Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Person, die sich zeitweise selbst medikamentiert hat und heute über das Stigma schreibt, das mit Detransition verbunden ist. Ich glaube, dass Trans-Sein gültig, aber sehr selten ist, und erwarte in den kommenden Jahrzehnten eine wachsende Welle von Detransitionen, wenn der internetgetriebene Anstieg der 2010er abklingt. Ich bin nicht gender-kritisch und lehne Kampagnen ab, die Menschen ihre Verschreibungen wegnehmen wollen, schätze aber, eine Bandbreite an Standpunkten ohne reflexhafte Feindseligkeit lesen zu können. Ich beschreibe mich als einsamer, seit ich Trans-Online-Räume verlassen habe, und bereue, nicht vor der Transition hinterfragt zu haben. Ich identifiziere mich derzeit als detransitioniert und wünsche mir, dass die Gründe Detransitionierter respektiert und nicht als Angriff auf Transmenschen behandelt werden.
Vollständige Geschichte
I came to this community to vent after seeing a hugely popular review of a mainstream movie on a well-known movie review site that read the film as discrediting detrans people. I don't doubt the film's pro-freedom-to-be-trans message, but interpreting it as an attack on detransitioners 'boggles the mind' — and the fact that the review had over 1000 likes with little pushback made me feel 'nauseous about where we're going.'
I'm not a regular contributor here, and I don't gain a whole lot from the space in general, but I felt I had to say something. What I value about this subreddit is that people are free to talk and question without stigma — you can engage with people holding all sorts of viewpoints on transness, the kind of views that cliquey trans group chats would 'flip the fuck out over,' but nobody here will. That's refreshing, and it lets you come to your own conclusions because everyone is coming from a different place. I don't think it's cultish, since the subreddit hosts dozens of different branches and definitions of 'detrans,' and I still don't personally know another detrans person by name. By contrast, a lot of trans Twitter rhetoric wouldn't hold up if it didn't have hundreds or thousands of mutual followers backing it up. I expect many of us here are actively lonelier for refusing to be influenced by those people anymore — that's definitely the case for me.
I want to be clear that I'm not a gender-critical person, though I know there are plenty of those people here. I have no interest in campaigns to stop people's prescriptions — as a former self-medder, I know nobody's going to stop you if you're convinced it's what's right for you. But I'm glad I can now read those viewpoints without shouting them down in the reactionary, reflexive way that basically all explicitly pro-trans spaces do. I'm unsure whether this is a great place for questioning people to come, or whether there's a reason they were drawn here to ask things rather than somewhere else and are saving themselves a lot of future regrets. I wish I'd done that myself, really.
None of us should sit and accept 'detrans' becoming the dirty word it is in many circles. It's really foul that a review with 1000 likes tramples on the reasons behind our decision-making.
I do think more and more people will be detransitioning over the next decade or two, and it will hopefully become more accepted by then. I personally firmly believe that transness is a valid thing — the first time I met a trans woman was actually in 1997, long before Twitter or most online forums — but very, very rare. The hugely internet- and community-influenced spike of them in the 2010s cannot and will not last forever. The bubble will burst, and people will have to deal with that and have similar regrets that we have. In the meantime I just wish fewer people were acting like us detransitioners existing 'throws trans people under the bus.' It would make life a lot easier on us all.
Part of me would like to speak with a person who is currently trans about this issue and get to the bottom of some of their paranoia about detrans people existing, and why some wish to discredit the whole thing because a percentage of us go down the 'gender critical' route. I doubt the OP of that Letterboxd review would care to answer me, and I know it would just be another depressing Twitter thread filled with abuse, so I guess it's better that we're segregated off like this.
On the biggest fear when trans: 100%. Back then, once I'd decided I was brave enough to face any backlash from being visibly trans, almost immediately being wrong became the more dominant fear. I would literally brush off groups of abusive men shouting whatever at me in public and in some cases be able to laugh about it, but would be on the defensive straight away at the idea I could have been wrong about myself. I just wish that more could see that we're all people who've been there, done that, bought the ill-fitting t-shirt, and respected our viewpoints that usually come from a place of empathy.