Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die sich in meinen Zwanzigern als trans identifizierte und etwa 3,5 Jahre lang Testosteron nahm, bis ich im Sommer 2024 abrupt aufhörte. Ich führe meine Transition heute größtenteils auf soziale Ansteckung und traumabezogene Probleme zurück und glaube – nach meiner eigenen Auslegung – an die Blanchard-Typologie neben anderen Ursachen. Seit dem Absetzen von T sind meine Brüste und die Körperbehaarung weitgehend in den Zustand vor T zurückgekehrt, per Ultraschall habe ich innerhalb etwa eines Jahres einen Eisprung bestätigt, und ich hatte mit Genitalatrophie und geringem Selbstvertrauen zu tun, was sich stetig gebessert hat. Mit sie/ihr fühle ich mich jetzt größtenteils natürlich, ich bin verlobt und habe Freundschaft und Stabilität in Hobbygruppen statt in LGBT-Räumen gefunden. Ich sehe Transition als medizinischen Eingriff weiterhin kritisch und berate regelmäßig andere in Detrans-Communities, auch wenn ich keinen formellen Aktivismus betrieben habe.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and identified as trans (ftm) for several years in my twenties. I first had the idea to take testosterone in my 20s, and I now think social contagion, or something like it, played a part in that idea and in my belief that T was much safer than I now believe it is. I also think trauma-related issues were involved in my own case rather than a genuine feeling of being in the wrong body.
I started testosterone in adulthood, some time after puberty, and was on it for over 3 years (elsewhere I say 3.5 years), self-injecting. I stopped suddenly in summer 2024. For the first months off T I felt lethargic and rough, which I now think is because I stopped abruptly rather than tapering; I have since recommended to others that they taper off rather than stop suddenly, and get medical input in advance of their appointment.
Physical changes and recovery: before T I had very little body hair; on T my body hair increased, and since coming off (about 18 months off by one estimate) my body hair has lightened and thinned a lot on my legs and stomach, though I still have slightly more than before T — but not an odd amount for a woman overall. My breasts had atrophied on T to the point I did not need a binder in flattering clothes, and they have plumped right back up; that return happened gradually and took at least a year. I had a Mirena coil (IUS) in place, which helps a lot with reducing my period symptoms — much less blood, much less pain — though it does not prevent periods from coming back. I have had issues with vaginal atrophy related to T; my local sexual health clinic has been helpful with referrals about the atrophy and has offered to prescribe topical estrogen if it does not fully heal. I also believe it is pretty bad for bones and general health not to have some sex hormones.
Fertility: I was referred by my sexual health clinic for a transvaginal ultrasound, and the sonographer told me which side I had ovulated on — I ovulated within about a year of stopping T (I noted the IUS increased the medical justification for the scan, but I believe it was largely done to reassure me about resumption of ovulation). It was a huge relief to know I was ovulating. Fertility preservation clinicians when I was transitioning told me I would need to stop T for 3 months before they could give hormones to trigger super-ovulation to extract eggs, and they seemed confident fertility would return, while noting a lack of actual trial data.
On the wider question of T and health, I have said that hypotheses about T's long-term effects on females are just hypotheses, that no one has researched it long enough to be useful, and that having been on T myself my money is on T being even worse for female lifespans than for male ones — I can't be sure, but that is what I suspect. I mentioned Faust's Gold, a book about athletic doping, as a possible indirect lead.
Coming out the other side: my confidence was at an all-time low around the time I stopped T, and it has improved quite a bit with time and social integration. Part of it was learning to live with being less sure and less black-and-white about things — a more mature confidence than I had when younger. Being detrans is certainly easier years in than it was months in. Two years ago I visibly reacted in discomfort to being gendered female; now I feel mostly natural using she/her — some of that reaction was learnt and could be unlearnt, and some is just habit about what you're used to hearing.
On causes generally, I think there are multiple reasons for transition that get wrongly homogenised: in my own interpretation of the Blanchard material I now believe some transition is sexually motivated (autogynephilia, autoandrophilia, or the idea of getting to be straight when you're actually gay); some conflate being gay and femme with being a woman or gay and butch with being a man; there is social contagion and subculture (as Az Hakeem argues); some have genuine sex dysphoria and buy into transition as a viable strategy; some are traumatised people for whom identifying as trans is the most socially accepted way to change their whole identity; plus other categories. I think these overlap in some people while others have only one reason. I personally was more social contagion / trauma-related issues. I have said I haven't seen transition improve someone's life except in ways achievable without the medical parts (new name, new style, fresh start etc).
I have not yet managed to attend an actual support group, though I planned to try the Genspec 'Beyond Trans' groups (online, some at midnight UK time) and I have found the Genspec podcast constructive, compassionate and nuanced, and I recommended the Gender: A Wider Lens podcast. I have found general hobby groups have done more for my sanity and functioning than LGBT ones ever did — I made friends at my local library knitting group, and many of my friends are older heterosexual Christian women who like knitting. I am engaged. I also noted that most random people I've met are less sexist and homophobic than the people who push others to transition.
I have not done formal advocacy or activism, but I comment regularly in detrans spaces, offer medical and practical advice to others considering stopping T, and have pushed back on the word 'detrans' being smeared as political.