Alle Geschichten

Acht Monate soziale Transition, keine Hormone und 2021 eine Retransition

Männlich · Desistiert100
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein detransitionierter, nicht-binärer Mann, der etwa 8 Monate lang sozial transitioniert war, aber nie mit Hormonen angefangen hat, und der sich 2021 zeitweise als retransitionierend beschrieben hat. Seit ich 7 oder 8 war, habe ich eine leichte Geschlechtsdysphorie, die an der Körperform hängt und nicht an Geschlechterrollen, und ich komme damit durch Meditation und Marihuana klar. Ich glaube, dass Geschlechtsidentität eine biologische Grundlage in der Architektur des Gehirns hat, und ich sehe sowohl die gender-kritische/TERF-Rhetorik in Detrans-Räumen als auch Blanchards Autogynophilie-Theorie kritisch. Ich setze mich für gründliche psychologische Selbstreflexion und Screening vor einer medizinischen Transition ein und unterstütze zugleich körperliche Selbstbestimmung und informierte Einwilligung bei Erwachsenen. Aktuell identifiziere ich mich als nicht-binär und bisexuell.

Vollständige Geschichte

I have identified as non-binary for as long as I can remember thinking about it seriously, and I've had gender dysphoria since I was about 7 or 8 years old. Looking back at my own history, there's nothing in my upbringing or personal history that would explain where the dysphoria came from — no trauma, no abuse that I can point to — which frustrates me because if I knew why I felt this way, at least I could take steps to address it directly. I went to gender clinical services to explore whether medical transition was the right path for me, but I never felt pressured into it. It was never shoved down my throat. Ultimately I desisted from medical transition because I realised I was non-binary rather than binary trans, and that changing my sex to female wouldn't actually help me. I did go through a period of about 8 months of social transition before stopping, and I never got as far as starting hormones. I describe myself as a desisted male who is non-binary. At one point in 2021 I mentioned I was retransitioning, and I talked about the UK waiting lists — 6 to 10 months to even see someone at a gender clinic, then around 4 screening appointments before you can even get near an endocrinologist. Hormone therapy in the UK can only be granted through a recommendation from an endocrinology specialist, as far as I know from information provided by a GP in a regulated system. I've said I fully support 18+ informed consent for all body modifications, but I also believe that as part of informed consent, people should be signposted to the fact that mental health conditions like depersonalisation or dissociation can be mistaken for classic gender dysphoria. I think anyone undergoing extensive body modification should do the due diligence and seek professional mental health services to thoroughly examine and process any trauma first. If they don't do that after being signposted, that's on the individual, not the state. I still have mild gender dysphoria. I'm fine about 75% of the time, which was one of the motivating factors for me desisting from social transition and stopping pursuit of medical transition. When the dysphoria hits, I manage it through meditation — I know that probably sounds woo-woo, but meditating on the philosophical statement 'what is identity? If not a conscious wearing a body' helps me zero in and go over the whys of what I'm feeling that day. Other than that, I use a lot of marijuana if I can't get myself to a more neutral state unassisted. My own gender dysphoria, when it occurs, is about the shape of the body: being too tall, too broad, not wide enough hips, too hairy, chest too flat. I present traditionally masculine and use he/him pronouns, not because I'm cis but because I'm lazy, truth be told. I find it easier to pass as a cis person out of convenience. I've said that being gender non-conforming and cisgender is possible, just as being genuinely non-binary and exceptionally gender conforming is possible. On causes, I'm inclined to agree with evidence from neuroscience and sexology that gender identity has a biological origin rooted in neural architecture. I don't have much faith in the 'gender is a social construct' argument, and I don't think loving yourself is enough to counteract genuine gender dysphoria. To me, real gender dysphoria is an instinctive otherness to the body the individual inhabits — a detachment or varying discomfort with bodily sex characteristics that is irrespective of gender stereotypes, expectations based on sex, or environmental pressures. The best analogy I have is phantom limb pain in amputation patients: logically it makes no sense because there's no environmental cause, it's just the brain freaking out because the body isn't mapped to how the brain expects it to be. I think a fair few people on detrans subreddits mistook whatever issues they had for genuine gender dysphoria, only to ironically end up with GD after medical transition to the opposite sex on top of whatever underlying issues they had to begin with. This isn't helped by what is essentially a very washy definition of GD in the DSM-5. I've said that the source of dysphoria for many people on these subreddits was respect of social gender expectations and feeling constrained by them, coupled with trauma. That's why, when anyone is questioning transitioning or detransitioning, I'm all for taking a long period of self-reflection, preferably away from all outside influences, both affirming and antagonistic, as these can cloud perspective. I often suggest a thought exercise: imagine yourself on a desert island, free of societal expectations but also without basic necessities. When survival has to be your first priority, if you're still having GD about your body, then medical transition is probably right for you. If those feelings no longer apply, then medical transition is probably the wrong path. I've also given people a list of questions to ask themselves: when did you start to believe you were trans? Have you always thought you were trans? Has there been anything in your life that could have caused dissociation from your body? What does it mean to be female to you? What does it mean to be male to you? If you lived alone without any social expectations, would you still feel this way? What do you feel when you see yourself in masculine or feminine clothing? Have you considered that you may be trans but not binary trans? Are your ideas about gender identity wrapped up in sexuality? I've asked others probing questions too — whether dysphoria is purely for the freedom to be traditionally feminine, whether it's sexual (could someone be gay/bi and subconsciously mixing up a sexual desire to be penetrated with a desire to be female?), whether there's a history of childhood sexual abuse, and whether dysphoria is only social or has bodily elements. I've said if someone has even a single doubt that bottom surgery is for them, they should postpone or cancel it, because nearly everything can be reversed in time except bottom surgery. Mentally, I've dealt with anxiety — I've talked about how anxiety about other people's perceptions is some of the most narcissistic behaviour a person can engage in, and that if you convince yourself that strangers hate you, you don't have to confront that it's actually just you hating yourself. I've said 'you will never be good enough for anyone until you're good enough for yourself.' On sexuality, I've identified as bisexual. On politics and identity, I consider myself non-binary both politically and in my identity, because before anything else I am human and refuse to be reduced to lesser than that. I've been critical of gender critical/TERF rhetoric in detrans spaces, saying I generally don't engage with certain detrans subreddits anymore because they're full of people spouting TERF rhetoric and offer me nothing as a desisted male. I've been consistently critical of Ray Blanchard and autogynephilia, calling Blanchard a 'trans chaser' and autogynephilia 'largely a cope' and 'discredited.' I've said trans communities, on average, have been extremely accepting of me and my desisting. I've advocated for further psychological screening before HRT, while also supporting blockers being prescribed during that assessment. I've argued against judges without medical degrees deciding the fate of someone who is genuinely trans. I've said I'm not against people transitioning, I just advocate for thoroughly exploring the self before undergoing HRT. I've also said that as detrans and desisted people, we aren't here to spread transphobia — we may not recommend medical transition as the go-to for everyone, but we recognise it is absolutely necessary for some people. On broader views, I've argued that gender roles in heterosexual cis culture are rooted in being 'breeding stock' for the continuation of the community, and that masculinity and femininity are social control methods to create a caste system based on sex. Anyone not fulfilling this role — LGBTQ, gender non-conforming, antinatalist, or simply infertile — will be treated with scorn or derision, proportionally to how socially conservative the environment is. I'm not against people having children, only the societal pressure to do so. I also believe biology is programmable and will continue to become more so as human biotechnology increases in complexity. I've expressed optimism about biotechnology — custom tissues, 3D-printed organs, organ cloning — and said I see the body as a machine that can be repaired, altered, or restored with enough know-how.