Alle Geschichten

Dysphorie nach einem Trauma, nicht vom Mädchensein

Weiblich · DetransitioniertErste Dysphorie 17 → Transition 17 → Detransition 201418
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin eine detransitionierte, bisexuelle Frau. Mit 17 habe ich sozial transitioniert, nur etwa einen Monat lang Testosteron genommen und bin um meinen 20. Geburtstag herum desistiert. Meine Dysphorie entstand nach einem traumatischen, aber nicht geschlechtsbezogenen Ereignis in der Highschool, vor dem Hintergrund der schweren unbehandelten psychischen Erkrankung meiner Mutter, Mobbing in der Kindheit, einer in Ekel wurzelnden Essstörung und Selbsthass ab 12. Zur Detransition hat mich die Erkenntnis bewegt, dass meine Dissoziation und die Entfremdung von mir selbst – meine Therapeutin vermutet eine Depersonalisations-/Derealisationsstörung – größer waren als jede Entfremdung von meinem biologischen Geschlecht, dazu kam der Beginn von Zoloft gegen Angst und die Belastung meiner Eltern. An manchen Tagen habe ich noch Dysphorie und Dissoziation, habe mich selbst verletzt und mich in Suizidgedanken hineingesteigert, aber es geht mir heute viel besser, und es war eine riesige Erleichterung, dass mein Vater im Juni 2021 mein Desistieren akzeptiert hat. Ich unterstütze Transition für manche Erwachsene, lehne aber medizinische Transition und Pubertätsblocker für Minderjährige entschieden ab, und ich setze mich für mehr gesellschaftliche Gespräche darüber ein, Geschlechtsdysphorie zu haben und sich gegen eine Transition zu entscheiden.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born female and grew up in the American South and Midwest, attending public elementary school and then private, all-girls middle and high school, graduating in 2019. I was a feminine child, but I remember being confused early on about the lines being drawn between me and my brother — I couldn't spit on the ground, couldn't go out without a bra, wasn't allowed a waist size bigger than 30, had to shave my legs and armpits or it was called a "hygiene concern," couldn't take a girl to prom, and had to wear a dress and heels to dinners where my brother wore a polo and chinos. My home life was difficult. My mother was severely mentally ill for most of my childhood — depressed, anxious, paranoid — and my father, who traveled for work about half the time, didn't realize how bad it was until much later. My mother told me routinely that I was fat, lazy, that people didn't like my personality or my laugh, and she doesn't remember saying any of it. When I asked her for a therapist around age 14, she described in detail how she wanted to kill herself too, telling me "you don't see ME telling YOU that" to hush me up. I was suicidal starting at 12 — before I even knew what sex was. I couldn't bathe myself properly until I was 13. I was academically far ahead of my peers but socially incompetent, and I was bullied badly enough to be pushed out of my middle school. I developed an eating disorder in high school and once fainted during choir from not eating enough. My eating disorder was rooted in disgust — a deep disgust with my body and reflection, an innate disgust toward many foods (especially reheated food or food in containers), and a dark fear of sexuality, not in vanity. I came out to my mother as a lesbian at 15 (I now identify as bisexual), and she was furious and fought with me about it repeatedly; my father initially called it a phase. I came out to her as bisexual multiple times as a 14- and 15-year-old and she denied it each time. In my junior year of high school, my mother was hospitalized in a mental facility for a week in an emergency; I told no one and isolated myself the entire following summer. That was also when I developed gender dysphoria. My high school graduation required all girls to wear white dresses; I yelled at my parents afterward and burst into tears, and my mother responded by hugging me and giving me cake. I began questioning my gender at age 17. I socially transitioned, using he/him pronouns and coming out to friends, family, and people at college as a trans guy. I never changed my name because it is gender neutral. I started testosterone but was only on it for about a month before stopping, because my parents were so upset after I came out to them that I couldn't justify continuing. The appointment and initial dose alone cost me upwards of $400 because my insurance refused to cover it. I experienced no medical changes from the month on T. I desisted around my 20th birthday. During my social transition I was treated badly in both conservative and ostensibly liberal settings — people called me "it," classmates gave me looks of confusion and disgust, and I overheard a floormate telling friends there was "this weird girl always in the gender neutral bathroom" (about me). I had anxiety attacks before the once-a-term sexual assault prevention lectures where everyone was made to state their pronouns. I avoided clubs and parties for fear of being asked my pronouns. I also had a predatory man who fixated on me specifically because I identified as a trans guy — he followed transmasc and nonbinary TikTokers, would convince transmascs online to send him nudes, and would ask me to describe my chest dysphoria. I did things with him I regret. His (trans) boyfriend, when I told him what happened, said no one had ever really seen me as a man. What ultimately moved me toward detransition was a combination of things. I realized my dysphoria was occasional and connected to broader body dysmorphias — I wanted to be skinnier (I had an eating disorder when younger), taller (I walked on my toes from a young age), and I wanted a male body, but recognized those as wants rather than needs. My parents encouraged me to start anti-depressants before doing anything else, and those eventually helped my mood. I was sick of the social weirdness. I was sick of being obsessed with my appearance. And I realized I didn't actually care about gender — being called "woman" or "she" wasn't something I loved, but neither was being called "man" or "he"; it was irrelevant. Ultimately, thoughts and anxieties about passing and my identity were ruining my life far more than being a woman ever had. A crucial realization was that my problem was bigger than a disconnect with my biological sex — it was a disconnect with myself and my life. My therapist believes I have depersonalization/derealization disorder alongside my anxiety; she has also floated high-functioning autism, which scares me, though both my therapist and my boyfriend have noted I share some traits with high-functioning autism. I have sensory processing issues similar to those with autism but they don't stop me from functioning if I'm allowed to dress and work and eat as I want. I have frequent dissociative episodes, sometimes for no reason. I've always felt I was playing a role rather than acting like myself. When people say "she" or my name, I feel a disconnect, as if they're speaking about someone else — but I felt the same disconnect with "he," which was part of why I decided against medical transition. I don't see my body as being mine; it's just an attractive body I'm in. The only positive way I can view my body is sexually — "Wow, I'm hot" or "Wow, I'm skinny" — otherwise I get feelings of "This is a nice body, but it is not my body" or "This is a horrible, ugly body." Being reminded of my female biology either deeply upsets me or turns me on. I believe my mother's mental illness and my childhood contributed to my gender dysphoria, which is a major reason I decided not to transition. Other contributors I've identified include internalized homophobia and misogyny, an irrational fear of men, disordered eating, extreme body dysmorphia, untreated mental illness, dissociation, and self-loathing. I had immense self-loathing starting at age 12. I also had a phase where I was afraid to leave the house — going to CVS felt physically painful — because I hated myself and was certain everyone who saw me thought I was a freak. Practically, what I did to handle my dysphoria was: go to therapy (my therapist, in a conservative part of the U.S., was neutral on transition); get on anti-anxiety medication (100mg of Zoloft, which works because my mother is on it too; I had a bad reaction to Buspar); exercise more and eat better to feel more control over my body; present more masculinely (men's clothes, sports bras to flatten my chest — real binders hurt so I don't use them, I never packed, and I never wear "real" bras); stop doing things that make me dysphoric (hookups, dresses); and practice radical acceptance, looking in the mirror and telling myself the body is mine to care for. I also worked on removing my self-loathing through therapy, friends, family, hobbies, and work. I came out as detrans/desisted to my friends — most of them LGBT — and they were completely supportive when I told them I was going back to "she/her." I still had to un-come-out to college friends who'd spent two years thinking I was a trans guy, which made me nauseous. The thing I regret most about my transition is telling my parents — not because they kicked me out, but because of the humiliating conversations and the emotional pain I caused them and myself for what I see as my own mistake. I pride myself on being smart, so being proven wrong by my parents was painful. However, in June 2021 my father came to me and asked for an "update"; I told him I'd realized I'd always had an unhealthy relationship with my body and shouldn't change it because of that. He told me he and my mom had always been impressed by my resilience and intelligence, that he'd support me no matter what, and that even though I'm female I don't have to wear dresses or do anything stereotypical. That conversation relieved an enormous weight — I'd been dreading un-coming-out to everyone, and knowing my parents were behind me made me feel I could face anything. I currently use "she/her" pronouns — not because I like "she" (I don't, and I definitely don't like "they"), but because "he" made my dysphoria worse and made people treat me weird, and "she" is what people default to given my high-pitched voice. I consider myself female and check "female" on forms, but I don't love calling myself a woman; I think gender is a broken categorization system and no definition of "man" or "woman" will ever be fully correct. I describe myself as a masculine woman or "butch-adjacent" but don't fully claim the butch label since I'm bi and dating a man. I dress androgynously, keep my hair short, don't wear makeup, and don't force myself to like shopping or dresses. I still experience dysphoria. Some days I wake up and don't know whose body I'm in; some days I deeply want to be a man, some days I don't. I have good days where I'm happy to be a woman and bad days where I want to crawl out of my body or hurt myself. I have self-harmed and obsessed about suicide and my gender. I was genuinely suicidal when I was identifying as trans, convinced that if I told anyone, they'd think I was manipulative. I'm much better now. My dissociation improved somewhat with anti-depressants and anti-anxiety meds but did not fade to a fully normal level. My eating disorder has been rearing its head again lately. I also had a car wreck not long ago that sent me to the ER. Sexually, I'm bisexual. I had my first kiss at 18, lost my virginity at 19, and began my first relationship, which ended a month later when I was dumped. I was in a friends-with-benefits situation for about two years with a straight cis guy I'd met while identifying as trans — we dated for a month, stopped partly because he was straight, and remained best friends who hook up intermittently. He was understanding about my dysphoria and made me feel it could be handled by talking through it rather than medical transition, though he supported medical transition if I wanted it. He waited patiently until I was ready for PIV sex, which I mostly do for his sake because I have to dissociate for it; I've also penetrated him, which I enjoy because I can be present in my body during it. He always asks before touching my chest. I'm currently dating a man (my boyfriend) — a hetero relationship even though I dress "like a boy." Sex in a female body is very difficult for me; I dissociate and feel "on the wrong side of it," and I've had sexual situations that were skin-crawling because I felt so detached. I've come to peace with the fact that my body brings enjoyment to others when I trust someone, but I hope to one day be fully present for sex. I'm now 20 years old. I go to a very good college and am incredibly insecure about my intelligence as a result of being a "gifted" child who was bullied out of middle school for being too smart. I'm a long-distance runner. I work a remote job. I got an off-campus apartment with my best friend so I won't have to use community bathrooms. My social circle is mostly lesbians and straight guys — my closest friends are a straight guy and a lesbian. I became inexplicably popular at college after being an outcast in high school. On transition for others: I still believe transition is right for some people and don't want to deny them their happiness. I'm supportive of trans people's rights and respect. However, I'm strongly opposed to puberty blockers and medical transition for minors — I wouldn't even be opposed to banning puberty blockers outright, believing there isn't enough science and that nobody is being unbiased; I think the bar should be incredibly high before altering kids' bodies, and that kids need therapy and support instead. I believe society should allow far more self-expression outside the gender binary, and that if we did, far fewer people would transition. I've also come to see that some kids who transition are gender non-conforming, gay, lonely, or unsupported and will become happier in their skin as they grow up — that's what happened to me. I'm critical of figures like Abigail Shrier, whom I see as a grifter who mocks her subjects and never advocates for GNC women, and I'm frustrated that high-profile critics of transition often reinforce the same gender-essentialist narratives that made me want to transition in the first place. I'm wary of radfem biological essentialism and of "egg culture" and "social contagion" framing that dismisses GNC youth. I've advocated for detransitioners having a voice, for a larger societal conversation about having gender dysphoria and choosing not to transition, and I've been active in this community, offering support and sharing my story. I also started a Gender & Sexuality Alliance at my all-girls high school, though administration restricted what we could do.