Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die seit meiner Jugend mehrfach zwischen Transition und Detransition gewechselt hat und Ende 2023 am Beginn meiner zweiten Detransition stand, während ich mein Geschlecht immer noch hinterfragte. Ich habe seit früher Kindheit (mit 5) Geschlechtsdysphorie, die ich auf verinnerlichte Misogynie und sexuellen Missbrauch in der Kindheit zurückführe und die sich weder durch Transition noch durch Detransition je gelöst hat. Ich nehme teils deshalb Testosteron, weil es meine psychische Gesundheit und Energie erheblich verbessert, obwohl ich weiß, dass es meinem weiblichen Körper schadet und Symptome wie hohes Cholesterin, Bluthochdruck, Harnwegsinfekte, Beckenschmerzen, Gelenkschmerzen und wiederkehrende Schmerzen in den Innenseiten der Oberschenkel verursacht. Bei mir wurde eine Depression diagnostiziert, und ich vermute auch tiefere Probleme mit dem Fehlen einer stabilen Selbstidentität und Schwarz-Weiß-Denken, was sich teils in meinem Muster zeigt, impulsiv Hormone zu nehmen und abzusetzen und das Geschlecht der jeweiligen fiktiven Figur anzunehmen, von der ich gerade besessen bin. Ich bin kritisch dagegen, wie Transition beiläufig als reversibel oder experimentell beworben wird, und habe wegen meiner Detransition trans/queere Freunde verloren.
Vollständige Geschichte
I have experienced gender dysphoria since early childhood — the earliest I can remember is around age 5. I came out for the first time in my teens and socially transitioned in my early teens, then desisted in my late teens. In my early 20s I retransitioned, this time medically, starting testosterone. I detransitioned around 26/27, then retransitioned at 30, and as of my posts in 2023 (when I was nearing my mid-thirties) I was questioning again and at the very start of a second detransition.
During my first detransition in my 20s I spent a few years doing a deep dive into the origins of my feelings. After a lot of self-work I came to a deep understanding of the root of my dysphoria — I identified internalized misogyny and childhood sexual abuse (CSA) as key causes — but I never could find a way to make the dysphoria go away. Eventually it wore me down and I decided to start T again, which I recognized was illogical because testosterone had never successfully rid me of dysphoria. However, my mental health is significantly better on testosterone: it makes me much more balanced (less high highs and low lows) and my energy is greatly improved (more spoons). Those two things contributed greatly to my decision to go back on it, even though I know how much damage it is doing to my body.
I began questioning again because I realized using T for these reasons might be counterintuitive — helping my brain in the short term so I can function day to day, but actively harming my female body in the long run. I also began to wonder whether I have a more serious mental health concern than the depression I have been diagnosed with, and whether lack of a stable self-identity and black-and-white thinking are key components of my experience, which I had never considered before.
I have a strong pattern of being influenced by whatever media I am consuming: I tend to desire being whatever gender the fictional character I am idolizing from that show/movie/book is, and I also pick up their style, characteristics, attitudes, and even accents from whatever I am listening to or watching. If I am obsessing over a character it tends to be all of the media I consume for that period. I recognize this as tied to having no sense of self — I have done reading on it and it fits me 'to a T.' I have a parent with BPD. I have tried traditional therapy very briefly a couple of times but found it a struggle to be real with someone I don't know or trust. I have impulsively gone back on and off hormones as part of this pattern.
A major factor in my comfort on T has simply been not living day-to-day life being seen as a woman. When I have lived as a woman, my entire existence to others has felt solely defined by what I could do for them, and it shapes my self-worth. I am taken much more seriously when the outside world perceives me as a man — I get less pushback when asserting my ideas, people actually listen, and I feel safe and like I don't have to justify myself when I take up space. I have internalized those feelings my whole life and my only escape has been living as a 'man.' I am terrified I might detransition and fall back into old patterns of just existing for others and fawning at every man I encounter because I don't feel safe. I am critical of people who say 'I identify as (gender) so treat me like you would (gender)' — I think the real problem is that people treat women and men so differently in the first place, and we should be destroying those ideas rather than upholding them.
I lost all my trans/queer friends when I detransitioned the first time — it felt like my existence was only valuable if I affirmed everything they thought about the world, and when my identity changed in a way they didn't like I was no longer worthy. I have had an ideology-fueled first transition (gender politics) and first detransition (radical feminist), followed by a second transition and second detransition. I am still radfem but have found freedom in separating my belief systems from my trans/detrans status, and there is peace in doing whatever is best for me at any given time regardless of politic, religion, or social pressures.
Medical: I got my testosterone prescription in the US by going to one appointment with a doctor other trans people I knew in real life had success with — a doctor who had never seen me before — signing informed consent, and getting a script that day. I have been on T for many years total across my transitions. Symptoms and complications I have experienced on T include: pretty regular UTIs; uterine and vaginal pain that could hit anytime but was particularly bad after orgasm; high cholesterol and high blood pressure; achy bones and joints (I have a baseline ache that acts up with weather/air pressure changes, and I believe my bone health has really suffered); and regular pain in my left inner thigh that started within the last year of my most recent stint on T. I experimented and found that when I stop taking testosterone the inner-thigh pain eventually reduces and disappears, and when I start again it returns. I have a PCP who takes zero of my concerns seriously, so I have not been able to get medical answers. I have also wondered whether the pain was related to the high cholesterol, maybe a clogging artery. I know how much damage T is doing to my body.
I have also dealt with the return of menstruation when detransitioning: my first 5 or 6 periods after my first detransition were really brutal. Things that helped were cutting out caffeine in the days leading up to and during my period, heat (heated blanket or pad), doing as little as possible during menstruation (exercise is impossible for me then — it hurts to exist, let alone move), period teas (fennel, ginger, raspberry leaf), and midol when all else failed. After those initially brutal periods I figured out how to manage them well enough for a couple of years before I transitioned again. It is hard going from years of no periods to having them regularly.
Physical changes from transition: a decade of binding changed my breast shape, which did not alter after detransition, though they did get fuller again over time. During my first detransition (which lasted a few years) my facial hair never went away completely but became softer and lighter and eventually slowed in growth; I shed a good bit of body hair, and areas like my belly and chest/shoulders got less hairy — not completely back to pre-T but I was happy with it. I have heard plucking and epilators can reduce hair over time and want to try them.
Mental health: I have been diagnosed with depression. My mental health is significantly better on T — I am more balanced with fewer extreme mood swings and have more energy. I have questioned whether I have a more serious mental health concern than depression, and whether lack of self-identity and black-and-white thinking are key components of my experience. During my first detransition, even after hormones normalized, I was in a constant state of low energy that made day-to-day life difficult; I leaned on coffee but was always dragging. My main concern about detransitioning now is that once I feel low energy I will just fall back into T use — no question — so I really need an action plan. I have not worked out consistently enough in my natural state to know how much regular exercise would help my energy.
Sexuality: I am some variety of bisexual. When I was FTM I felt like I could only be attracted to men and never women; when detransitioned I feel like I can only be attracted to women and not men. I cringe at the idea of being in a straight relationship or having a heterosexual crush — it feels embarrassing. During transition I knew many lesbians who transitioned to male and became 'gay men.'
Attitudes: I am critical of how transition is currently framed and promoted. I think it is a myth that you can just 'try out' hormone replacement therapy and see if it is right for you, that all the effects of HRT are reversible, and that if you are even questioning your gender it means you are probably trans because cis people apparently don't do that. I also think gender = stereotypes and is a flawed idea fed into by greater society. I have noted that ROGD is a real thing but am frustrated when people with that experience assume everyone else is like them — my dysphoria has been present since early childhood, and if I were born in a different era I likely would have just had to learn to love myself and my body, as butch elders did; I just happened to be born in a time where I could be medicalized. I wanted to just be me but male. I think the newer era of 'trans' kids/young adults is a different breed, and that in most western cultures where LGBT+ identities are accepted it now seems more about being special (the truscum vs transtrender dynamic). I am wary of the medicalization of transition and the lack of discussion about its risks — 'there's so much in the realm of medicalization that's not discussed out of fear.' I advised someone not to go cold turkey off T but to taper, since it is a big adjustment for the body, and affirmed that being an adult female is what makes someone a woman. I do not appear to be involved in formal advocacy or activism.
Current status: I am a detransitioned woman in the process of my second detransition as of late 2023, still questioning my gender identity, with dysphoria that has never gone away with either transition or detransition. I have decided it is not worth continuing to damage my body if it will not resolve the dysphoria, and I want to learn to live with it and reclaim my health.