Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin Hausarzt und HIV-Spezialist in Detroit, biete sowohl Transitions- als auch Detransitionsversorgung an und verstehe mich als Fürsprecher der Detransitionsversorgung, nicht selbst als Detransitionierter. In etwa elf Jahren habe ich rund 3.000–4.000 Transgender-Patienten behandelt, und ich helfe offen Menschen bei der Detransition – inzwischen ein bis zwei pro Monat, vor zehn Jahren noch etwa eine pro Jahr. Ich bin Autist mit ADHS und PTBS nach einer Tragödie 2017, und ich habe selbst keine Geschlechtsdysphorie. Ich empfinde erhebliche Schuld und seelische Qual wegen Patienten, denen ich womöglich geschadet habe, und sage, dass es mich nachts wachhält, dem falschen Teenager HRT gegeben zu haben. Ich vertrete eine gemäßigte Position, dass Transition für manche richtig und für andere falsch ist, und erforsche aktiv nichthormonelle Ursachen von Geschlechtsdysphorie.
Vollständige Geschichte
I am a family physician and HIV specialist based in Detroit who has spent about eleven years providing hormone therapy to transgender patients — roughly 3,000 to 4,000 of them — and I am, as far as I know, the only doctor in the United States who openly provides detransition care without judgment. I first posted on this subreddit in July 2020, after anti-trans subreddits were being banned, to say that this community should exist and that I had followed it carefully to keep my screening of patients rigorous. I returned with a longer post in April 2023 explaining why I was there.
I am autistic — I describe myself as 'autistic as fuck' — with ADHD, myopia, PTSD from a fire in 2017 in which I lost everything and nearly my life, and I carry a family history of schizophrenia and Hashimoto's thyroiditis. I have no gender dysphoria myself. I was raised by a military father, and I believe that background, plus being in the 100th percentile for testosterone production alleles, is why I didn't develop dysphoria despite carrying many of the genetic variants I associate with it. As a teenager I went through a phase of dressing as a skater boy because I was autistic, didn't fit in, and didn't know how to dress normally — I've said I don't know what would have happened to me if someone in this generation had told me that meant I must be transgender.
My path into this work was not political. I started providing transition care when a patient in residency asked me and had already completed the requisites, and I kept acquiring patients because I treated them like human beings. I developed my own HRT techniques, trained about fifteen other doctors, and hold board certification in HIV medicine (AAHIVM), which I have recertified. I run my own private practice — a family practice with therapy cats and exam rooms themed around video games and anime — capped at twenty patients a day. I got into crypto in 2012, so money is not my motivation; I say this is my vocation and the only thing that gives me purpose.
What brought me here repeatedly is distress about what I see happening. About two to three percent of my practice detransitions, and while that sounds small, ten years ago I detransitioned maybe one person a year and now I'm doing one to two per month. I've said that detransitioning people is causing me 'a lot of mental anguish and stress,' that 'a little piece of me inside dies' every time a patient tells me psychiatry got it wrong, and that giving the wrong teenager HRT 'keeps me up at night.' I've described my desire to help here as a kind of 'psychological opiate' to ease the guilt of knowing some patients were hurt by me. I published a paper on restoring fertility in people who have been on hormones — claiming the first ever — and I'm working on a theory I call Meyer-Powers syndrome, which I believe links gender dysphoria to MTHFR mutations and a cluster of associated conditions (ADHD, autism, POTS, hypermobility, Ehlers-Danlos, Hashimoto's, IBS, myopia, MCAS). I started myself on L-methylfolate and methylcobalamin and said my mental health was vastly better within a week.
In practice I try to correct underlying endocrine or metabolic abnormalities before anyone starts cross-sex hormones, offering androgen blockade or hormone normalization first; I've said about half of the teens who try it feel better and decide not to transition. I gatekeep heavily, require psychiatric assessment, and hold a mandatory appointment with me before any irreversible surgery where I walk patients through every complication I've ever seen. When patients do detransition, I help them medically — clomiphene to reboot the gonads, bicalutamide or spironolactone to block androgens, SERMs, anastrozole, referrals for vocal feminization surgery, FFS, breast reconstruction, and topical estrogen for atrophy. I've said I've 'gotten rather good at it.'
I've been called transphobic, a Nazi, and accused of conversion therapy and genocide for suggesting gender dysphoria can sometimes be treated without transition; I've been banned from a transgender clinicians' group for suggesting topical testosterone to preserve genital development in blocked MTF teens. My uncle won't speak to me because I treat trans kids. Some detrans organizations won't speak to me either because I still transition people. I've been threatened with lawsuits and threatened to sue over what I called defamatory pages on a website. I've had patients hug me and sob saying they'd be dead without transition, and I've had patients tell me they made a mistake — including one young local girl whose therapist had forged all her documentation, a mistake I learned from. I once blocked a tween girl from hormones who wanted to transition only after her brother died eating a death cap mushroom; she wanted to replace him in the family, and she is now a well-adjusted adult.
My position is deliberately moderate: transition is right for some people and wrong for others, the truth lies in the middle, and both the strongly pro-transition and strongly anti-transition camps are wrong. I believe in bodily autonomy — 'we own our own meat sacks' — and I'm against compulsory medical intervention generally. I've said I would welcome any former patient back, would see them for free, and that if I saw one at YoumaCon I would want to give them a hug and tell them I'm sorry things worked out the way they did. I keep showing up here because I believe my presence, even when it draws hostility, helps me learn to do less harm.