Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann, der sich als trans identifizierte, von Social Media und Online-Trans-Communities beeinflusst war und das teilweise erkannte, indem ich zwei 18-jährige Freunde denselben Weg gehen sah. Meine religiösen, konservativen Eltern haben mich davon abgebracht, auch wenn ich die Erkenntnis selbst gewonnen habe. Ich mache mir jetzt Sorgen um einen männlichen Freund, der transitioniert, und um ein Mädchen, das ich kannte und das meiner Meinung nach durch Mobbing in die Transition gedrängt wird. Ich kritisiere, wie die Trans-Community Einflüsse und Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria abtut. Operationen, laufenden medizinischen Bedarf oder ein formelles aktuelles Identitätslabel jenseits dessen, dass ich aus der Trans-Identifikation herausgekommen bin, beschreibe ich nicht.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male and identified as trans for a period before coming to the conclusion on my own that I had been influenced into it. I don't give exact ages or dates for when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, or when I started hormones, but I do know I ordered hormones from what I describe as dodgy websites, and I went as far as that but not further — a friend of mine bought the IKEA shark plushie, which I note was "a step further than I went."
What woke me up was seeing two people I know, both 18, one male and one female, decide they were trans. Both were nerdy, online, and very possibly neurodivergent. Realising I was exactly like them made me see that I had been a victim of social media influence. The incessant hugboxing, affirmation and "you're valid" content pushed me over the edge. I also found it off-putting that only trans women seemed to show up whenever lesbian subreddits popped up on my feed, even though I'm male.
I was raised by parents who are educated, religious and conservative; they eventually talked me down from transitioning, though I was rebellious and came to this realisation on my own in the end. I describe myself as a left-wing atheist who generally opposes my parents in most ways. I'm now critical of how the trans community treats Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria — they dismiss the idea that anyone could be influenced into changing their gender, treating it like "unicorns or dragons," and compare being trans to an innate genetic trait like sexuality, which I feel is homophobic. I also think putting transphobia on the same level as racism, sexism or homophobia, which have been understood for a long time, is ridiculous.
I'm worried about my male friend who is transitioning: he's doing all the same things I did, has an anime girl profile picture, and I predict he'll start ordering hormones from those dodgy websites like I did. I want to tell him he will probably never pass as female, that many trans women on social media don't pass, that he should get off the internet, and that hormones aren't 100% reversible — but I know that if I say anything I'll be "crucified and burned on a stake" by my other friends, who are very progressive and instantly affirmed his new name and pronouns without question. So I feel I'll have to watch him go down this path.
I'm also worried about a girl I knew who wants to transition to male; I suspect the fact that she was bullied is pushing her towards it, and I believe the effects of taking testosterone are much worse than taking estrogen. Separately, I heard a 14-year-old sister of a friend talking about getting a binder and found it frustrating that I couldn't say anything about how harmful I think that is. Her household is super supportive and would probably never speak to me again if I raised objections.
On medical questions, I've been told by a doctor that male top surgery for gynecomastia is different from a double mastectomy, but I'm not 100% sure. I don't currently describe a specific current identity label beyond being someone who identified as trans and has since come out of it, and I don't describe ongoing medical needs, surgeries I've had, or a formal detransition announcement. My main feelings now are frustration at the trans community for hiding behind transphobia accusations to deflect genuine concerns, worry for friends going down what I see as a dangerous path, and a sense of having been influenced myself by online culture.