Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine Lesbe am Rand der Detransition, die vom Ende meiner Zwanziger bis in die Dreißiger mit dem Geschlecht rang und mit 31 im Jahr 2023 sagt, dass sie sich erst jetzt versteht. Ich beschreibe nie, selbst Hormone oder Operationen gehabt zu haben, sage aber, dass ich bei der heutigen Offenheit mit 13 Hormone genommen und in meinen Teenagerjahren eine Top Surgery gehabt hätte. Ich schreibe ausführlich gegen die pädiatrische und schlecht regulierte medizinische Transition, gegen das gewinnorientierte US-Gesundheitssystem und gegen die Feindseligkeit gegenüber Detransitionierten, betone aber, nicht gegen trans Erwachsene zu sein. Meinen eigenen Weg beschreibe ich in spirituellen Begriffen und bezeichne mich als spirituell, aber nicht religiös. Derzeit identifiziere ich mich als Lesbe mit Fokus auf Selbstverbesserung und habe seit der Detransition keine Suizidgedanken oder Selbstverletzung gemeldet.
Vollständige Geschichte
I have never posted a thread of my own, but over the course of 2023 I commented repeatedly in the r/detrans community, and what I wrote there amounts to my own account.
I am a lesbian. I have been single for about five years, which I describe as time I took to focus on myself and self-improvement, and I deliberately stepped away from labels and groups to build relationships with people outside of whatever group I identify with. I say this improved my mental health and well-being tremendously. I don't wear rainbow flags or promote my sexual orientation publicly because I don't think it is anyone else's business, and I am not defined by who I am attracted to or by my physical characteristics. I am attracted to people for who they are inside; love, I say, isn't about physical attraction, that's just lust.
On my own gender struggle, I have written that 'from 20-30 struggling with this was such cognitive dissonance it hurt and sent me in spirals many times.' I have not described hormones, surgeries, or an actual social transition for myself anywhere in this transcript, so I will not claim any. What I do say is that I did not have to deal with this as a teenager: I was 'just a kid existing as myself,' not attractive, with an 'aweful puberty but it was okay,' and nothing was about sex or presenting. I also say that if I had been in the position of a younger person writing in today, with the openness about gender ideology, I 'would have taken hormones by 13 and gotten surgery at least top in my teens' — which is my way of saying I believe I was vulnerable to it. I am glad I didn't know much or care about the whole LGBTQ world back then.
I have described a long period of not fitting: 'My spirit tells me something is not right. My spirit tells me something doesn't fit well with me. I tried to kill this spirit in order to fit in...only to be lonelier and more scared than before. I have started to find my peace.' I say I aged fast as a kid and then much later as a free adult outside the household, and that at 31 I am 'now only understanding myself.' I also mention being literally attacked by a rottweiler as a kid, which left me not wanting to be around dogs, until I eventually owned two huskies I raised and a cat — my family and my dogs — which I use to argue that people and experiences change and shouldn't be lumped into one category.
I am spiritual but not religious. I believe we are all souls on a journey, and that we are enduring a spiritual revolution rather than one based on money, things, or looks. I think people are confused and struggling because since the day they were born they have been indoctrinated into something they don't understand or agree with in their souls. I say peace comes from understanding and appreciating what you have inside rather than outward, earthly matters, and I don't push religion because of the wars it has caused. At the same time I argue that the idea of 'trans is being treated as a soul in the wrong body' implicitly requires religion to be real, since religion is the only framework in which a soul exists outside the body — which is why I think the topic is so difficult.
On the medical side I am critical. I say the transition surgery market in the US was a $2.1 billion industry as of 2022, projected to reach $5 billion by 2030, citing Grand View Research, and I note that figure excludes therapy and hormones. I argue the true long-term cost of lifelong hormone use and resulting medical conditions is probably far higher than the surgeries themselves, but that no unbiased long-term follow-up of trans and detrans people exists because of stigma, so the real cost can't be tracked. I say affirming care is 'still an experimental phase' and that there are no real studies, only theories and speculation, and that only time and unbiased documentation will tell. I have linked to a psychology theory article in Psychology & Health as the best thing I could find for someone asking about the rise in FTM transition numbers.
I am not against trans people: 'Everyone should be able to do what they want with themselves. They just need to be mature enough to consent and have the medical industry be open and honest about the journey and challenges they may face.' I argue strongly that a 12-year-old cannot consent — they can't get a tattoo, vote, own a gun, or have sex with an adult — and that parents who know nothing about the LGBTQ world should not be making life-changing decisions based on what a four-year-old says, and that treating a 12-year-old's psyche the same as a grown adult's is dangerous. I say there are age laws for a reason and kids shouldn't be able to make mistakes on irreversible things. I place the blame on the medical complex rather than individuals: 'There should be professionals weeding people out. But current laws allow anyone with a title to confirm and change these kids lives.' I say responsibility depends on the situation — good therapy, being over 21, time to decide, full warnings means the person is responsible; an inadequate doctor, no knowledge of repercussions, or being underage means 'it is not your burden to bare.'
I am also critical of how detransitioners are treated. I say the hate hurled at detransitioners is projection: 'They fear detrans people so they pretend they do not exist, are not real people, or hate them. You are not allowed to be a detrans ally because they fear this and will call you names.' I point out the irony that they are doing to detrans people exactly what the masses used to do to trans people — using a small percentage to argue a group doesn't exist or shouldn't matter. I also argue that the anti-detrans logic actually hurts the trans community, because it insists tens of thousands of people were groomed into thinking they're trans, which will increase transphobia.
I see the political landscape as a false binary: one side wants transition banned completely, the other wants no questions asked and easy access for all, and this binary mimics gender binary itself. I describe the right as a masculine complex with toxic alpha-male posturing and the left as feminine and socialistic, and say the resulting blindness forces centrists and allies to pick a side or be seen as evil by both. I say centrists have been silenced and compare it to detrans people: 'If you aren't one or the other you just don't exist or your opinion is just wrong.' I believe lobbyists keep ordinary people fighting each other so no beneficial change can be achieved, and that the trans community fears detrans openness because it's being used as a political weapon, when the real culprit is the medical industry.
I have given direct advice to individuals in the sub. I told someone full of self-hatred that those feelings are most likely why they wanted to transition in the first place, and that the fix is therapy to find the root cause. I told someone considering HRT to ask many questions of trained health professionals, weigh pros and cons, and not to seek outside validation through peer-to-peer pressure, calling that 'a recipe for disaster.' I told a young person to figure out whether transition is 'a WANT or a NEED' — desire versus survival — and said nobody should transition until a want becomes an absolute need after exploring whether autism or trauma is involved, since the brain isn't fully developed until the mid-20s. I told someone worried about baldness that hair transplants exist and that being bald is an extremely manly problem since about half of American men go bald before 50. I told someone questioning that there is nothing wrong with questioning, and I told a young person posting in the sub that there is no hate here, that they are loved inside, and that they can DM me if they need a friend. I also defended someone doing their due diligence against being told they already know their answer, saying that's no different from what trans folks do.
I have not described any advocacy or activism beyond this commenting, and I have not described any medical interventions, complications, fertility concerns, or diagnoses for myself.