Alle Geschichten

Jahre der Geschlechterverwirrung, keine medizinischen Schritte

Weiblich · Desistiert503
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin eine detransitionierte bzw. desistierte Frau – ich habe nie medizinisch transitioniert und mich nie öffentlich geoutet, habe aber jahrelang mit meiner Geschlechtsidentität gerungen und identifiziere mich jetzt als heterosexuelle, cis, geschlechtsnonkonforme Frau. Ich wurde als Kind sexuell missbraucht, von Mädchen gemobbt und hatte Probleme mit dem Körperbild, wollte aber nie weniger feminin aussehen. Meine Verwirrung verstärkte sich, als nichtbinäre Identitäten zum Mainstream wurden und ich das Gefühl bekam, die Kategorie „Frau“, in der ich lebte, werde aufgegeben. Der Film Tomboy und eine Therapie halfen mir, mit mir ins Reine zu kommen. Ich bleibe kritisch gegenüber nicht-dysphorischen trans Identitäten und gegenüber der Auslöschung von Detransitionierten, unterstütze aber Rechte für Menschen mit echter Dysphorie.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born female and have always identified as a woman, though my relationship with gender has been complicated for as long as I can remember. I'm a lifelong tomboy, straight, and what I've called a "small-time desister" — I thought about transitioning but never even came out publicly. I'm 20 years old as of May 2020 (I stated this directly in a post), so I was born around 1999-2000. My gender struggles go back to early childhood. I was bullied by hyperfeminine girls starting in kindergarten, while boys were always happy to hang out with me despite my somewhat lacking social skills. I also experienced a mild sexual assault in first grade. By second grade I had stopped wearing "girls clothes" — before that I'd been into Disney princesses and ballet. The most masculine I ever tried to look was in those first few months of refusing feminine clothing, though I never cut my hair; I've said keeping my girl-length hair is a large part of my understanding of my own femininity and why I'm not a boy. I've described myself as a tomboy who was lucky to have five or six boys at school into comic books who didn't care that I was a girl. My parents raised me without gender constraints but didn't push nonconformity; my little sister was always a classic girly girl and we were both encouraged to pursue what appealed to us. I was sexually abused as a child and have struggled with body image issues my whole life, though never in the direction of wanting to look less feminine — mostly standard media-driven stuff about weight. In middle school I was excluded from a gifted program test because I had an IEP, even though my IQ results from around the same time would have qualified me; I've used that as an analogy for how I feel about nonbinary identities now. I never medically transitioned and never publicly came out as trans. Around 2017 I started voraciously reading news and research about transgender people and detransitioners. I was pretty TERFY at the time — I made fun of "tumblrinas" and "transtrenders" — and felt nonbinary people were denying their own femininity to escape misogyny. I never adopted a nonbinary identity because of those prejudices, though I wore plaid every day. I have very small breasts (AA cup) and have said it was easy to hide them with a sports bra. The core of my struggle, which intensified over 2020-2021, is that the modern definition of womanhood has shifted in a way that destabilized my own sense of being a woman. I was raised with the idea that "vagina = woman" in a deep sense, and I've said I think trans women are women because they feel more comfortable in female bodies, not because they like glitter. But as physical dysphoria stopped being required to be trans, and nonbinary identities became widely recognized, I felt the space of womanhood I occupied was encroached upon. I wrote that "people like me used to call themselves women. Now so many of them are abandoning the term that I feel abandoned." The label I most often use for myself is "gender non conforming," but even that gets erased when people conflate GNC with genderqueer. My best friend (assigned male at birth) came out as nonbinary around 2018-2019, which put me in a difficult position — I either had to pretend to believe their identity was legitimate when they had no dysphoria, or come clean and risk the friendship. I was pissed when they came out because it felt like they were reinforcing gender stereotypes. I've also noted they had a tendency to glom onto ideologies (they were previously into libertarianism, Jordan Peterson, Ben Shapiro) without squaring the consequences, and that unlike with those views, I couldn't discuss my conflicts with them for fear of hurting their feelings. I attend a fancy progressive liberal arts college in the US where I constantly feel like people assume I want to murder trans women because I look androgynous but use she/her pronouns. The pressure I feel to identify as nonbinary is subtle and implicit — nobody is explicitly making me conform — but I see androgynous nonbinary AFABs in media and feel it's sending a message. I've worried that if I don't use they/them pronouns people will assume I'm gay, insecure, an egg, or a TERF. I once considered joining my college Ultimate Frisbee team but an acquaintance's comment about being the "only non-woman on the team" made me feel sick and I decided not to join. I've also visited my school's Gender and Sexuality Center and asked the director to link to one detrans resource; he declined. What ultimately helped me come to terms with myself was watching the film Tomboy and an interview with its filmmaker, which led me to think about "radical freedom" — the idea that you can't not make a decision, and every choice about gender presentation carries meaning. I've also found general therapy helpful; my therapist is a "normie" trained in CBT/DBT and I've recommended her approach to others. I've recommended to others that they try presenting as the gender they feel like when feeling trans but with their old name and pronouns — I did this myself when struggling with dysphoria and about a month in realized I felt more dysphoric as a boy than as a girl, which helped a lot. I'm straight (though frequently mistaken for a lesbian), and I mostly hang out with cis gay guys. I've said my androgynous presentation is partly compensation for not being a lesbian, and that people assume I'm a TERF when I say I'm masculine, a woman, and straight. I've been briefly misgendered with "they" a few times but people correct it when I ask. I have not undergone hormones or surgery, so there are no medical complications or irreversible changes to report. I don't describe significant regret about medical interventions since I never pursued them; my regrets are more about lost time spent in confusion and the social cost of feeling I can't be open about my views. I've been active in online detrans and gender-critical communities since at least 2020, offering support to others, sharing articles, and recommending therapists. I support rights and acceptance for trans people with dysphoria, and I've said I think there are real trans people out there, but I'm critical of non-dysphoric identities and of how detransitioners are invisible and erased. I've advocated for therapy-first approaches and minimum therapy hours for minors before medical transition. As of my most recent activity I still identify as a straight cisgender woman and gender non-conforming; I have not transitioned and do not plan to.