Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau – weiblich geboren, ich habe mich eine Zeit lang als trans identifiziert und seither detransitioniert, und heute beschreibe ich mich einfach als Butch-Frau. Ich bin nicht in einer hier beschriebenen Weise medizinisch transitioniert, aber ich habe jahrzehntelang mit Körperhass zu tun gehabt, der in der weiblichen Pubertät wurzelte, dazu kamen in meinen Teenagerjahren eine Essstörung und Körperdysmorphie, die Diagnose interstitielle Zystitis, ein Übergriff, eine Fehlgeburt und später Geburt und Stillen. Heute akzeptiere ich meinen Körper, auch wenn es fast dreißig Jahre gedauert hat, und ich arbeite als medizinische Biologin. Ich sehe kritisch, wie jungen Menschen Transition aufgedrängt wird und dass es keine Nachsorge für Detransition gibt, und ich ermutige aktiv andere, die zweifeln oder detransitionieren.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and I am a woman now, after a period when I identified as trans. I have never been someone who fit neatly into feminine stereotypes: I don't enjoy makeup, I don't follow fashion, I don't wear skirts or heels, and I don't have long hair. My hobbies skew traditionally masculine — I love video games (Final Fantasy, Mass Effect, Dragon Age, Stardew Valley, Zelda, Pokémon, Kingdoms of Amalur, Minecraft, The Elder Scrolls, Red Dead, The Witcher, Bioshock), I go to the gym, I love Formula One and archery (my Hoyt bow is my baby), I took A-level history because of my interest in the Third Reich, I gobbled down anything on the Discovery Channel about space as a child, I love chess though I'm not great at it, and I'm currently 800 pages into writing a sci-fi novel. The 'girliest' thing I'm into is Lush products, for their ethics and smells. I work as a medical biologist / biomedical scientist.
I have never believed in a 'female or male mind'. I think we're all just unique individuals born into female or male bodies, and that female and male bodies have real sex differences but are ultimately just vessels. I'm female because of my genotype, my phenotype, and how I was treated growing up because of those two things — nothing else. I find it insulting when people suggest that liking soft clothes and makeup makes someone a woman.
My body has been a difficult place to live. Female puberty was horrendous socially and physically; I hated my body. I developed painful bladder syndrome (interstitial cystitis) when I went through female puberty and I still have it at nearly 30 — after nearly 20 years it doesn't really bother me anymore, I just have to drink a shit-tonne of water, avoid certain foods and alcohol, and reduce stress. In my teens I had an eating disorder and body dysmorphia: I starved myself, wanted to have ribs removed because I couldn't get skinny enough naturally, wanted a nose job because I was obsessed with my 'button nose' and it looked massive to me, and wanted breast enlargement. I nearly had surgery but thankfully grew out of it after my teens. I also went through a phase where I wanted to move to Transylvania because I *knew* vampires were real and *needed* to become one — I'm so glad I did none of those things.
I've been assaulted, worried about pregnancy from it, lost a wanted pregnancy further down the line, and since given birth and breastfed, all because my biology is female. I still don't love my body — it's fatty and bleeds every month, my boobs aren't perfectly round and perky, my stomach has a chubby pouch, my hips have an awkward dimple, and I'd describe my frame as awkward because it doesn't look like how women's bodies are portrayed in media — but it gave life to my baby and I love it for that. It's taken me nearly thirty years to accept my body.
On transition and detransition, my view is that nobody would go through major treatment like transitioning 'for fun' — there is always an underlying mental health condition where someone feels the need to drastically alter their healthy body. I've argued against the 'No true Scotsman' idea that someone who detransitions was 'genuinely trans' in the first place: she was trans, and now she has come out the other side and is detrans. I've pointed out that scientific research changes over time, and that detransition data is hard to obtain — I've recommended Michael S Irwig's paper 'Detransition Among Transgender and Gender-Diverse People—An Increasing and Increasingly Complex Phenomenon' to people struggling to understand why there isn't much data, and noted that if you ask pretty much anyone in this sub they'll tell you they received no aftercare or follow-up after detransitioning. I was upset to learn there have been attempts to have this subreddit banned, calling it 'messed up' and 'awful' that people would try to shut down a support group for others questioning their transition.
I'm glad I'm not a teenager growing up today — I'd be called an 'egg' and definitely would have felt pressure to fully transition. I've advised younger people questioning transition to be honest about their past, saying decent people should respect you for owning your past mistakes, and that teenagers have always done dumb things but now we have access to more information and medical procedures than ever before and the teenage brain is underdeveloped and incredibly impressionable. I've suggested people look into OCD and autism if they obsess over gender daily, having read about a young person whose gender dysphoria symptoms resolved after being treated with medication.
I've been open about my own experience to encourage others: I told someone that I used to look in the mirror and not feel like my face fit who I felt I was, and that I'm finally learning to accept the way I look and even love it to an extent. I've also been blunt with people I see as sexist, telling one commenter to reflect on their negative opinion towards women. I care about accurate science — as a scientist I find it frustrating that data showing minimal differences between female and male brains gets overlooked, and I've corrected someone on the corpus callosum being proportionately larger in females while noting the study's flaws. I've also pushed back on the idea that detransitioners don't exist or aren't worth tracking, and I've encouraged detransitioners who've come forward, wishing others would do the same.