Alle Geschichten

Transition fühlte sich wie das Spiel an – dann spielte es keine Rolle mehr

Männlich · Detransitioniert50
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann, der transitioniert ist und später wieder herausgekommen ist; einen Wendepunkt erreichte ich Mitte zwanzig, als gesteigerte Selbstwahrnehmung die Spielchen der Transition, des Durchgehens und der damit verbundenen Ängste irrelevant erscheinen ließ. Ich glaube heute, dass Geschlechtsdysphorie viele verschiedene Ursachen hat, dass Transition Eskapismus sein kann, statt die Arbeit zu leisten, sein Geschlecht zu akzeptieren, und dass die essentialistische „So geboren“-Rahmung persönliche Verantwortung beseitigt. Ich habe die Risiken von HRT, die maskulinisierenden Wirkungen von Testosteron und die Orchiektomie kritisiert und setze mich direkt mit Autogynophilie als Erklärungsrahmen auseinander. Nach der Transition kämpfte ich mit starkem Cannabiskonsum, Poppers und dissoziativen sexuellen Erfahrungen, mit denen ich nicht glücklich bin. Suizidgedanken oder Selbstverletzung habe ich in diesen Kommentaren nicht beschrieben.

Vollständige Geschichte

I transitioned and later detransitioned, and by late 2021 I was spending time in detrans spaces offering blunt advice to others. I was born male and identified as trans for a period, and I now describe myself as having come out the other side of it. I remember reaching my mid-20s and simply having a different level of self-awareness than I had before. The things that gave me anxiety as a younger person were no longer as relevant; suddenly I had new desires and goals, and I no longer felt like being "chained to stupid games about transition, passing, all the other bullshit." That shift in maturity is what I point to as the turning point for me. I did not use drugs much during my transition, but after I transitioned I began heavily using weed, and later poppers during porn and masturbation, and had many dissociative experiences that I am not happy about, even though they felt good at the time due to orgasm. I came to believe that this progression of dissociation through sexual fantasy is what leads many female-attracted males down the road of transitioning, and I have advised others to cut out the weed. I also see parallels between that pattern and porn addiction: people who know a behavior is damaging but keep choosing it because the dopamine hits are too appealing, and who have not figured out how to replace those hits with something that adds to the person rather than just more neurotransmitters. On the medical side, I have been skeptical and critical. I have told someone re-starting hormones that HRT does not change an adult male's bone structure, since bones remodel very slowly, and that excess testosterone mainly affects muscle, fat, tissue and cartilage — which is why bodybuilders get bulkier faces, larger noses and thicker skin. I warned that the "steroid" look is not attractive and can lead to a bulky nose and ears, moonface and other issues, and that I did not think it was a good balancing act against an estrogen-feminized face. I have said the primary risk of HRT is having to reverse changes like breast tissue, and that while sexual dysfunction or atrophy is possible, in my opinion it does not happen to most people. I have also said I have no idea why someone would get an orchiectomy — I see no positives, only negatives, and asked why anyone would castrate themselves. I have thought a lot about autogynephilia, and I have engaged with it directly in conversation, telling someone that regardless of whether the concept is "discredited," it clearly described their behavior, and assuming they planned to be a "trans lesbian" until they convinced themselves it would be erotic to have sex with a man while only as a woman. I have argued that people with AGP fantasies are in a trap, and that unless they radically focus on re-orienting their sexuality away from those fantasies, maybe they should transition, because otherwise they will just obsess about it — sometimes the best cure is reality. I have also questioned whether someone's preference for attraction to men over women would survive being "the ideal male, with a nice 9 inch dick that women worship," and suggested that feeling like an inadequate partner as a man, versus simply existing and being desired as a woman, may be driving the preference. I have expressed skepticism about people's claims of passing, saying most trans people severely overestimate their ability to pass and misread social situations. I have also reflected on gender dysphoria more broadly. I have argued that essentialist thinking — treating being trans as something you either are or are not — is attractive because it takes all responsibility and intention out of your hands, and I recalled that strain of thought vividly from when I was closer to a younger person's age. I believe people get gender dysphoria for multiple, often completely different reasons, that being trans is not the same as being gay for many people, and that transitioning is not a guarantee of satisfaction and may be a form of escapism rather than doing the work to become comfortable with the sex and gender you were born as. That work, I have said, may take time, maturation, and identifying the core reasons for your feelings. I have also commented on the social realities for feminine or crossdressing men attracted to women, noting they are not valued by the majority of straight women, and that taking that route would require ego death and attaching your value to other things while ignoring society's messages — a route I personally was not interested in. I compared a difficult but potentially rewarding path of self-improvement against devolving back into a submissive role that someone finds comforting and most likely is sexualizing, warning that the second path is a dangerous phase where you can choose to fall back into past habits and dopamine pathways. I do not describe myself as religious, though I talk about things "damaging the soul" in the sense of our state of being. I have not described a specific therapy experience, family reaction, relationship status, or current medical status in these comments.