Alle Geschichten

Nach sechs Monaten war die Transition schon falsch

Männlich · Detransitioniert206
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann (Mann-zu-Frau-zu-Mann), der etwa ein Jahr als Frau gelebt hat, nachdem ich nach sechs Monaten erkannt hatte, dass die Transition die falsche Entscheidung war. Mein Weg zur Transition wurde getrieben von autismusbedingten Schwierigkeiten mit sozialen Erwartungen, einer jahrelangen chronischen Erkrankung, die mich meinem Körper gegenüber feindselig machte, AGP und einer ästhetischen Anziehung zur Weiblichkeit, lebenslanger Depression und Selbsthass sowie einem Therapeuten, der zur Transition drängte. Ich sehe Geschlecht heute als Rahmen sehr kritisch: „Sex ist okay, Gender ist das Gefängnis“; ich glaube, dass Transition starre Vorstellungen von Männlichkeit und Weiblichkeit festschreibt. Ich bin in der r/detrans-Community aktiv, biete Unterstützung an und warne andere davor, sich in irreversible medizinische Schritte zu stürzen. Suizidgedanken habe ich nicht beschrieben, und ich gebe an, dass ich mich erst seit Kurzem in meiner Haut wohlzufühlen beginne.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born male and I am male. I came to identify as trans and lived as a woman for a period, and I now identify as a detransitioned man (I have also described myself as "mtwtm," male-to-woman-to-male). I have described myself as a "fellow former autogyn" and explicitly stated "AGP was a factor" in my transition, alongside aesthetic fetishization of femininity: "I like feminity as an aesthetic I always have." Looking back, I can list the things that pushed me toward transition, none of which I now think were valid reasons. First, I felt that society's expectations of me did not line up at all with my personality or behavior; standing up for myself was incredibly difficult and conflict of any type would leave me in a racing-thoughts depressive state for days. Second, I went through a years-long health crisis that made me feel extremely disconnected from, and eventually actually hostile towards, my body; I have elsewhere described this as "a serious chronic medical condition." Third, I like femininity as an aesthetic and AGP was a factor. Fourth, I never felt right or like I fit in, and I had the belief that "these other people didn't fit in and then they transitioned therefore after I transition I'll fit in." Fifth, general self-loathing: lifelong depression and never feeling comfortable in my own skin until recently, with the logic "hate myself, want to change myself, what bigger more dramatic change could make." I am on the autism spectrum, and I believe being on the spectrum absolutely contributed to my dysphoria. My reasoning is that autism has to do with not being able to resolve social expectations: "Man and woman are binary categories and for a spectrum-y person its easy to get wound around the idea that 'i'm 51% or more stereo-typically woman so i should just be a woman because that's what society wants'." Also, being on the spectrum means you feel misaligned with your surroundings much of the time, so the idea of going through a long process where you are more aligned at the end seems appealing. I also noted that intense depersonalization brought on by being on the spectrum and a serious chronic medical condition was a factor in my experience, and that my experience had nothing to do with wanting to be submissive. I tried transition for about a year. My therapist pushed it, so I tried it, and it "felt awkward and lame and extremely not worth it." I realized transition was the wrong decision for me six months in, when the euphoria subsided and the feeling that my body was "wrong" somehow began creeping back in, slowly, then suddenly — that had been the feeling I wanted to escape. I do not have detailed records in this transcript of specific hormone regimens, doses, or surgical procedures; I have not mentioned any surgeries, puberty blockers, or specific medications for myself. I have not mentioned fertility concerns or specific medical complications from transition itself. On causes, I have been explicit that none of the factors I listed were true reasons to go through transition, but my therapist pushed it. I have also argued that there needs to be room for people who felt "pushed" by their doctors into a choice they came to realize was not right for them to ask why their doctor screwed up so badly. I have not described any specific trauma, abuse, assault, or bullying beyond the years-long health crisis, lifelong depression, and difficulty with conflict. On sexuality and gender politics, I hold a strongly critical view of gender as a framework. My recurring formulation is: "Sex is fine, gender is the prison." I believe transition actually reifies the idea that there is a single 'correct' way to be a man or a woman, citing Iran as an excellent example. I have said I didn't want my gender identity to be the center of my life, I wanted to get away from the box of gender, but being trans puts you even deeper inside it, and that the best way to deal with the pressure to conform is to just ignore it. I distinguish sharply between sex (male and female) and gender (masculine and feminine) as two different concepts, and I have expressed disbelief that some people in detransition communities treat them as the same. I have been active in the r/detrans community as a commenter, offering support to others considering or going through detransition. I advised someone unsure about taking T and puberty blockers that there is no harm in waiting until they are sure, and suggested taking a "break" from thinking about gender to escape cyclic repetitive thoughts. I have complimented others' appearances after detransition, encouraged people that they owe nothing to transition or to any community, and thanked and defended the subreddit's moderators. I made a darkly humorous comment that an "FtMtF class action lawsuit is gonna be lit," reflecting a critical stance toward the medical establishment's role. On my emotional state, I have acknowledged that my experience "feels insanely embarrassing" even though it isn't, and that reading others' posts made me feel less lonely and weird about my own experience. I have also reflected on bitterness: I told another person that you don't have to be bitter or cynical, and that if you are, you aren't really ignoring society's bullshit, you're just internalizing it; I noted that "the more I move from angrily declaring that I don't care towards actually not caring, the happier I get." I have said I never felt comfortable in my own skin until recently, suggesting my body reconciliation has improved. I have not described any suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts. I have not described a specific current career, family situation, or partner. My overall attitude toward transition for others is conditional and critical rather than categorically opposed: I emphasize personal autonomy ("You owe it to yourself to do exactly what you want with your body no more no less"), caution against rushing into irreversible steps, and argue that gender categories are far more expansive and less binary than they seem, so that one can be whatever one wants without surgery.