Alle Geschichten

Ein schwuler Mann, der aufhörte, an Gender zu glauben

Männlich · Detransitioniert1187
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein detransitionierter schwuler Mann, der sich nicht mehr als trans identifiziert und das Cis/Trans-Schema ganz ablehnt, und sage: „Ich glaube nicht mehr an Gender.“ Ich transitionierte, nahm eine Zeit lang Testosteron (das meine Stimme vertiefte und meine Haare beeinflusste), hörte dann auf und stellte mein natürliches Testosteron wieder her, und die Reue – was ich „Trans-Reue“ nenne – brachte mich in diese Community. Ich glaube, dass soziale Ansteckung, Misogynie, verinnerlichte Homophobie und ein übermäßig bestätigendes Medizinsystem mich und andere wie mich in die Irre geführt haben, und ich setze mich nachdrücklich für klinische Zugangskontrollen, gegen die medizinische Transition Minderjähriger und gegen erzwungenen Pronomengebrauch ein. Ich habe mit Trauma zu tun gehabt und mich mit DBT befasst, und auch wenn es mir emotional immer noch schwerfällt, über das Thema zu sprechen, bin ich online laut geworden gegenüber den Schäden, die ich in der modernen Trans-Bewegung sehe.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born male and grew up as a little boy who played with all kinds of toys — GI Joe, Barbie, I liked it all. I am gay, and I identified as trans for a period of my life before detransitioning. Looking back, I recognize that if I had grown up in today's climate I might have been targeted for social transition as a child, because I didn't conform to rigid gender stereotypes. My journey toward transition and then away from it has been shaped by a lot of reflection. I came to understand that I don't subscribe to the cis/trans paradigm anymore — I think it's too ideological and puts people into boxes. I don't believe in gender anymore. I've said plainly: you're the sex you're born as and the rest is drag, or theatre. That doesn't mean I'm non-binary or queer — I reject those labels too. I am me. Spiritually, the answers came to me when I visited India and a few other Eastern countries. I saw religious iconography of deities who appeared neither male nor female yet were referred to as he or she. I came to understand that my consciousness, the being that I am, is always going to be way more complex and deep than what my physical shell shows, no matter how it looks. I have transformed my dysphoria into being curious about how people see my body/vehicle, without taking it personally. If they think I'm a he or a she, I take that as their experience of me, and not my own experience of who I am. At the end of the day they can call me whatever pronoun they want — I can't be overly identified with any of it. On hormones: I have described how, as a male, I have an overall deeper voice, but when I killed my testosterone my voice went up an octave, and when I eventually restored my natural testosterone it went back down again. This tells me I did spend time suppressing testosterone and later restored it naturally. I have also spoken about hair regrowth after stopping T — explaining that hair can grow back as long as the follicle hasn't died, and that stopping T while hair is still just miniaturized can allow it to re-thicken over time — which suggests I have personal experience with androgenic alopecia concerns related to testosterone use. I have not given exact dates for when I started or stopped hormones, or for any surgeries, so I'll leave those blank. I've been open about the fact that detransition happened to me. I wrote directly: 'If we have to accept every child's self-declaration no matter what, then that leads to trans regret later... which is what this whole sub is about. It's what happened to me.' I've also acknowledged that talking about it is hard: 'It's a really difficult subject for me to talk about despite how I may write about it. It's emotional.' I've thought a lot about what led people like me astray. I believe social contagion plays a big role, especially among girls — I've cited psychology research that girls are more subject to social contagion than boys, comparing it to anorexia wards where girls have to be kept apart because they worsen each other's condition. I've noted that before 2014 MTF was more common than FTM and now it's the opposite, and I attribute some of this to toxic misogyny culture making the option of escaping femality appealing. I've also said I've met quite a few other FTMs who were heavily influenced by yaoi and anime from a young age, and I validated someone else's experience of that. I think there is an FTM version of autogynephilia caused by young women being obsessed with yaoi/anime gay boys. I'm personally in the fetish community and I guarantee AGP exists, though I think AGP types are a small minority within trans spaces. I've also pointed to homophobia as a driver — I've said that cishet parents of feminine boys would rather them be a girl than a gay boy who likes 'girly' things, which amounts to gay erasure, and that the same happens with tomboy lesbians being told they're in the wrong body. I see this as inherent sexism: the mainstream promoting boys becoming girls and girls becoming boys just because they enjoy things stereotypical of the opposite sex. I envy nothing about how the modern movement operates. I've been angry about how institutions handle this. I've said detransitioners are the biggest threat to the movement's ideology because 'we drank the kool aid and it didn't work. We were one of them.' I've criticized the affirmative care model, saying clinicians don't care because of money and because not using it could get them in trouble. I believe litigation in the US is how this will be resolved — it has to be about money. I've also said the movement's vitriol is turning people against trans people and making them less safe, and I've condemned doxxing, getting people fired, and threats against families. I have complicated feelings about passing. I've said passing requires big money or luck in being androgynous enough, creating a privilege hierarchy, and that FTM bottom surgery is horrific and doesn't make you pass at all. I've questioned whether it's right to encourage someone to transition who is never going to pass, and I've said some people are being led down the garden path of transition who don't have a hope in hell of ever passing. I've been direct about what I think being trans actually requires: if you don't have gender dysphoria, you're not trans. I've questioned whether someone really has gender dysphoria if they keep the secondary sex characteristics of the sex that causes their dysphoria. I've argued that self-declaration without clinical verification dilutes the cause for people who genuinely need the diagnosis, conflates it with other voices, and confuses the general public. I've said transsexualism was originally identified as a psych condition based on people with gender dysphoria being unable to function in life. I'm gay, and I've worried that the expansion of the trans umbrella is eroding positive perceptions of gay people that had already been achieved. I've called much of it gay/bi erasure. I've also said I'm sickened by the abuse of the word 'genocide' by modern left wing ideologies, and I've pushed back hard when I feel the movement speaks for me as a gay person. I've been through real difficulty. I've referred to my trauma and said I will never try to heal it in those communities because they've spent years destroying the meaning of words, with constantly shifting goalposts. I've written: 'Our bodies have become political minefields, instruments for other people's trauma and social justice narratives. I'm tired. Leave me alone, I am living the life I need to.' I've mentioned DBT can help but it's hard to find a good program, which suggests I've looked into treatment for emotional dysregulation or trauma. On envy of women before my transition: I envied the attention they got from men, especially men I was always attracted to but could never get, and I envied the variety of fashion, the bias toward women in the beauty industry, and the social acceptability for women to be vain. I stopped envying them when I realized the misogyny that exists at a deeper level, and when women I envied opened up to me about their assault stories. I've also talked about my working life — I've run two businesses, one that failed because it wasn't financially buoyant and one that succeeded long term until I shut it down to go to nursing school. I've worked with activist types in the workplace who 'vanguard the workplace' and make their neuroses everybody's problem. I'm not American — I've said so directly when accused of following US politics. I've been critical of compelled speech, especially at work where I've said I don't even feel comfortable calling people 'they' but could be fired if I don't. I've said nobody owes anybody validation and that there have to be boundaries. I've also described a personal situation involving my nephew: when he was 8, he wore two different colorful socks to school, another kid bullied him for 'girl socks,' and the teacher said 'Maybe he wants to be a girl and there's nothing wrong with that.' My family didn't know until over a year later that he was being made to question his identity. I've said I'm not even right wing despite holding these views. I've been moved by a friend's metaphor about trees — that they come in bizarre and interesting configurations but they all belong, and that the vast majority of people, even unconventional people, can learn to be okay with who they are without radical interventions. I don't downplay bona fide gender dysphoria — I've said it exists and that's not up for debate — but I'm fiercely opposed to educators, clinicians, and pop culture prompting young people to think they're in the wrong body. I've called it completely unethical to give children workshops and lessons about being in the wrong body. Currently, I'm living my life and trying to be left alone. I've said I don't care what people call me because I know who I am. I've expressed hope that political momentum will get 'the truth into the light of day,' while worrying about backlash. I've said the lawsuit system is probably what will settle this. I've also expressed a darker weariness — some days I pray for the flood, because this world is so full of evil and there is never justice.