Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich wurde weiblich geboren und habe mich lange als trans/GNC identifiziert, identifiziere mich aber heute als detransitionierte/desistierte Frau und Lesbe. Meine Dysphorie begann vor der Pubertät, aber irgendwann erkannte ich, dass ich es hasste, weiblich zu sein, wegen Misogynie und Ungleichheit und nicht wegen meines Körpers an sich. Eigene Hormone oder Operationen habe ich in diesem Transkript nicht beschrieben. Heute sehe ich die Trans-Community, die medizinische Transition (besonders bei Kindern und autistischen Menschen) und das, was ich als Grooming und Misogynie innerhalb des Trans-Aktivismus sehe, sehr kritisch. Ich habe meinen Frieden damit gefunden, meinen Körper anzunehmen, und kämpfe nicht mehr mit ihm.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and grew up dreading and crying over the prospect of developing breasts and menstruating — these feelings started before puberty. For a long time I framed this as being gender non-conforming or non-binary or trans, thinking 'I don't act like a girl and I hate being one, ergo must be gnc/nb/trans.' I went through a lot of soul searching trying to find what fit me best. Much later I realized I hated being female and hated my female body because I hated the inequality and the danger of just existing as a female. It took me decades to get where I am now.
Once I recognized that I could act however I want and still be me, still be female (like being a butch lesbian), and that external misogyny shouldn't dictate how I feel about my body, things changed for me. I've come to find through my experiences that GNC is just being human — gender roles and stereotypes are a social construct and there's no 'right' way to be female (or lesbian). Behavior counter to stereotypes doesn't make me or any woman less female.
I don't currently describe myself as having had hormones or surgeries — the transcript doesn't mention any medical interventions I personally underwent. I do have strong views about medical transition for others. I believe the hoops to HRT and surgery need to be put back up, and that we need to thoroughly vet and explore all confounding factors before green-lighting invasive transition. I think 100% affirmation 100% of the time with no room for questions, hesitancy, downsides, dangers, or regret is not okay and is hurting children and adults. I've said it will never stop blowing my mind that it's legal to put children through life-altering meds and surgeries, and that it was never about the safety or benefit for children.
I'm critical of the trans community. I've said the trans community is misogynistic and that I learned the hard way it's inherently so — that it cannot exist without misogyny. I've said male and female brains are not a thing and that it's pseudoscience used to groom others into thinking they're trans, and that using stereotypes to assign gender to a brain expresses normal personality traits and preferences. I believe the trans movement has erased and set back decades of feminism fighting against sexist stereotypes. I've also argued that detransitioners get silenced by being called transphobic simply for existing, and that the trans community is trying to hide true detransition statistics because detrans existence contradicts their rhetoric.
I'm concerned about autistic people being groomed into transition — I've said they are socially awkward and very impressionable, and when they struggle to fit in because of autism, the trans community comes in and grooms them into thinking their struggles must be transness, much like the religious finding community with a church. I've warned others about grooming and social pressure, including asking someone not to let the trans community do that to their sibling. I'm also critical of parents who push transition on children, calling it abusive.
I've expressed sympathy for others' detransition experiences, including someone whose mother 'transed' them, someone whose fertility was stolen by the trans community, and someone who had all breast tissue removed. I've encouraged a questioning person not to have any procedures done, saying 'You're female and that's great!' and that conforming to gender stereotypes is the opposite of feminism. I've also questioned whether there are better coping skills for dysphoria than surgically constructing a non-functional phallus.
On being labeled transphobic: I've said being critical is not transphobic, but that detrans people get shat on either way, and I've pushed back when others in the detrans community are told they were 'never trans in the first place.' I've also been skeptical of a poster who claimed to be mistaken for male without having transitioned and who shared legal documents and genital photos to validate themselves online, saying it sounded like trolling.
I don't currently identify as trans. I identify as female and, based on my references to being like a butch lesbian, as a lesbian. I've found peace accepting my body and no longer struggling with it.