Alle Geschichten

Eine vertiefte Stimme und der Rat, den er gern gehört hätte

Männlich · Detransitioniert71
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann, der heute als Mann lebt und zuvor als trans Frau gelebt hat, und ich habe öffentlich darüber gesprochen, dass meine Stimme durch Testosteron tiefer wurde, bevor ich aufhörte. Ich habe trans Menschen geraten, sich wegen Meinungsverschiedenheiten über die Transition nicht von ihren Familien zu entfremden, und Eltern von Töchtern, die ihr Geschlecht hinterfragen, gesagt, dass Bestätigung manchmal schädlich sein kann und dass diese Mädchen oft einfach bessere Bewältigungsstrategien brauchen oder vielleicht einfach schwul sind. Bis 2020 war ich an einem viel besseren Punkt, feuerte andere Detransitionierte an und drängte Menschen, sich ein echtes Leben aufzubauen, mit Handwerk, Hobbys und harter Arbeit, statt die Trans-Identität zu ihrer ganzen Persönlichkeit zu machen. Der Rat, den ich am häufigsten gebe, ist, zu einem Psychologen oder Psychiater zu gehen und wirklich bereit zu sein, sich zu öffnen. Suizidgedanken oder Selbstverletzung bespreche ich in dem, was ich hier geschrieben habe, nicht.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born male and transitioned to live as a woman. By late 2019 I had already detransitioned — I know this because in December of that year I was talking about my voice having "deepened a bit" and telling myself to be glad it hadn't gone further, which means I had been on testosterone at some point and had stopped. I told people I'd met more women in real life than they'd think with voices like mine now, and I tried to shrug it off and love myself, saying it still sounded female to me. I think of myself as someone who lived both sides of this. In October 2019 I was giving advice to a trans person about their family, telling them to explain themselves but not to try to convince their relatives, because "you may alienate them from you." I drew a direct parallel to my own past: "When you thought you were trans, you wanted the benefit of being treated like your feelings and decisions mattered, and now that you aren't trans you want the same thing." I told them their family members also want to be validated, and not to cripple the relationship over bias. Family, I said, is everything. I also spoke as someone who understood the trans side. In December 2019 I wrote, "As a trans woman who also supports personal truth my heart goes out to young women everywhere on whom society is so hard," and I said I wouldn't want a daughter of mine to have to learn she isn't trans from her own experience. I was clearly still working out how to talk about all of this — at one point in that same month someone came at me about language and I snapped back, "i dont have to justify my life to you. God this is so tiresome." What I kept coming back to was how hard it is to grow up female. I was explicit that I hadn't grown up female myself, but I said I was aware of the massive stress placed on teenage girls regarding looks and actions, and that it seemed much easier to focus on being a boy than to deal with bodily changes and beauty standards. I was writing to a parent of a daughter who was identifying as a boy and suicidal, and I told them, gently, that comforting her and treating her as she wanted might be "crippling her psyche" — not to insult them, since all they wanted was happiness for their kid, but because she needed a healthier coping mechanism than deciding she's a boy. I suggested she might just be gay and not have the framework to understand it yet, and I recommended lesbian TV shows and books like "Heather Has Two Mommies." I also raised the possibility that a lot of the bullying might be happening online, and I urged limiting Instagram usage, comparing it to not letting a child eat the wrong foods. I suggested introducing her to women with masculine jobs or hobbies — mechanics, construction workers, racecar drivers like Danica Patrick. By 2020 I was in a much better place. I was cheering other detransitioners on — "go girl! your past doesnt have to define your future!" and "so happy for you!! live your truth girl!" I got genuinely emotional over someone's good news, calling it the sweetest thing I'd ever heard and telling them they were amazing and would have everything they wanted if they worked hard and lived smart. I joked around too — I told someone they should become a beet farmer. I had real anger toward a certain kind of trans identity politics. In March 2020 I said the problem of people making being trans their whole personality was worst among those who don't detransition, and I said I hate people who think "oh im special because im trans" — "no youre not, youre literally just like the rest of us — youre just one of the thousands of Kim Kardashians the LGBT+ community managed to spawn this decade. Learn a trade, pick up some hobbies, quit being a piece of shit." That was the angriest I got in this whole period. When people asked what had helped me, I kept it simple: "consulting a psychologist/psychiatrist and being truly willing to open up." That was the core of my advice. And in July 2020 I summed up my whole approach in the words of the band IDLES: "love yaself." I don't talk much about specifics of my own medical history in what I've written here — I know I had a deepened voice from testosterone, I know I stopped, and I know I think of myself now as not trans. I don't go into detail about surgeries or dates. What I do know is that I came out the other side believing in personal truth, in family, in hard work, in learning a trade, and in learning to love yourself.