Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich habe desistiert und bezeichne mich heute als Frau, und die Erfahrung hat mich zu einer radikaleren Feministin gemacht, als ich zuvor war. Ich blicke auf meine Depression als Teenager zurück und sehe, wie sie Entscheidungen prägte, die ich einst für ganz meine eigenen hielt, auch den Impuls zur Transition, den ich heute als Selbstablehnung und Eskapismus lese und nicht als authentische Identität. Ich sehe Transition, nichtbinäre Identität und das, was ich als narzisstische und sozial erzwungene Aspekte der Trans-Ideologie wahrnehme, im Großen und Ganzen kritisch und habe mich online deutlich dazu geäußert. Konkrete medizinische Details, Diagnosen oder Suizidgedanken beschreibe ich in dem, was ich geteilt habe, nicht. Meine Reue dreht sich darum, das wiederholt zu haben, was ich heute für Lügen über Gender halte, und sie wirkt gefestigt statt schlimmer werdend.
Vollständige Geschichte
I desisted, and doing so has reshaped almost everything I think about gender, feminism, and myself. I used to repeat the standard progressive lines about trans identity and thought of myself as a good feminist for it; now I cringe at having ever said those things. Seeing how trans women talk about cis women after I desisted made me a more radical feminist than I ever was before.
Looking back, I can see how much of my own thinking was shaped by depression. I remember being a depressed, mentally ill teen and just kind of "owning" it without ever once connecting how my depression was influencing my decisions — it's so obvious to me in retrospect. At the time I was still possessed of the idea that the world was against me, so my depression was an ambient reaction to that, while my personal decisions were all independent and meant as a salve to it. The idea that even the things I wanted weren't really my own choices would probably have broken me back then. I now think transition stems mostly from self-disacceptance rather than some extreme desire for another form — there has to be a necessary perception of a "void" with regard to our own defined personhood before someone would consider co-opting an identity that isn't innately theirs. I also think a lot of it is suppressed, self-loathing homosexuality, probably encouraged by shallow-minded parents and friends.
I see my own experience reflected in things other people say about transitioning. When someone writes "I feel I was trying to kill that depressed lonely child by transitioning," I recognize that impulse immediately — it's a kind of adult escapism and magical thinking. No matter where you go, there you are; you can't escape yourself, and you have to accept it. I've said that transition is supported by a narcissistic culture that urges us all to hide who we really are and chase escapist fantasies, while detransition is the act of accepting yourself, which our culture isn't really into right now. I also think decreased economic and social mobility contributed heavily to the rise of trans identity, because people have increasingly opted toward private fantasies of life — personal identities containing prebuilt stories they can live out by occupying them. It's a much more attractive lie when there doesn't appear to be any legitimate alternative for a life with purpose.
I'm skeptical of the whole framework now, including the idea of male and female brains, which I believe has been disproven. I don't think gender identity is biological at all; I think it's purely social. I don't think any transitions are truly successful — the most successful-seeming ones are probably people with a very powerful psychological imperative to project a happy image, because their public persona is a large part of who they are. To me it comes down to whether you're the kind of person who can lie to themselves and live in wishful thinking your whole life, hoping one day it'll "take," or whether you accept reality as it is and try to find a better way to be happy than forcing something impossible because you've fixated on it. I've also said that the purpose of a treatment is to be effective, and that the maintenance of transition outcomes requires a level of self-deception that seems unhealthy and unsustainable — everyone in the world needs to gender you correctly for all the HRT and surgery not to be ultimately meaningless, which means your happiness is intrinsically tied to the successful suspension of belief.
I'm especially critical of nonbinary identity. I've written that nobody is nonbinary, and that being uncomfortable with your gender is a challenge to seek self-acceptance, not to capitulate to some non-identity to avoid being scrutinized. I find it contradictory that people refuse to define themselves while simultaneously drawing a circle around men and women as a set of behaviors and clothes. I've also observed people who call themselves nonbinary for attention but are functionally cis lesbians struggling to be happy in relationships because of arbitrary semantics they're adhering to for no reason — like being a slave to words. If you had a real-life human being who wanted to love you, why would you not opt for that every time instead of a fake internet-points-getting gender?
I've become much more critical of what I see as male entitlement dressed up in feminist language — things like "genital fetishism" and "cotton ceilings" being used to peer pressure people into supporting entitlement by framing it as progressive. I've noticed a pattern where a woman's discomfort simply doesn't matter in contrast to a man's or a trans woman's, and I remember a specific post about a woman uncomfortable with waxing a trans woman's penis who had to phrase it as being "for my husband's honor" to avoid being pilloried for her "genital bigotry." I've also written about recurring posts on trans subreddits that amount to a "two minute hate" about a woman at someone's job, full of barely suppressed male rage about jealousy over passing.
I don't have a specific account of my own medical transition to give — I haven't detailed hormone use, surgeries, or exact dates in what I've shared publicly. What I can say is that I desisted, and the process of doing so involved coming to terms with reality rather than continuing what I now see as self-deception. I've engaged with detrans communities and ideas, and I've noticed that the existence of detrans people means transition could be a mistake, an idea that's unacceptable to a lot of trans people because they literally cannot psychologically engage with the possibility that what they're doing might be wrong. I've also observed that people who keep their regret private do so because of peer pressure, social influence, and the sunk cost fallacy — lots of reasons to lie and protect how you feel.
I don't describe specific mental health diagnoses, but depression was clearly a major factor in my younger years and in the decisions I made then. I don't discuss family or romantic relationships in detail, though I've commented on how transition can destroy marriages and families. Sexually, I identify with lesbians and gay women — I've written about real lesbians in my city who frequent less visually "queer" spaces, and some of my best gay female friends love tennis, dog walking, and working on bikes. I've also said I would tell certain people "I'm not into conversion therapy," reflecting my belief that you can't force people to get used to things that define hetero- and homosexuality in the first place.
My current stance on transition for others is broadly critical. I don't think any transition is truly successful, I don't believe nonbinary identity is real, and I think the whole framework rests on narcissism and self-disacceptance rather than genuine identity. I've been vocal about this online, writing long posts and comments laying out these arguments, including a widely-shared post arguing that I cannot think of an argument for transgender identity that wouldn't also validate transracialism, since both seem to be pantomimes based on external observation. I've also written about "internalized transphobia" as a term people use when they encounter an argument that logically explains trans ideology in a way that feels more correct than anything they've heard, but would mean they aren't really trans — so they have to convince themselves it's some evil external force rather than their own reasoning. I don't describe any formal advocacy or activism beyond posting and commenting online.
Overall, I'm in a much more grounded place than I was as a depressed teenager. I've accepted myself as I am rather than trying to become something else, and while I don't describe my current quality of life in detail, the clarity I have now feels like progress to me. I regret having repeated what I now see as lies about gender and feminism, and I feel embarrassed for ever having said those things, but I don't describe that regret as overwhelming or worsening — it reads more as settled conviction than as ongoing anguish.