point came when I finally passed as a cis man and went 'Oh fuck' — 'I finally passed as a cis man and went "Oh my god I fucked up".' I stopped T in 2021, about five months after which I started looking like myself again. My period returned about a month after stopping. Within roughly four months most things feminized: skin softened, smell returned, acne and oiliness went away, fat redistributed. I gained a significant amount of weight from 'eating my feelings,' developed more keratosis pilaris, and got persistent zits on my upper arms. My facial hair mostly faded but some peach fuzz remains, and shaving my neck gave me ingrown hairs that look like acne. My hair became noticeably curlier and I had to change my whole routine. The lasting change that has caused me the most distress is my voice.
I was diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder Level 1 (formerly Asperger's) in September 2022, and later also with ADHD and BPD traits. This diagnosis was the key that unlocked everything: I realized I had misinterpreted autistic masking and my autistic perception of gender as 'transness.' I had been misdiagnosed with 'BPD traits' by a psychiatrist earlier who never assessed me for autism, and I blame the professionals who were 'not educated about autism and never told me I was an autistic woman.' I also later developed what I think is PMDD, which I can't fully untangle from having been on hormonal birth control, then off it during T, and now unable to tolerate hormonal birth control.
My voice has been the central, years-long struggle. It was already androgynous/low female pre-T, and after T it was fully male. I have spent from mid-2022 onward doing intensive voice training — with a local speech-language pathologist, with lessons from Your Lessons Now, Vox Nova/Selene DeSylva, and by studying Trans Voice Lessons on YouTube. I learned the perceptual model focusing on vocal weight and size to achieve vocal fullness, and raising R1 was a breakthrough resource for me. Early on I made mistakes — I constricted my false folds and got a killer sore throat, and the swallow-and-hold method hurt. My voice also lightened naturally in stages: a bit a month or two after stopping T, then a huge difference around 10 months off, and it has continued to lighten over the years. It went from about 120 Hz to consistently 140–150 Hz. For a long time I posted recordings constantly asking people to gender my voice, and I was deeply distressed when strangers assumed I was a trans woman, or when people used they/them pronouns on me without being asked. I was 'called sir repeatedly on the phone' and at one point said I'd 'rather rip my throat out and learn sign language.' I also lost and then regained my singing voice — I used to be a low soprano/alto and now sing in the tenor range, but I can again sing songs I couldn't after stopping T.
The detransition itself was deeply traumatic for me — I said it felt worse than a major car crash I was in, and comparable to abusive relationships or homelessness. I went through a period of about a year where I was smoking a lot of weed, eating my feelings, and crying constantly. I was on medical leave from work, considered going on disability (and I do now receive income support/disability), and had a two-year burnout. I was in therapy but it was 'affirming' therapy, which made things worse; I later found a trauma-specialist therapist who I still see, and I was told I wasn't yet ready for EMDR. I also got into Buddhism and Taoist principles as a way of finding deeper meaning and practicing non-attachment, and I recommend DBT skills and Gabor Mate's work.
After detransitioning I became briefly enmeshed in gender-critical and alt-right spaces — I 'got drawn to radical feminism and later the alt right for a period of time' — and I was steeped in postmodernist theory during my undergrad, which I say 'almost made me literally insane.' I have since stepped back from all of it, recognizing that these sources were 'just as black and white, rigid, and essentializing' as the pro-transition spaces I'd been in. I received threats for voicing my opinions online, which prompted me to stop spreading anger on the internet.
I considered suing my prescribing GP, reasoning that they followed Canadian standards of care but not WPATH standards, and that my autism diagnosis gave me a case. I asked about legal action in Canada generally and shared an article about the first Canadian detrans lawsuit. I also briefly floated the idea of writing a book or essay collection about my detransition and autism diagnosis, and even posted about sex work as a possible income option, though I didn't pursue either seriously.
On sexuality: I now identify as mostly straight, though I'm GNC in some ways. I reflected that transition was partly about feeling sexually free — no longer being 'a woman' — rooted in internalized misogyny and discomfort with my female body being sexualized. I was awkward, into yaoi, loved thinking of myself as a gay man, and loved playing that role in the bedroom, and I wonder if I had autoandrophilia. I've had a positive experience with my genitals after bottom growth — I posted about r/bigclit to reassure other FTMTF women that what they have is within the realm of normal, and noted 'the guys do comment like crazy' which made me feel better.
Dating went from frightening to good. I worried no one would want me because of my voice, acne, and weight, but I eventually entered 'the best relationship I've had in a really long time' with a man who 'can't get enough of me physically despite my major weight gain and a lingering effect of T which is my deeper voice (and also bottom growth).' Coming out as detransitioned to partners has been something I've navigated carefully, wanting to wait until after a few dates.
I have trans friends and I'm semi-active in my local queer community IRL. I don't think trans people are faking it — 'I know trans people who are incredibly happy with their transitions. I don't think they are faking it.' I'm critical of 'militant they/thems' who remind me of my former self and give me a trauma response, and I'm alarmed by figures like Dr. Devon Price. I had a falling out with Buck Angel after he blocked me for disagreeing. I consider myself truscum-adjacent in believing dysphoria is central, but I'm 'not in the space of policing people's gender identities' and believe 'fully consenting adults who know all their conditions and are of sound mind can do what they want.' I think 18 is old enough to consent to transgender surgeries, and I'm anti-ban and pro-self-determination, while wanting far more research, safeguards, and non-affirming exploratory therapy first. My advice to people considering T is blunt: 'PAUSE AND REFLECT. DO NOT TAKE MORE UNTIL YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY SURE,' and to only pursue medical transition if you have severe, persistent dysphoria based specifically on your secondary sex characteristics — 'If I was alone on an island, would I still have distress over my body?'
Today, at 33, my life is largely back to normal. I completed a program catered to autistic individuals and did a work placement. I have a master's degree. I'm in a good relationship, I've rebuilt my social world after what I call 'social suicide,' and I've generally reconciled with my body. My voice is still slightly deeper than it was, and I don't actively use my trained voice day to day, but people confidently treat me as a woman. The last time I was misgendered was in the summer before this update, and I think that person just wasn't paying attention. A woman at work even told me she loved my voice. I've stopped really caring about passing and focus on the richness of the rest of my life.