Alle Geschichten

Zweimal desistiert vor 18 – und die Jahre von 8 bis 12 darin verloren

Weiblich · DesistiertErste Dysphorie 13 → Soziale Transition 13 → Desistance 15669
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die sich als trans FTM identifizierte, mit 13 sozial als nicht-binär und mit 14 als trans transitionierte, mit 15 desistierte, mit 16 erneut transitionierte und kurz vor meinem 18. Geburtstag erneut desistierte, nachdem ich entschieden hatte, nie Testosteron zu nehmen. Ich habe nie Hormone genommen oder eine Operation gehabt, und ich plane wegzuziehen, statt mich vor den Menschen um mich herum als desistiert zu outen. Ich glaube, dass meine Dysphorie größtenteils davon herrührte, ein maskulines, nerdiges Mädchen mit nur männlichen Freundschaften zu sein, und von der fehlenden weiblichen Maskulinität in den Medien, und ich denke heute, dass trans Männer keine Männer sind. Ich habe mein androgynes, maskulines Auftreten behalten, identifiziere mich aber nicht mehr als das andere Geschlecht. Ich habe das Gefühl, die Jahre von 8 bis 12 damit vergeudet zu haben und dass es dazu führte, dass ich die Schule abbrach.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was 17 when I first posted here, identifying as trans FTM and pre-everything, having planned to start HRT at 18 but suddenly full of doubts. My main fears were that I wouldn't be happy with the results, that I'd regret T and feel my life was ruined, that I'd never be a "real man," and that it might mess up my sex life. I also recognized that at 17 I didn't have much life experience to base such a huge decision on and that my brain wasn't fully mature yet — I'd heard 25-30 is when brain development finishes. I did have dysphoria, but I was afraid the negatives would outweigh the positives and that it might be better to learn to live with myself without medical transition for at least a few more years. I was scared that trans people in real life would call me transphobic for being nervous about T at such a young age. Reading replies here, the "lifetime of medicalisation" and the "never ending LARP" struck me as real and scary — I felt activists never tell you the ugly side, and it seemed ridiculous that in three months, at 18, I'd be able to change my life so drastically. The physical changes I feared most were weight gain, hair loss and acne: I had clear skin and a slim, androgynous body and considered myself attractive in an androgynous way, and I didn't want to lose my looks. I also worried about the health risks and about the ugly side of the lifestyle post-transition, especially romantically. Someone suggested exploratory therapy and I decided to look into it, thinking it might fix things without the sacrifices others described, though I worried the affirmative approach made it hard to find. I told myself I had to try the reversible approaches before the permanent ones. I liked the idea of body neutrality — acknowledging what your body does for you rather than how it looks — as an alternative to body positivity. I accepted I'd probably never "like" my body, especially my chest, but that I could focus on my skills instead. I came out as FTM but was already planning to desist. I presented very androgynously with short hair and masc clothes, and while adults sometimes read me as a young pre-pubescent boy, other high schoolers could tell I was female at birth, and I was mostly read as they/them, which annoyed me — it felt like people didn't believe I was a guy and just forced preferred pronouns to be nice. I decided I would never come out as desisted; instead I planned to move away so I wouldn't get grief from people around me, and so trans kids wouldn't tell me I "never had dysphoria" when I'd struggled throughout my teens. At that point I said I didn't care what pronouns people used — they're just words and don't change what I physically am or how I see myself. My history was complicated: I socially transitioned to non-binary at 13 and to trans at 14, then desisted at 15. My parents were against my transition from day one and never once used my preferred pronouns, though they did agree to call me by a unisex name. That first desistance was because of my environment — I desisted into a very feminine girl — and then I retransitioned a year later at 16 after finding I was back where I started, uncomfortable with myself. I constantly wished to retransition until it got the best of me. I felt comfortable identifying as a boy for over a year, then desisted again because I was nearly 18 and had decided I didn't want to sign up to the medical experiments. I'd "transed, detransed, retransed and then detransed again" — my fourth time coming out. Looking back, I think my dysphoria mostly stemmed from the distress of being female when all my successful friendships were with gamer boys. As a little girl I was a nerd who only cared about toys — boys' and girls' alike, cars or dolls or Thomas the Tank Engine — which turned into gaming. I didn't care about fashion; I had long hair and wore dresses but didn't care what I looked like, my hair would become a bird's nest from not brushing, and I didn't pick out most of my clothes. None of the girls liked me and I gravitated toward nerdy guy friends. When I hit puberty it got harder to stay with them; the few female friends I had started getting boyfriends while I couldn't imagine dating my male friends. I became disgusted with my female body from about 13 when it became obvious, and I started worrying my male friends might like me in that way. Every time I hung out with girls it failed. In middle school I had obsessions with male characters I thought were crushes, but I realized I wanted to be them — often anime characters with a smaller, soft appearance, blonde hair and blue eyes, the shortest male character. I never wanted to sleep with them or even kiss them, I just wanted to be them. I couldn't relate to femininity in media; female masculinity isn't represented, and even female characters in shows and games were hyper-feminine. When I transitioned FTM I no longer had to be "attracted" to them — I could idolize them. I tried hard to be feminine but it felt alien; when I identified as a boy I finally felt I could be myself. I do believe I had genuine dysphoria since puberty, not just a reaction to the world making women seem like a bad thing. Transitioning actually made me more popular — I stopped worrying about being seen as dating my male friends and genuinely felt like one of the guys. I'd never worn baggy clothes because I've always had an androgynous build, and masc clothes and short hair remain my thing. I never felt comfortable being girly. I was glad I never went on T and never would, because I felt it would make it impossible to date anyone, and I wanted to date soon. I was around nearly all non-binary and transmasc people in real life and noticed they seemed miserable and dysphoric even after HRT, which made me doubt T would stop my feelings of dysphoria. Seeing friends do HRT and still seem sad pushed me further toward desisting. I worried about the sequence of dysphoria — after the voice it would be the chest, then the genitals, then something else — and about the fact that bone structure would never change and sex organs would never be like a cis man's. I thought about how telling someone you're trans before sex might put them off, limiting sexual partners to a small group. I also considered fertility: I'd heard you can still get pregnant as a transitioned trans man, though I wasn't sure why anyone would want to, and suggested freezing eggs before T or adoption/foster care — but added that learning to accept yourself would be better first. I posted a list of things to consider before transitioning: limited prospect of sexual partners; having to live in an accepting bubble and cut out unsupportive people; facing discrimination if I don't pass; permanent reliance on the medical system; which prison I'd go to if arrested; that men's bathrooms won't have supplies if I still get my period on T; and the possibility of being unhappy with how I look post-transition. I framed it as questions to ask, not a ban — if it's still worth it after considering everything, I didn't see an issue. I came to believe that trans men aren't men and trans women aren't women — that I'd forced myself to think otherwise but it was easier to accept they aren't. I said the objective truth is that gender is whether you're born a man or a woman, but I let others believe what they want. I thought a lot about whether I could be quite attractive as a lesbian, and that maybe moving somewhere with lesbians around would make it easier to accept my body. I said I didn't know what my sexuality was — I thought I might be a lesbian but had never tried anything with anyone. I was critical of the pronoun-asking culture and of what I saw as gender ideology invading lesbian spaces, and I reported someone for suggesting MTF HRT as a fix for baldness, since promoting cross-sex hormones is against the sub's rules. I told myself I'd been saying I'm a girl and can't change that, but I'd been so comfortable presenting as a trans guy that I kept the presentation the same — I just stopped identifying as the other gender and accepted that not conforming to gender roles doesn't make me a man, and that I can never really be a man, only imitate secondary male sex characteristics. Doing so would mean permanent reliance on a medical system I already had a hard enough time getting mental health support from, reduced dating opportunities, and living in a bubble of acceptance. I decided desisting was right for me in the long run, and this time I did it because I'd found the time to emotionally mature, not because of my parents. I told another person to wait and keep exploring, acknowledging that their parents' transphobia might be weighing on them but that desisting might be better in the long run — only they could decide. I ended by saying I wasted years 8-12 on this, "fuck my life," and that it ended up leading to me dropping out of school.