Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann (MTFTM), der jahrelang als Frau gelebt, Östrogen-HRT genommen und eine Orchiektomie hatte und Ende 2020 wieder als Mann lebte. Ich war bei einer Beratung für eine Brustoperation, um das unter Östrogen gewachsene Brustgewebe zu entfernen, fand sie beängstigend und unerschwinglich teuer und habe mich dagegen entschieden. Ich bereue die Jahre der HRT und die Orchiektomie zutiefst und tue mich schwer, mir zu verzeihen, auch wenn meine Reue stabil bleibt und nicht in Selbstverletzung eskaliert. Ich bin zu einem starken Verfechter des Autogynophilie-Modells (AGP) geworden, um die Mann-zu-Frau-Transition zu verstehen, bezeichne mich als „AGP-Truther“ und wende diese Perspektive unverblümt auf andere an. Geschlechtsangleichende Operationen halte ich heute für gefährlich und auf verstörende Weise normalisiert, und ich dränge jeden, der eine Transition erwägt, vorher seine Motive sehr gründlich zu prüfen.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male. I identified as trans for years, lived as a woman, was on estrogen HRT for years, and had an orchiectomy. By late 2020 I was detransitioning (MTFTM) and living as a man again, though I described myself as hating "being a man with tits" — I had developed some chest tissue from years of estrogen that I was considering having surgically removed.
In November 2020 I went to a consultation for so-called "top surgery" (chest reconstruction/removal of the breast tissue I'd grown on HRT). It terrified me. The surgeon described drains dripping blood from the chest for days, the risk that moving wrong could cause a hematoma requiring another surgery, a cost of around a million dollars, and the possibility that the nipples could literally die from blood loss. I saw around three female-bodied people (FTMs) in the surgery waiting area, including apparently some under 18, and everyone seemed disturbingly blasé about it. I wanted to scream at them not to do it. I decided I would not go through with the surgery.
I said I would never forgive myself for the years of HRT and the orchiectomy. When I was still identifying as trans, surgery had seemed totally normalised and no big deal; once I was living back in reality, the physical risks and invasiveness were obvious and horrifying to me. I did not have insurance, which made the cost prohibitive anyway. I described the prospect of surgery to undo what I had voluntarily done to myself as "sad and daunting." I noted my chest was relatively small and easy to hide, which was a small mercy, but I blamed myself heavily and struggled to forgive myself for what I'd done.
I came to believe that "gender affirming surgery" seems awful in every way, and that the whole trans and detrans experience differs a lot depending on whether someone is androphilic (attracted to men) or gynephilic (attracted to women). I described myself as "straight" (attracted to women) in that context, though elsewhere I said I was "bi."
I became strongly convinced of autogynephilia (AGP) as an explanation for male-to-female transition. I called myself an "AGP truther" and told another person in the community that they were AGP, that a romantic relationship wouldn't stop someone from being AGP, and that their bisexuality was a result of AGP — that they only wanted to be with a man to feel feminine. I acknowledged I might have been projecting, since I described myself as "bi" but said for me it was AGP. I said I had been trans for years before I realised AGP was real, and that it's underdiagnosed. I explained that although the seed of transition is often sexualised, it can lead to genuine gender dysphoria that isn't itself experienced sexually, and that "you certainly don't have to be a pervert to be AGP." I advised people to examine their motivations very thoroughly before making permanent decisions.
I also discussed physical effects: I said testosterone made me hungrier but much more energetic, that my metabolism felt faster than when I was on estrogen, and that I gained weight on T, mostly on purpose. I speculated that someone's testicles might have been affected enough by estrogen that they no longer produced sufficient testosterone on their own, and that higher T might help with energy and joint issues, though I understood it could feel dysphoric. I said I had personally "broken through" my dysphoria and no longer cared about being masculine.
I was blunt and philosophical about gender, asking what causes femininity in males if gender is a social construct — "Why would a boy grow up wanting to be womanly?" — and admitted I didn't have an acceptable answer for what causes gender. I said I'd been misled by trans ideology and was trying to understand my own position on it, and that I didn't want any harm to befall the person I was arguing with.
I ended one exchange with dark sarcasm about how easy it is to be validated as trans: "If you ever, even for a second, outside or inside of a sexual context, wondered what it would be like to be a girl - congrats, you're a girl. Fetch your programming socks and set up your nsfw Twitter."
I was supportive in a blunt way — I offered to talk via DM to someone else going through detransition, congratulated people on progress, and wished them well, while being very direct about AGP.