Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die sich als trans Typ identifizierte und weniger als ein Jahr lang täglich meine Brust abgebunden hat, was bleibende Rippen- und Brustschmerzen verursacht hat. Zur Detransition kam ich durch Therapie, indem ich erkannte, dass meine Dysphorie eine Reaktion war auf eine homophobe, konservativ-muslimische Erziehung, auf internalisierte Homophobie nach meiner ersten Beziehung mit einer Frau und auf die unsichere Lage, als maskuline Lesbe wahrgenommen zu werden. Ich nehme mich als Frau an und habe mich dem Desistieren verschrieben, auch wenn ich sage, dass ich noch nicht ganz desistiert bin. Ich hatte weder Hormone noch Operationen und rate anderen heute, sich Zeit zu lassen und vor der Entscheidung auf medizinische Eingriffe zu verzichten. Ich bleibe kritisch gegenüber bestimmten Behauptungen von Trans-Aktivisten zur Sozialisation und befürchte, dass Eltern heute zu schnell geschlechtsnonkonforme Kinder als trans etikettieren.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female. I grew up in a very conservative, religious Muslim household that was also homophobic. When I was younger I saw myself as a trans guy and became obsessed with making sure everything about me was stereotypically masculine or at least neutral — I would reason my way out of liking or having liked anything not typically masculine, because I needed to prove to myself that the labels trans, guy, and masculine fit me and that the labels cis, woman, girl, and feminine did not. I'm still trying to undo that habit.
I started binding almost daily, often for longer than recommended (8–12 hours) for under a year. At the time I had intense anxiety and was breathing wrong the whole time. Since then I've noticed the bones of my ribcage at the level of my armpits sticking out and hurting sometimes; the protrusion is at the front of my chest, mostly on one side, and there's pain fairly often. I posted about it online wondering whether it was related to binding.
A therapist a few years back convinced me that she could make my parents accept me as trans and that they'd be relieved that I was at least "straight" — 0/10, would not recommend. My parents violently refused to accept me as trans, but we have a fine relationship now that they're in as much denial as they can be about me being a lesbian. Nowadays my concern is how to avoid having an arranged marriage.
I entered my first relationship with another female not long before I started to think I was trans, and being perceived as a lesbian made me very uncomfortable. I live in a homophobic household and a homophobic society and had internalized all the horrible things said around me about lesbians, masculine women, and gay people generally; it isn't safe to be perceived that way here, and I didn't feel like I fit a lot of the ideas about lesbians. So it made sense that I would jump at the opportunity to be a "straight male."
Therapy was a big part of me detransing. I accept myself as a woman now. This is the body I'm in and I'm learning not to dissociate every time I feel unsafe, uncomfortable, or ashamed of myself or my body. Not liking my breasts will not change the fact that they're there and they're a part of me, and hurting myself to get rid of them isn't something I want to put myself through anymore. I wouldn't say I'm entirely desisted yet, but I've made a commitment to work towards that and try to overcome it instead of going along with it and doing whatever it takes to quiet it for a bit — that never worked well anyway. I see dysphoria as a form of distress and a reaction to my upbringing, my current relationships and life circumstances, to society and its gender roles, and the way men treat me.
I resolved the thought "am I actually trans" by thinking about whether I identify with men. I don't relate to them or see myself in them. I don't want to be male. I simply want to be safe and masculine, neither of which makes me male or trans. My dysphoria doesn't arise from an essential need to be male; it's entirely a product of what males and females are allowed in this world. Women are not given respect, bodily autonomy, safety, etc., so it doesn't feel good to be female and look at my female body and think that others perceive me as female. But that doesn't mean I want to be male — I just want to have what they have. By understanding all this, I can see there was nothing about my desire to transition that was authentic or intrinsic; transitioning seemed to be, and was given to me as, the solution to all my problems.
Watching other detrans women talk about their experiences helped a lot — they were so similar to mine, and medical transition had not entirely resolved their dysphoria or made them feel whole and complete the way they thought it would. I now tell others to give themselves a lot of time and not do anything drastic, including any kind of medical intervention, before really sitting with it. I don't believe anymore that I need to experience medical transition to be 100% sure it's not a good solution.
I've also become critical of certain trans activist narratives, for example the claim that you absorb the messages of the gender you identify as, which would mean trans women are socialized as women — I don't think that's how socialization works at all, since it's directly related to how others perceive you. I also think a lot of what pre-op and trans women experience is more linked to gender nonconformity and homophobia than transphobia, and I've argued about the nature of misogyny in that context. On the other hand, I worry that a lot of parents nowadays aren't holding as much space for gender nonconformity and are going quickly to extremes ("is my kid trans?!?!").