Alle Geschichten

Acht Jahre Labels, dann gar keine mehr

Weiblich · Desistiert498
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin eine detransitionierte/desistierte Frau, die sich etwa acht Jahre lang als trans (und nichtbinär, agender, bigender) identifizierte, aber nie medizinisch transitionierte, und ich lehne heute Labels ab und bin mit meinem weiblichen Körper im Reinen. Zur Transition trieben mich schweres Mobbing und geschlechtsbezogene Misshandlung dafür, nicht feminin und akademisch begabt zu sein, was mir PTBS, aufdringliche Gedanken und das Gefühl gab, dass nur die Seele meines Körpers unerwünscht war. Somatic Experiencing, Anteilearbeit, Buddhismus, die Lehren von Thich Nhat Hanh und Jungs Anima/Animus-Konzept halfen mir zu erkennen, dass die Idee vom „falschen Körper“ keinen Sinn mehr ergab und ich psychologische Integration brauchte, nicht körperliche Veränderung. Ich bleibe geschlechtsnonkonform, bevorzuge den Begriff gnc, vermeide es, mich Frau zu nennen, und bin skeptisch gegenüber Körpermodifikation und Geschlechtslabels im Allgemeinen. Ich habe weiterhin mit traumabedingter Dissoziation, Echoismus und Schwierigkeiten zu tun, in Gruppen zu passen, aber meine psychische Gesundheit und Selbstakzeptanz haben sich deutlich verbessert.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born female, and I never medically transitioned, but I identified as trans on and off for about eight years and strongly contemplated hormones and surgery during that time. I also used labels like non-binary, agender, and bigender at various points. Currently I try not to identify as anything at all, because I find labels restrict my behavior — I catch myself thinking "I'm nb now, shouldn't I do more of that?" I might say I'm nb if the context requires it, or say I'm female, but I generally avoid saying I'm a woman because I strongly associate that word with cultivating particular behavior, which is triggering for me. I'm fine with being female and "cultivating femalehood instead of womanhood." The core of my story is that I was bullied relentlessly for behaviors that didn't match how I was supposed to act as a woman. I was mocked for reading books, dismissed when I said something complicated, and told that anything smart I said was just pretending — that something was wrong with my head and that having a man would cure it. I developed pretty strong PTSD with intrusive thoughts resulting from gaslighting. I experienced gendered abuse my whole life because people were upset I wasn't womanly enough — I was busy studying and reading. Boyfriends I tried to date all left me saying I cared more about my field than about them. I felt extremely lonely and repeatedly othered from my own gender, hearing "you're wrong, this body should have different personality, what is wrong with you." I came to feel that people wanted to make use of me — to comfort them, listen, start a family, raise children — but nobody wanted the soul living in that body. That made me resentful, because I figured if I'd been born male I could just pursue my academic interest without all of that. Identifying as a man during my darkest period helped me steel myself through almost complete social isolation for the sake of my goals. If I'd identified as a woman, I would have succumbed to guilt and pressure to "not be selfish," but identifying as man gave me boundaries. Deciding I had a male brain cured my intrusive thoughts and let me read and study in peace. I was extremely defensive about gender ideology — wrong pronouns or claims that there are only two genders would send me into meltdowns and panic attacks — and I now think I had reassigned my memory of my abusers onto people who attacked gender ideology. I managed to forget the abuse itself, but the emotional flashbacks stayed with different triggers. I have no idea whether anyone fully believed the ideology or whether it was constructed to exploit my trauma; if the latter, I have no respect for them, because it didn't help me heal, it made me feel threatened and as if my only place to belong was to back up that agenda. I also had a period of strong mental fragmentation: I needed to imagine myself as a man to access certain parts of my personality, because otherwise they were locked away as "undesirable." I still struggle with this to some degree. I have parts with different gender identifications — when male parts front, I experience body dysphoria — and through parts work I came to understand that all of them are true me; I'm just a sum of those parts. What moved me toward detransition was a combination of trauma therapy and a spiritual/philosophical shift. The therapies that helped were somatic experiencing (Peter Levine) and Janina Fisher's parts work, because I was dissociated from my body and needed to learn to live in it again. I also did daily repetition of skills and attitudes — replacing negative thoughts with positive ones, keeping a gratitude diary about what my body can do — because the brain takes huge repetition to change. Reading about trauma and the mind-body connection led to a major revelation: the idea of being "born in the wrong body" stopped making sense to me after about a decade of believing it. My personality was formed in exactly this body, so how could it be wrong for me? I used Thich Nhat Hanh's flower metaphor — a purple flower grown from the conditions it had isn't a wrong flower. Getting really into Buddhism also helped: if in past lives I might have been a man, but also a cat, a bug, or a fish, why would it matter so much how this particular body looks? Gender matters very little in Buddhism. Jung's idea of animus/anima also resonated — I felt I wanted to become my animus when wanting to transition, but embracing both parts of the psyche is a state I need to achieve in my mind, not by altering my body. That was one of the things that made me reject transition in the end. I never got any body modifications except a few piercings, which hurt and I disliked. I contemplated breast reduction at one point purely aesthetically — I have no back pain — but after knowing someone whose recovery was rough for a month, I decided against inflicting anesthesia and a month of pain on myself for what? To be perceived differently because something in my body is stereotypically associated with something in my soul that doesn't match? I don't wear binders because they restrict my breathing and would trigger me into freeze mode; I'm fine with a sports bra. I'm generally opposed to body modification for myself and skeptical of it for others — I think it requires self-objectification, the idea that your body isn't you, and that someone is selling you a dream that modifying your body will make the pain in your soul go away. Mentally, I've improved substantially. I used to have strong social conformity and social rejection was painful; I'm not sensitive to criticism now despite being a hyper-sensitive person overall. I had a rebellious phase that caught up to me at 21–24, expressed partly through interest in body mods. I still have trauma-related issues: I'm dissociated from my body at times, I have echoism — I only show behaviors that are safe in a given group, so with women I'm afraid to be blunt, with men afraid to show my sensitive side — and I feel comfortable only with my close circle of gnc friends. I'm still hugely avoidant of body appreciation work. On adversity: I was bullied nonstop by females at school while males mostly ignored me; as an adult, women sometimes schemed to exclude me even when I'd never interacted with them. I was verbally abused a lot. Female friend groups felt like a hive mind — private venting meant something mildly off I said could reach ten people I never spoke to, and my secrets got exposed. Male friends were only friends if they had bedroom interest in me, and friends would cut me off cold turkey once they got a girlfriend. I was extremely lonely. On sexuality: I once thought I was "straight as a ruler" and tried to correct myself into being in a relationship, but I'm not het — my cishet friends and I had little in common, largely around relationship issues. I'm not interested in dating; I need to know someone for a few years as a friend before dating as a safety measure, which is out of sync with my culture's dating norms. I don't mind respectful compliments, but being hit on upsets me because it makes me feel interchangeable — "he just wanted a girl and would take any." I dress gender-neutrally or in male-looking clothes, wear no makeup, and don't try to look attractive for men. On regret: I don't express sharp regret over specific medical procedures since I had none, but I do feel I lost something — I felt pretty happy looking masculine, yet while being trans I somewhat hated myself even in that look, picking apart how I looked all the time. I also feel I wasted years on a framework that didn't help me heal. I'm not from the West and English isn't my native language; I find the whole pack of gender terms culturally foreign and use them the way I use English — as a communication tool, not an identity. Currently I'm at peace with my body and don't want any reassignments or corrections. I mostly have a male gender and a female body, and I think that's fine. I prefer the term gnc. I don't think I'd ever be comfortable saying I'm a woman, but I'm fine being female. The best I've felt about myself was traveling in the mountains, where I rarely looked in a mirror and when I did I was happy with what I saw — it was just me, not an object to be fixed.