Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein dem Detransitionieren nahestehender... nein – ich bin eine klinische Sozialarbeiterin und 36-jährige bisexuelle Frau, die nie transitioniert ist, aber sagt, dass sie sich wahrscheinlich gefragt hätte, ob sie trans ist, wäre sie im letzten Jahrzehnt Teenager gewesen. Ich habe nie Hormone genommen und keine OP-Geschichte, lebe aber mit erheblichem Unbehagen an Brust und Körper, das der Dysphorie ähnelt, und arbeite durch Therapie und EMDR-Ausbildung an Selbstakzeptanz. Ich lehne das rein bejahende Versorgungsmodell und Geschlechtsidentität als Konzept ab, verweise Klienten aber wegen des beruflichen Risikos weiter an bejahende Kliniker. Ich bilde mich in Trauma, Dissoziation, EMDR und IFS weiter, damit ich Menschen bei der Genesung helfen kann, falls sich das Blatt wendet. Ich bleibe eine Frau, die geschlechtsbezogene Stereotype ablehnt und sich dafür einsetzt, sie abzubauen.
Vollständige Geschichte
I am a clinical social worker — a therapist — and I'm female. I'm 36 years old as of March 2020, and I've been a therapist long enough to be fully licensed, though I'm not in private practice and can't afford to take the professional risks that outspoken gender-critical therapists like Sasha Ayad and Lisa Marchiano can. I'm bi, and I'm married to a straight man who has long hair almost down to his nipples; I have a very short pixie cut. I wear makeup maybe twice a year at most, dresses or skirts a couple of times a month, mostly comfy pants and flannel or sweaters, and no heels except when I go latin dancing about once a month, where I do wear makeup and girly dresses. I have a low female voice — I recorded a clip for someone comparing our voices — and I've never been on hormones. I'm a 30E with what my mom called "birthing hips," and I never want to give birth, though I love kids.
I have never identified as trans, but I've said openly that if I had been a teen sometime in the last decade, I probably would have wondered whether I was trans too, because trans issues weren't a thing when I was a teen — we were just girly girls, butch, tomgirls, "athletic types," goth girls, skater girls. I don't know if what I experience would count as dysphoria, because the term wasn't something I knew existed until recently. What I do know is that I still struggle to accept and appreciate my breasts and my curves. The discomfort is a feeling of disconnect and disgust — like my breasts don't belong on my body and they are gross. I never considered not having them, because that wasn't an option when I was younger, so I've worked hard not to focus on them: I wear short necklaces so attention goes to my neck rather than my chest, I don't look at my chest and my face in the mirror at the same time, and I'm most uncomfortable when my husband focuses on them or when I'm in bed, since I'm a side sleeper and feel them more. I've worked hard to define myself by what my body does rather than what it is — "I'm not my breasts or hips. I am a person who does awesome things and is worthy and lovable." It takes time, work, patience, therapy, and I'm still working at it.
As a young adult I played a game with myself while people-watching: for each person I'd ask whether I thought they were ugly, and I'd usually find something to like — big ears, pimples, weight paired with great style. Only 1–2% were people who plainly didn't care for themselves. Then I'd imagine other people playing that game about me. It didn't fix my self-esteem, but it stopped me worrying about how others saw me, because I'd started looking at myself the way I looked at others.
Professionally, I don't believe hormones and surgeries should be treatment for mental illness, and I don't write letters — but I'm obligated to refer clients to someone who does if that's what they want, and I know the same is true in medicine. I can't advertise that I don't do affirmation therapy because I risk losing my jobs, clients, reputations, and perhaps my license; some professional organizations suggest that non-affirmative therapy for trans people is conversion therapy. So the only thing I can do is tell people with gender identity issues that I don't feel I have the right training to help them and refer them on — knowing they'll land with an affirmation therapist, which sucks. I've said that if someone came to me specifically because they had gender issues and said outright they didn't want to be affirmed, I would honestly still worry about treating them, because we're in a culture of witch-hunters right now. I hope people start seeing that soon and change course.
Instead I'm training as hard as I can in trauma, dissociation, and body image — I'm being trained in EMDR and starting to look at Internal Family Systems as a treatment for gender dysphoria — because I have a feeling the tides will turn and there will be a lot of people needing therapy to recover from the damage they've done to themselves, and I want to be ready to help openly when that happens. I've described how the mental health world is slowly discovering how big a role trauma plays — trauma meaning "any event that caused a survival response," not just the big things — and how dissociation can play a huge role in gender dysphoria. I've recommended EMDR to people asking about dysphoria, explaining it targets memories tied to negative beliefs and reprocesses them with bilateral stimulation, and pointed them to emdr.com and psychologytoday.com to find a qualified clinician. I've also recommended Michael Pollan's "How to Change Your Mind" on psychedelics, noting his advice to work with an experienced guide rather than try them alone; I've never tried mushrooms or any psychedelic myself.
I'm critical of current trans culture for reinforcing society's gender norms and making it seem like anyone who doesn't fit those norms is likely trans. I've worked with tons of young children and they nearly all like sparkly things, playing in the dirt, role-playing with kitchen sets and tool sets, regardless of sex. I definitely don't believe in gender identities — male and female are physical states, nothing else — and I've been a long-time advocate for slowly breaking down traditional sex-based roles and expectations. I'm a female who likes camping and bugs and grilling and bourbon neat and flannel, and also crafts and Disney movies and skirts and baking and everything purple; that doesn't make me non-binary or gender fluid, it makes me a balanced woman. I think the whole concept of gender identities doubles down on the idea that things, sports, clothing, even emotions belong to one sex or the other, and that makes me sad. I hate the word "cis." I've told people experimenting with their masculine and feminine sides to just do it, that being a woman is not a set of stereotypes, and that you can be a girl, woman, however you want to be. I've also encouraged people to be compassionate to their body after assault — "Your body is the victim, not the perpetrator" — and noted that men are also sexually assaulted and women can also be strong.