Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Butch-Frau, weiblich geboren, die sich etwa von 19 bis 24 als trans identifizierte und um 2020 desistierte. Ich hatte eine Top-Operation, ohne je Testosteron genommen zu haben, und bereue sie nicht, hörte aber vor den Hormonen auf, nachdem ich extreme internalisierte Misogynie und religiöses Trauma als Triebkräfte meiner Transition erkannt hatte. Seit dem Desistieren kämpfe ich trotz Therapie, Sport und vieler Bewältigungsstrategien mit schwerer, anhaltender Depression und Unsicherheit und plante, es mit Medikamenten zu versuchen. Ich bin in einer Beziehung mit einer Freundin, habe gelegentlich noch Bottom-Dysphorie und bin kritisch gegenüber der Online-Trans-Kultur, während ich anderen rate, Traumata zu klären, bevor sie transitionieren.
Vollständige Geschichte
I desisted somewhere around 2020 after identifying as trans for about four years, from roughly age 19 to 24. I'm now 25. I was born female, and I'm a masculine, butch lesbian — only into women. My current status is complicated: I describe myself as kind of desisted, kind of detrans, but I've reverted to the label 'butch' because it fits me best. I'm still androgynous and I still get occasional bottom dysphoria, but I don't plan to progress any further with transition.
The only medical steps I took were top surgery and no hormones. I had top surgery without ever going on testosterone — I had wanted it since puberty hit, waited 12 years, and genuinely tried to see if I could manage without it before going ahead. I don't regret the top surgery at all; my chest dysphoria was constant and unending, present even when I was alone, unlike my other forms of dysphoria which fluctuated with my hormones. I had made preemptive peace with the possibility of regret. I did not go the 'unusual transition route' — people, mostly other trans people, gave me shit for it, but I'm glad I stuck to my guns because I'd be in deep regret now. I was pretty much my own doctor for most of it. I have a tattoo dedicated to my transition that isn't subtle.
What moved me toward desisting was a combination of things. Part was overcompensating for top dysphoria — on a subconscious level I didn't think people would understand my chest symptoms. The bigger factor was extreme internalized misogyny: a hatred toward women as a whole that bubbled to the surface and was visceral, the worst hatred I'd ever felt. The irony wasn't lost on me and made me realize that hatred I was projecting outward had at some point been turned inward, which stopped my transitioning plans in their tracks. There was probably a twinge of internalized homophobia too, but less prominent. Being a very masculine woman probably fed into the misogyny. I also had religious trauma: I was raised evangelical, fundie-lite, and ex-Christian, and being a woman, masculine, and lesbian mixed poorly with that upbringing. My symptoms didn't manifest until middle school, which was exactly when my family turned fundie-lite. I wonder how I'd have turned out without that damage.
I also realized my transition 'wasn't because of some inner truth but an inner hate.' I had dysphoria specifically linked to physical strength — I value being physically strong, and that was one of the only motivators for going on T. Once I started strength training five days a week, a lot of that 'dysphoria' vanished, and I realized I didn't need T to be strong. Top surgery also opened the door for me to be comfortable in my body and rethink further transition.
I went to therapy and processed what I thought needed processing, but by July 2021 I was in a deep pit of insecurity and depression, writing that after all the work I was 'still that same insecure dysphoric mother fucker.' I tried self-harm, transitioning, drinking, weed, burying myself in work, seeking outside and internal approval, cleaning up my diet, working out, being spiritual, being an atheist, going red pill, being a feminist — everything people said should help — and the dysphoria still came back every day. I said I was going to try medication but doubted it would help. I've struggled with depression and anxiety, and I asked someone about PMDD, suggesting I may have dealt with it. I've used THC (edibles, in a legal state) which muted my dysphoria even before transition and helped my depression and anxiety; I theorized some of my dysphoria was anxiety-based or chemical. I had a strong edible experience where I felt like I was traveling through the fifth dimension experiencing the universe as fractals. I wanted to try meditation and shrooms but hadn't yet.
On adversity: I was raised in a misogynistic environment, not the worst but damaging, and it had a negative impact on me. I've dealt with religious trauma. I've used self-harm at some point. I described my dysphoria as having damaged my personal life, ruining relationships and making me push people away.
Socially, I have a girlfriend (a lesbian) and have dated around without issues in the wlw community; I mostly date bi women otherwise. I have trans/lgbt friends irl. I found the online trans/lgbt community authoritarian and abusive — 'the same authoritarian bullshit I left Christianity over' — and left lgbt groups even while still trans because they didn't have my best interests at heart. I'm critical of transition for others: I think people should sort out trauma and mental health concerns (asd, ocd, anxiety, depression) first, be wary of internalized misogyny and homophobia, and start with the least invasive solution. I believe dysphoria can be misread body dysmorphia or trauma, and I advise journaling, self-knowledge, and putting down labels. I'm frustrated by society's laser-beamed focus on sex/gender and by social contagion/nocebo effects, which I compare to the self-harm contagion I grew up with. I don't regret my top surgery, but I regret the transition identity itself and the years lost to it; the depression and insecurity around it were still severe as of mid-2021.