Alle Geschichten

Brustwachstum beendete die Hormone – der Rest bleibt

Männlich · DetransitioniertErste Dysphorie 10 → Transition 24 → Detransition 30605
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann, der etwa 6–7 Jahre lang mit Unterbrechungen MtF-Hormone nahm und als trans Frau lebte; im August 2022 hatte ich die Hormone abgesetzt und begonnen, mich wieder als Kerl zu sehen, auch wenn ich mich nur in Online-Räumen als Detrans geoutet hatte. Ich habe die Hormone vor allem abgesetzt, weil das Brustwachstum mich in eine feminine Erscheinung zwängte, die ich nicht wollte, und seitdem habe ich echte Vorteile erlebt, darunter wiedergewonnene körperliche Kraft und die Freiheit, Androgynität anzunehmen. Ich habe immer noch deutliche Brustentwicklung, eine feminine Körperform und mäßige Gesichtsbehaarung, was mich beim Dating, Schwimmen und an öffentlichen Orten ängstlich macht. Ich sehe mich als bisexuell, konnte mir damals aber Romantik weder mit Männern noch mit Frauen richtig vorstellen, obwohl ich wieder angefangen hatte zu daten. Ich sehe kritisch, wie Transition beworben wird, besonders das „Ei“-Narrativ, und halte Trans-Sein eher für ein kulturelles Konstrukt als für ein angeborenes Schicksal.

Vollständige Geschichte

I had cross-gender curiosity from a young age — by about 10 or 13 or 14 I was an avid crossdresser and wanted to be a girl, and I started having thoughts like "well I'm short so I'll hardly be a good looking guy." I guarded being trans as a secret I'd protect with my life, and that held true until I was about 24. I had trans thoughts all my life and engaged in gender nonconforming behavior, but in my early 20s I had decided I could be happy being a non-gnc cis guy. What pushed me toward transition was coming across online the notion "transition now, or transition later?" — "Would you rather do it now, when you have a chance to pass and you're not hurting anyone, or would you rather transition in your 50s when you have a wife and kids and will always look like a hairy, fat man in a dress." Combined with how easily it could be started and a real sense of urgency, that influenced me heavily. I also think I was going through a period where I felt very lonely and directionless, and in that state it's easy to be susceptible to online indoctrination, especially when it's countercultural but aligns with biases I'd absorbed over a lifetime. I internalized a lot of homophobia and toxic masculinity. I transitioned MTF and took hormones off and on for the greater part of 7 years (about 6 years of trying to transition), including spironolactone. On HRT I became physically quite weak — weaker than a lot of cis women I knew — and basic lifting like groceries and laundry felt like a real chore; I think there's an incompatibility between male-sized bones, muscles and joint connections and reduced muscle mass from lack of testosterone. Spiro also caused severe bruising — I was black and blue all the time with big bruises, people told me I should see a doctor, and since coming off it I haven't had a bruise. I also had significant breast development. I presented as a woman for years, with a feminine name and female pronouns in the hiring process for a new job, and I put effort into fitting the feminine gender role, though I never changed my voice, didn't go to great lengths to hide moderate facial hair, hardly wore makeup, and only sometimes shaved my legs — part of why I shaved facial hair closely was so I could use public bathrooms without incident. I remember being laughed at for having painted nails as a guy. I found feminine expression in men was maligned, and yet I always found it unacceptable for myself — a kind of internalized toxic masculinity. I was cynical about transition even at the time, with a nagging feeling saying "don't be proud, this is wrong." I also felt like I wouldn't be a "real man" so transitioning was an escape from those expectations. What moved me toward detransition was starting to feel discomfort from how much breast growth I was experiencing — a mixed experience, since I enjoyed looking more feminine and passable, but it put me in a box where I could no longer present as cisgender and it was harder to dress masculine or androgynous. The line for me was "do I want to wear bras and try to really look female?" versus "would I rather wear a binder and try to look androgynous?" — that was the major reason I stopped taking hormones. I'd been off hormones for a couple of months by August 2022, and about 4 months off by early September 2022. I found real benefits off HRT: feeling physically stronger again, and an interesting sense of freedom in embracing the androgyny of getting a little hairy and a little more muscular while still having feminine thighs and breasts. There's also something good about not having to dose myself with anything to feel like myself. I began thinking of myself as a guy again, but I hadn't told anyone other than in online spaces — I deliberately didn't want anyone else's thoughts and opinions influencing me while making this very personal choice, and I never told my family to use different pronouns. I wasn't sure how it would be to ask friends to go back to "he" and a different name, though I thought I'd get there even while continuing to present as a feminine man. Getting "sir" still threw me off a little and I was trying to get used to it again, and not taking "brother" as an insult. I was considering a gender-neutral name. I was pretty chill with whatever pronouns people used for me. I worried about how people would see my breasts — "man tits" were embarrassing when I tried to present neutral or masculine, and I felt as a detrans male that nobody would be attracted to me, particularly because of the breasts. I asked how to go swimming as "a dude with boobs" and whether I just had to wear a t-shirt. I also worried about whether getting off hormones would cause me a lot of dysphoria, since I'd become averse to body and facial hair while appearing feminine. I found this detrans community helpful for navigating my identity and was "coming to really value this small community." I thought I might need a new username soon. I saw myself as bisexual — sexually attracted to both men and women — but felt more comfortable romantically with women, though I couldn't see myself with a woman at the moment because my gender and sex felt so complicated, and frankly couldn't see myself with a man either; I was working on getting back into dating. I'd been fetishized plenty during my full actual trans phase, but by August 2022 I'd been on a couple of dates with someone who seemed to actually like me for who I was. I now think trans ideation is often a pattern of deciding the grass is greener on the other side, when it isn't and you can't get there anyway no matter how hard you try. I think hormones are a good medical option for individuals with the worst gender dysphoria, but it's coming to be seen as a panacea for people who have bigger issues with gender roles than with biological sex. I don't think transgender is a thing that people either are or are not. I think being trans as seen today is a cultural construct rooted to a place and time rather than a natural truth, and that trans people are a subset of gender nonconforming people. I hated the term "egg" — I didn't hear it until well into transitioning — both for its coy playfulness and for implying being trans is a destiny. I felt like a much better representative of feminism and gender-equality as a man than I do as a transgender person, and called identifying as nb regressive and neo-essentialist. I was critical of beauty standards and the beauty industry, and of the pressure on young people to find meaning in physical appeal. I also had a combative streak online about Christianity, arguing the Christian god isn't real and that religious tradition was manmade, while saying I could get behind Sikh, Buddhist or Hindu concepts of God and the universe as God. I was 30 years old in August 2022, and by September 2022 I said I was "just getting started on undoing(?) my transgender hormone changes now in my 30s."