Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine heterosexuelle Cis-Frau, die in der Highschool ihr Geschlecht hinterfragte und Dysphorie erlebte, die großteils davon getrieben war, dass andere mir sagten, wer ich sei, und von verinnerlichter Misogynie. Ich bin nie medizinisch transitioniert; geholfen hat, Labels fallen zu lassen, mich so zu kleiden, wie ich will, und wegen tieferer Probleme in Therapie zu gehen. Ich identifiziere mich heute als AFAB und gender-nonkonform und kritisiere Transition als „goldenes Ticket“, besonders für autistische Frauen und Kinder. Ich habe diese Ansichten mit meiner Therapeutin und einem gender-kritischen Partner besprochen. Ich habe keine Suizidgedanken, Selbstverletzung oder Suizidversuche gemeldet.
Vollständige Geschichte
I found this community after going down a rabbit hole in December 2019, and it reminded me of my teenage years. Back then I was the only "Ally" in my circle, but people around me always wanted me to be some part of the LGBTQA+ spectrum — they never accepted that I was a straight cis woman. I felt that group met every criterion for a cult.
I was gender questioning as a teenager. In high school I had "super bad dysphoria," largely because people kept telling me they knew my sexuality and gender better than I did, and I felt bullied into trying to be trans. What ultimately helped me most was getting away from labels altogether: once I started wearing just what made me happy, a lot of the dysphoria went away, and I became fine with the parts of myself I hadn't liked. I now describe myself as AFAB NGC (non-gender conforming), and I say the only label that matters to me is AFAB because that's all my doctors need to know. I've told people to "Evolve above gender."
I've reflected a lot on why so many women question their gender. I believe society's misogyny leads to internalized misogyny that makes women question being women. I've also discussed with my therapist how autistic women are diagnosed FTM far more often than they should be, and that autism isn't even screened for when evaluating why someone thinks they're trans. My therapist told me that people don't want to do the hard work on gender dysphoria because influencers talk about transitioning as a "golden ticket" instead of addressing the deeply internalized trauma causing the dysphoria. I also noted that my former best friend's entire personality revolved around being trans, and that there's a huge lack of understanding about the psychological factors involved in being transgender, which leaves people searching for answers themselves.
I'm skeptical of online gender quizzes: I took one to prove a point to my significant other — I tested as "trans" while he, who is gender-critical, tested as "questioning" — and I did it specifically to show him "how much of a trap it was." I have an SO (significant other) who is gender-critical.
Practically, I still deal with some body discomfort: the tight sleeves on women's shirts are really tight and cause dysphoria for me, so I wear men's shirts or tank tops. I've said women's clothing is too tight in all the wrong places, the shorts aren't cut right for flexible movement, and they never fit right "because they want you to feel bad." My advice to others is consistently to just be yourself, wear what you want (even a dress with bootcut jeans or a minidress with cowboy boots), see your doctor and therapist for the deeper issues, and not worry about pronouns. I've said gender only matters from a medical-care standpoint and that "surgery won't fix your problems if the problem you have is within yourself."
On medical and political issues, I've warned that full hysterectomies are associated with early onset dementia. I've taken a nuanced but critical view of youth transition bans: I think children shouldn't be transitioning in practice, but acknowledge parents are trying to do right by their child, and I view government intervention as a huge overstep of authority leading to more broken homes — while believing the government isn't doing it "on the side of science" but as "a control thing." I've also criticized pro-transition communities for trying to "drown out" detrans voices with their narrative.
I've never mentioned hormones, surgeries, puberty blockers, a formal detransition date, or a specific diagnosis in these posts. I've never mentioned suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts. I currently identify as a straight cis woman who is gender non-conforming, and I am critical of transition as a solution, especially for youth and autistic women.