Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die nie medizinisch transitioniert ist; ich bin um 25 desistiert, nachdem meine Dysphorie, die mit 20–22 am stärksten war, mit der Zeit, mit Therapie gegen Depression und Angst ab 2013 und der Konzentration auf mein Informatikstudium verblasste. Mein Transitionswunsch wurde von mobbingbedingtem Selbsthass, einer Essstörung, Yaoi-besessenen Freundinnen und einer Ex, die mich zu einem „süßen schwulen Jungen“ drängte, sowie von Internet-Bestätigung für maskulines Auftreten getrieben. Mein Therapeut ließ mich versprechen, nichts Irreversibles zu tun, bis meine Depression geklärt sei, und mein jetziger Freund half mir, meinen Körper so zu lieben, wie er ist. Als ich desistierte, wurde ich von der trans Community ausgegrenzt, aber heute mit 27 geht es mir viel besser, und ich identifiziere mich als Frau in einem nicht-identitären Sinn. Ich trete für Vorsicht, Therapie und die Behandlung der Ursachen vor einer medizinischen Transition ein, unterstütze aber eine angemessen diagnostizierte Transition bei schwerer Dysphorie.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and grew up in France. Looking back, my first real trouble with how I felt about myself started in my early teens: I struggled to feel pretty, largely because of constant bullying once kids in secondary school started caring about looks. They attacked me based on my looks, and although I know I wasn't ugly, I became obsessed, developed an eating disorder, and felt like "some sort of monster" — I couldn't look at myself in the mirror without crying. I have thin, curly hair that nobody taught me to take care of; cutting and straightening it at 15 gave me a tomboyish look, but I actually felt cute then.
I stopped using Tumblr around 2013, when I was about 19, because I could see my depression was being exacerbated by it. I realized something was off when people would tell me I couldn't really be depressed and yet I still had the energy to get up and go to college every day.
My strongest feelings about transitioning came between 20 and 22. I had friends and an ex (who later came out as FTM) who were heavily into anime boys' love (yaoi); they treated me as a "cute little gay boy" and, in my early twenties, pushed me toward transition to become a man. The first time I got positive attention about my looks was when I presented tomboyish and people would "he/him" me on the internet, even those who knew I was a teenage girl. My ex would fantasize about us being gay men and starved me of love and physical attention because I wasn't enough — because I wasn't a man. That made me believe I was a solid 7-to-8 as a man and a 2-at-most as a woman, which I now call utter bullshit.
I went to therapy with a psychologist, starting around 2013, who was not into all this gender stuff and made me promise not to do anything irreversible to my body until I sorted out my depression first. He convinced me to address my depression and anxiety before making such important decisions about my body, and that helped me enormously. I never started hormones and never had any surgery; I desisted from transition instead.
What actually helped me realize I wasn't trans was finding another goal to focus on — my studies. I entered the studies I really wanted (computer science), even though people tried to take me away from it because it was seen as a male job, and I realized how pointlessly gendered that was. I made my best friends by helping my community and volunteering in my town, made lots of friends through dog sitting, learned to cook healthy and take care of my body as it is, and discovered hiking, a physical activity I love. Focusing on my studies helped me a lot in my desisting process. My dysphoria faded as I grew up: it started fading at 23 and completely disappeared at 25 and beyond.
My current boyfriend also saved me from this nonsense. He helped me appreciate my true self by telling me he thought I was beautiful, that I didn't need to transition to be attractive to his eyes, that I didn't need makeup, that any hair length suited me, that hairy legs didn't make me gross or unwomanly, that I was beautiful as a tomboy and also in skirts, and that I could be either gender-conforming or gender-nonconforming without submitting to medication for life or surgery. He helped me get out of communities where gender was at the center of everything and learn to love myself. When I met him I was already in the process of desisting but had a hard time being called by my birth name, because of its connotations of bullying and poor self-worth; I went by a diminutive of my name for a while, and a few years later re-adopted my full name, grew to like it, and reattached myself to my identity.
The social cost was real. I had a seemingly solid group of friends — some of them trans people and my ex — who turned their back on me and started tweeting things like "cis people are disappointing, they are no longer my friends" when I said I wasn't sure I was trans and didn't want to go into hormones, let alone anything further. I have never been abandoned by my goth or metalhead friends when I changed hobbies, nor by gay friends when I started a straight relationship, but I was automatically ostracized by the trans community when I dared to desist. I knew trans people mostly in real life and they were like the internet ones: insisting you are in the wrong body, setting high expectations for transition, and shunning me when I decided to desist. Friends who disappear if you detransition are not friends.
Today, at 27, I feel so much better since I stopped caring about how other people think of me. I am a woman, but not in a gender-identity way — I just accepted what nature gave me and learned to like it. I live with my boyfriend; we equally share chores, play video games, watch the same YouTubers, and we are both software developers working with the same programming language. I resemble my cis male partner far more than my female peers, but that doesn't make me a man — it makes me my own person. I don't have any dysphoria now: I have learned to love myself as I am and find my place in the world by just being me. I've also helped run a French-speaking Discord for French desisted/detrans people.
I'm now critical of how quickly some people get hormonal therapy and surgery, especially on young people, and I predict a wave of detransitioners in a few years. I think the marketing around puberty blockers, which many people claim have no permanent effects, is sickening. I believe anyone with even a glimpse of doubt about regretting transition should wait and not do anything irreversible yet, sort out underlying mental health issues first, and shift their attention to career, hobbies, friends, and skills. I also think 100% affirmation is not what a good friend does — support doesn't equal affirmation — and that vulnerable people deserve questioning, wariness, patience, and support rather than reflexive affirmation. At the same time, I don't think of transition as poison when it's used appropriately for crippling gender dysphoria after therapy and hormone therapy haven't helped; my objection is to it being used as a first resort. I also push back against internalized misogyny in detrans spaces and internalized misandry in trans spaces, and I try to encourage people to filter out toxic content about how awful men or women supposedly are.