Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich wurde männlich geboren, habe mit 17 transitioniert, etwa fünf Jahre als Trans-Mädchen unter Östrogen und Blockern gelebt, mir den Adamsapfel entfernen und meinen rechtlichen Geschlechtseintrag auf weiblich ändern lassen, bevor ich 2021 die Genital-OP verschob, als die Zweifel wuchsen. Im Oktober 2021 setzte ich das Östrogen ab, nahm später wieder Blocker, während ich Operationen beiseitelegte, und beschrieb mich 2023 als „zurück zum Mann gegangen“ – ein detransitionierter schwuler Mann mit mäßigem Brustgewebe durch Hormone, der sich derzeit weder strikt als Mann noch als Frau identifiziert und noch auf der Suche ist. Ich habe eine Borderline-Persönlichkeitsstörung und habe ADHS, ASS oder Alexithymie in Betracht gezogen und hatte neben dem Identitätswechsel mit Depression zu tun. Ich bereue, die Transition überstürzt zu haben, und mache mir Sorgen um unerforschte Gefühle, sage aber auch, dass meinem Leben etwas fehlen würde, wenn ich es nicht getan hätte. Ich bleibe ambivalent und unterstütze die Entscheidungen anderer, bestehe aber auf ehrlicher Prüfung der eigenen Dysphorie.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male. As a child I always related to girl characters on TV and films, played with dolls, and occasionally crossdressed. I started my medical transition at 17 and have been on hormones for almost four years by age 22 — estrogen and testosterone blockers. Over that time I also had some laser hair removal, my Adam's apple removed, and legally changed my name and sex to female. I lived full-time as a girl for about five years. By my own account I passed mostly, and life as a woman had a "blissful autopilot feeling" — things just clicked in social settings, and I knew how to "girl" naturally. I enjoyed most of the changes and generally liked how I looked.
Around August 2021, with genital surgery scheduled in a few weeks, I started seriously questioning. I had major social dysphoria — being a boy had been very uncomfortable, I was dissociated from my body and didn't know how to look good or take care of myself as a boy. But I also noticed I sometimes looked at attractive men with jealousy: "why wasn't i like that?" and wondering what it would be like to be in their position during sex, and sometimes feeling turned on knowing those men had the same body parts as me. I described feeling like a second class citizen in the world and having no will left to fight that. I also disclosed that I have borderline personality disorder and had considered whether I have ADHD, ASD, or alexithymia, which makes recognizing my own feelings and motivations difficult.
I decided I had rushed things and needed to slow down. I postponed the genital surgery, wanting to be in a better headspace and explore possible underlying issues first, while also fearing that if I waited I might suddenly feel sure about being 100% femme again. I was afraid that if I spoke up, my diagnosis for a trans identity might be taken away for sounding like a "looney." I live in Finland, where healthcare is affordable or free including trans matters, but it can get complicated.
In mid-October 2021 I stopped taking estrogen after almost four years. I described myself at that point as 22, nonbinary. Mentally I didn't feel much difference, though I was dealing with depression and an identity change that might have been suppressing my libido. Physically I noticed erections returning sensitively and strongly, with tension/pressure, sometimes painful at first — I attributed the pain to genital atrophy needing to adapt again, and said it went away fairly quickly. I was a little worried about skin and hair changes since I liked how female hormones had affected those. My breasts had always been small (AA/A) since I was skinny with little fat; there was some permanent tissue, but at five weeks off estrogen they felt flatter. I said bloodwork had always been at its prime on estrogen and blockers, and that I bounced back quickly to male hormones without issues about four months after stopping. HRT is bad for fertility, I noted, but for basic bodily functions it's "purely individual."
I felt good seeing myself as "just a person who happens to have this body" — I'm pretty androgynous and like the way I look — but I didn't start transitioning for nothing, so I was taking it easy. I presented both girl and boy, deep down not identifying as either. My style was very androgynous; the girl look just added a wig and pretty silk dresses. I was critical of what I saw as trans community messaging that everything has to be "rosy and sweet or it isn't true," and said I was happier feeling "im me, a girl, and trans, so i do things this way" than constantly emulating cis women.
In January 2022 I asked about the term autoandrophilia, saying it fit me quite nicely: I had dolls as a child, socialized with girls, related to female TV characters and felt awkward about my genitalia, but did I have a clear inner sense of being a woman? "not really i think." In February 2022 I wrote that for the first time ever I had started seeing beauty in being a boy, but with most people there was weird embarrassment when presenting male — I was terrified someone would expect me to do something "male," and it got icky in social settings. It was only a very specific kind of boy I felt comfortable being, and I had trouble separating which male aspects I actually wanted for myself from what I just found sexy, since I'm into men mainly. I'd never had the same anxiety living as a girl — I felt safer, more peaceful — but bad self-esteem, feeling like less of a woman, and fear of something going wrong had gotten the best of me after five years as a trans girl. I had no problem with femininity itself. I asked: "who do i wanna go through the world as????"
By August 2022, at 23, I said I had set aside surgeries and was still on blockers while trying to figure out whether I'm truly trans or just very very non-conforming. I said I don't have many male friends, none who are also male and questioning their gender or detrans, and I especially wanted to talk to gay or gender-nonconforming people for perspective. I described myself as interested mostly in men.
In August 2022 I mentioned that after stopping estrogen I'd had breakouts on my face and upper back, having had "perfect porcelain skin" on about four years of estrogen and blockers — and that I was on blockers again at that point. In July 2023 I said "i've recently sort of gone back to being a man" and acknowledged it can get tough. In August 2023 I described the situation as feeling like "struggling to pick a character for a video game," and signed off as "another nice looking detrans gay male with moderate breast tissue from hormones who doesn't think too highly of themself either." I noted that being a transfem can be simpler, but if there's any questioning and you're content with how you'd look as a man it feels unnecessary — yet being a man comes with all kinds of anxiety which resulted in transition originally.
I've been supportive of other people's transition choices while insisting it's legitimate to logically examine all possible reasons for one's own dysphoria. I pushed back on claims that gender dysphoria's existence is only debatable if you haven't felt it yourself. I've given appearance and styling advice to others, encouraged someone to find male inspiration pictures, and told another person "if you're not gay yourself you're gonna shut up now" when they commented on gay matters. I also commented on the Rose McGowan controversy, defending her as having meant good and gendered correctly, criticizing what I saw as overreach in intersectional call-out culture. I have not described any advocacy or activism of my own beyond these online comments.