Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte lesbische Frau, die impulsiv inmitten von unverarbeitetem Trauma, Dissoziation und sexuellem Missbrauch in der Kindheit transitionierte und deren Dysphorie ich heute als Trauma und Körperdysmorphie statt als Trans-Sein verstehe. Ich hatte eine doppelte Mastektomie und jahrelang Testosteron, was mich emotional taub, mit vernarbter Haut und Brustwarzennarben zurückließ, die mich um meine natürlichen Brüste trauern lassen. Die Detransition hat mich meinen gesamten Freundeskreis gekostet, der mich ausgrenzte und als TERF abstempelte, sodass ich einsam und ängstlich bin, auch wenn ich wieder Kontakt zu meiner Familie habe. Ich bereue die Transition und würde sie nicht wieder machen und wünschte, ich hätte stattdessen Trauma- und somatische Therapie bekommen und höchstens eine Brustverkleinerung. Heute rate ich anderen – besonders jungen geschlechtsnonkonformen Mädchen –, nicht zu transitionieren, wenn sie sich von ihrem Körper getrennt fühlen, und ich sehe Pubertätsblocker und aktivistischen Druck, der nuancierte Diskussion erstickt, kritisch.
Vollständige Geschichte
I am a detransitioned female — a lesbian who identified as trans for several years and detransitioned roughly three or four years before I wrote this in July 2020. I had been posting on this board about a year earlier, deleted my account, lurked, and then came back because I felt so lonely and anxious that I needed to vent.
My mental instability went back a long way: I had been like that since I was 11, with a very shaky sense of self, unable to recognize myself in the mirror, and self-destructive for about ten years before I transitioned. I desperately wanted to be anyone other than the woman I was. Just before transitioning I began having fractured flashbacks of sexual abuse — childhood sexual abuse I had never had proper, unfragmented memories of, only very physical flashbacks. The decision to transition was quite impulsive, although afterwards I was able to edit together a very convincing life narrative in which all the signs of my transness had apparently been visible from early childhood.
In the beginning of my transition I had frequent panic attacks and trauma flashbacks, and during them I begged my partner to call me by my old name because hearing my new chosen name felt ungrounding and freaky — though afterwards I remembered almost nothing of those episodes. I often woke in the mornings confused and anxious, feeling like a stranger in my own life without grasping why. I avoided my old friends and family members, and I had a lot of doubts that I actively kept out of my mind.
What moved me toward detransition I describe as a kind of spiritual awakening or ego death: realizing that I am not the stories or identities I construct in my mind. I understood I had been extremely dissociated from my body because of trauma, including the childhood sexual abuse, and I began to see how much the femaleness of my body and the trauma that came with it had shaped my psyche. I came to understand that what I had called "gender dysphoria" was a combination of dissociation and body dysmorphia, and that testosterone had made me even more disconnected from myself. "It all just fell apart and I had to face who I really was." I now believe a healthy identity can only be formed by owning up to my own past, not by fantasy images of how I should be.
I also think outside influence played a big role. Some of my friends were transitioning, I saw a lot of trans stuff online, and I kept seeing the phrase "if you think whether you might be trans, you are trans." I had thoughts saying I was trans but also lots of doubts, which many trans people told me were just "internalized transphobia." I now feel the idea of being transgender came from the outside — the internet, my friends — not from inside me, and I wish I had never done it and had stayed away from reading so much trans stuff. My life at that time revolved around trans and queer feminist activism, and pretty much all my friends were trans or nonbinary.
Medically, I had a double mastectomy / chest masculinization (top surgery) with scars around my nipples, and I was on synthetic testosterone. The testosterone made me numb and more disconnected from what I was actually feeling, so much so that it took me years to realize it wasn't right for me. It also damaged my skin: I say I had "the most perfect skin before testosterone" and now my face and back are filled with scars, and I warn others about possible balding, painful acne that scars, and vaginal atrophy as unpredictable effects. I have not had any other surgeries and don't want any more, because I don't want to traumatize my body further.
My relationship with my body since detransition has been a roller coaster. I sometimes google reconstruction surgery techniques and pictures even though I'm pretty sure I never want surgery again. I really miss my breasts and the natural proportions of my body, but I also enjoy swimming without a shirt and running without uncomfortable sports bras, and I feel better that men no longer stare at and sexualize my breasts. There are days I love my androgynous flat-chested body and days I weep because the scars around my nipples remind me my body was violated. I try to accept myself as I am because I can never get back my natural unscarred breasts. Looking back, I think the best options would have been (1) trauma therapy plus somatic therapy to heal the body dysphoria/dysmorphia, reduce dissociation and process the abuse, trauma and misogyny that made me want a flat chest, and (2) a breast reduction instead of a double mastectomy — the surgery I had should have been the last option.
The aftermath socially has been brutal. When I detransitioned I was ostracized by my friends and labeled a TERF. During transition I had distanced myself from my family and had no friends outside the TQ community; after detransitioning I got closer to my family again but have very few friends. I've been through extremely rough years largely on my own. I compare my personal experience — living years in a trans activist echo chamber and then detransitioning and being ostracized — to what someone experiences leaving a cult, while being careful to say that being trans itself is not like a cult. I find it very hard to make new friends: I'm not straight, definitely gender nonconforming, and everywhere I go, irl or online, the non-straight (especially female) people seem to be part of the community I left. Online lesbian spaces seem more focused on "how terfs are trash" (and detransitioned females are automatically treated as TERFs) than on being a lesbian. I'd love to find friends and maybe a partner, and I especially want to make friends with older lesbians and to connect with people through creative activities where identity politics matter less.
I would describe my political position as centrist on these issues, but say the hostile atmosphere and thought- and language-policing make nuanced conversation difficult. I'm scared of the radical queer-feminist trans community I was part of, its harassment of detransitioners, and the political power it seems to have, including its influence over health care professionals — while acknowledging there are many trans people who don't hold those views and wishing individual trans people love, happiness and healing. I'm critical of puberty blockers, saying people view real life like a video game where you can modify your character and pause: "Hormonally pausing someone's puberty? That's such a huge fucking thing." I advise anyone who feels constantly "in their head" or disconnected from their body not to transition, to get grounded first through massage, exercise and fuller breathing, and I warn that their "dysphoria might be actually dissociation symptoms." I don't believe there's any way to know who will detransition and who won't.
On regret, I hold both that it was painful and that it taught me things, but I wouldn't do it again if I could choose and I don't want anyone else to have to go through that pain. I wish I had known that what I called gender dysphoria was a completely normal reaction to trauma, and that it's possible to feel more connected to your body without changing it. I'm almost 30 as of July 2020, and I tell younger people that gender and sexuality feelings keep changing — mine still are — and to take their time, since identity evolves throughout life but especially before 25, and that you can be androgynous, feminine or masculine without being trans.
Mentally I've been exhausted, disappointed with society, feeling like an outcast, increasingly lonely and anxious, and at my lowest in my original post I wrote that the black-and-white, oversimplified state of discourse made me not want to live on this planet anymore. I've also speculated, without sources, about a possible spike in trans suicide rates around ten years after transition, wondering whether it happens when transition goals are accomplished and buried underlying issues — unprocessed trauma, depression, anxiety, eating disorders — start resurfacing.