Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte – genauer gesagt desistierte – Frau, die als Teenagerin ernsthaft erwog, ein trans Mann zu sein, aber nie medizinisch transitionierte. Meine Dysphorie wurde größtenteils von verinnerlichter Frauenfeindlichkeit, Geschlechtsnonkonformität, frustrierenden sexuellen Erfahrungen und dem Konsum von Pornos und Yaoi/Fujoshi-Medien getrieben. Ich desistierte vor etwa zehn Jahren (bis 2019), nachdem ich erkannt hatte, dass es mir egal war, gesellschaftlichen Geschlechtererwartungen zu entsprechen, und ich identifiziere mich jetzt als bisexuelle Cis-Frau. Ich kritisiere sowohl starre Geschlechterstereotype als auch ausschließlich bejahende Ansätze bei Dysphorie, unterstütze aber grundsätzlich das Recht der Menschen zu transitionieren, wenn es sie glücklich macht. Suizidgedanken oder Selbstverletzung seit dem Desistieren sind nicht berichtet.
Vollständige Geschichte
I never actually transitioned — I desisted, I think that's the term, about ten years ago. I'm a woman, and I identify as a cis woman now, though I seriously considered at one point that I could be a trans man.
I want to be clear I'm not pretending to be trans or trying to invalidate anyone reading this, but I think my experience might help someone understand what dysphoria can feel like. When I was a teenager I had a really high sex drive. I watched porn, read erotica, fan fiction, doujinshi — basically everything non-stop. When I hit puberty I was aroused by women more easily, but I couldn't orgasm, didn't enjoy penetration, and felt like the women in porn were faking it, especially in anal scenes. I couldn't figure my own body out, even with a vibrator I got. My own body was frustrating to me. Back then I didn't understand the pleasure of oral sex, which is the only way I can orgasm to this day.
There was also something that felt really off to me about straight relationships. I have a million theories about it now. I think it was a mixture of the media I was consuming — girls were always damsels in distress — and the fact that some of the first porn I stumbled across was creepy. I started out with hentai specifically because I hoped that if my parents walked by they'd think it was just a cartoon. I was pretty naive about it.
Because I thought the women in porn were faking it, I got really into yaoi and became a fujoshi. Then I moved on to mlm porn and mlm erotica. I definitely had some penis envy, and also the stories just felt heartwarming without what I perceived as the gender imbalance of straight relationships.
A lot of what was driving my dysphoria was internal misogyny, and also being gender non-conforming. I think it's unfair when people pretend there isn't a bit of both fetish and trauma/internalized misogyny on both the male-to-female and female-to-male sides — that women can fetishize too.
Now I'm a bisexual woman who has had a fair share of experiences with both sides, enjoys both, and knows that female orgasms are real and much better than I once believed.
I grew up very gender non-conforming. I don't own a single dress. My mom would yell at me when I was younger because I would use a wallet instead of a purse. It took me 26 years to realize I was comfortable wearing skirts every now and then. I took calculus in high school and up to calc 4 in college for my engineering degree, and I loved math. I've been playing video games every generation since the NES, despite having to beg my parents to buy me consoles — they would buy them for my brothers instead. I built my own VR-compatible gaming computer. I listen to more variants of metal than most people know exist.
It's why I thought I was trans when I was a teenager, but I luckily desisted when I realized I honestly don't care what society thinks of me or whether I match society's belief about my 'gender.'
I'm all for people being themselves, dressing however they want, adopting whatever stereotypes they're comfortable with — I'm even fine with people injecting hormones and going through cosmetic procedures if that makes them happy. But I don't want anyone defining womanhood for me. I think there are a million ways to be a woman, and it's sexist to say you have to fit whatever the 2019 norm is to qualify as one. I do treat the gender stereotyping I hear from parts of the trans community as delusion when it's used to define womanhood.
I've also criticized how affirmation-only spaces operate. When I ask people why they're trans, it's always just a 'feeling' — a voice in your head, a sense of being, the 'push a button and change your sex' thought experiment. But those spaces rule out the possibility that the feeling might change. It doesn't matter if you followed that feeling, went through all the same dysphoria, felt suicidal while dysphoric, or spent 3, 7, or 10 years transitioned or identifying as trans — once you detransition, some people act like you were never trans and your advice doesn't matter. I think pure affirmation can be just as bad as pure gatekeeping, though I recognize pure gatekeeping is also bad.
I've also seen gender stereotypes enforced in my own family — my older brother forces gender stereotypes on his kids, separating his son from his daughter when the son wants to watch My Little Pony with her. I think stereotypes are just dumb.
I live in a liberal, large city where I see people who are brave enough to be unapologetically themselves — for example, people who appear male-bodied with full beards wearing long dresses, or people who appear male-bodied wearing makeup and skirts without trying to raise their voice to sound feminine. Big cities seem easier for individual expression because there are so many different types of people.
Overall I'd describe myself as a cis person who hates gender as a concept and wishes people cared less about gender and passing, and more about just being themselves.