Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich wurde als Junge geboren, habe fast ein Jahrzehnt lang transitioniert, beginnend in der Kindheit, und habe seitdem detransitioniert; heute bezeichne ich mich als detransitionierten Mann. Ich glaube, dass meine Geschlechtsdysphorie in einer traumatischen und von Missbrauch geprägten Kindheit wurzelte, und ich habe die gegengeschlechtlichen Hormone von einem Tag auf den anderen abgesetzt, nachdem ich erkannt hatte, dass mein Gefühl, dem anderen Geschlecht anzugehören, von gesellschaftlichen Männlichkeitserwartungen herrührte. Finanziell geht es mir wegen der Transitionskosten jetzt schlecht, und ich habe rechtliche Schritte gegen meine Behandler geprüft. Ich mache mir große Sorgen um meine Schwester, die nach mir begonnen hat, sich als trans zu identifizieren, und jetzt medizinisch transitioniert; ich versuche herauszufinden, wie ich ihr helfen kann, während meine Familie passiv „unterstützend“ bleibt. Ich vertrete mit Nachdruck, dass es für Transition keine Langzeitevidenz gibt und dass sie nie eine Behandlung für Geschlechtsdysphorie sein sollte.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male. My gender dysphoria began in childhood, and I now believe that the root cause of it was the traumatic and abusive childhood I grew up in — our family was and still is broken. I transitioned, and that period of my life lasted almost a decade; when I describe it now I say almost a decade of my life and all my life savings was flushed down the drain. During my transition I was on cross-sex hormones and blockers, and I quit them cold turkey without having had any blood work done yet. I also had at least some kind of surgery, since I refer to irreversible major damaging surgeries in the context of my own experience.
While I was still identifying as trans, I was already wary of gender ideology but accepted it without delving too deep, trying to distance myself from it and be as undetectable as possible. I isolated myself once I started transitioning. I came across the transmedicalist sect at one point and was excited to tell my sister about it, thinking I had figured out why deep down it all felt weird to me up until then — but beyond that one conversation we never really spoke about it. I also recall believing it was objective reality that I was the opposite sex, and I can't imagine what anyone could have said that would have convinced me otherwise at the time.
What moved me toward detransition was essentially realizing that the feeling that I was the opposite sex came down to an ingrained sense of what 'maleness' is through societal roles and expectations — that no matter how feminine my behaviour or interests are, that doesn't play a role in what sex I am. I had to heal and realize things on my own; no one helped me out. I described the whole experience as having a daze-like effect, as if that period of my life is blanketed in a thick haze, and I still feel a bit of the residue of that haze, just coming out of it — like waking up from a dream. I quit hormones cold turkey. Since detransitioning I have not had any blood work done yet.
I now describe the treatment I received as a satanic 'treatment' of gender dysphoria and consider it malpractice. I have looked into whether anyone has taken legal action against medical providers over this, because almost a decade of my life and all my life savings is gone and I'm doing pretty bad financially as a result. I'm doing pretty badly financially overall because of the transition.
I do not agree with the standard 'personal choice and autonomy' framing: I believe these are harmful choices being made through mental anguish, illness, and trauma, and beginning as a child in both my case and my sister's case. I think nobody should be able to transition, that transitioning is a highly destructive process with zero basis in long-term data, and that therapy addressing the root cause of gender dysphoria is what actually works. I've cited the Swedish Dhejne study (20-fold increased suicide rate 10–15 years post-surgery) and the SEGM/AJP correction on gender-affirming surgeries not improving mental health. I've also shared a case report of a gender dysphoric patient treated successfully with Pimozide. I've argued that medical professionals have a duty to properly treat patients rather than blindly follow a mentally-ill patient's desired treatment, and that children cannot consent to these interventions.
My sister started identifying as trans a few years after I did, while I was still caught up in it. She is barely a legal adult now and is already medically transitioning, which is a big reason for my concern. She puts pronouns and 'die TERFs' on her social media. The rest of our family is vehemently and mindlessly pro-everything-trans and treats my detransition with a dismissive 'oh ok, well we accept you whatever you do. :)' I feel somewhat responsible for getting her out of it, though I'm unsure how much my transition actually influenced her. I've been trying to support her as a person while leaving sex out of things, and I'm considering raising my concerns with our mother. I don't feel comfortable using male pronouns and a male name for her, but stopping outright would ruin our relationship, so I feel stuck. I don't want to be yet another enabler.
I have been misgendered as female exclusively right now, and having to explain to people that I'm actually male and have them not believe me or think I'm a 'trans-man' is humiliating and draining. I've described myself as a mentally-ill abused child whose self-destruction was enabled by family. I've been hostile toward people I see as defending transition, telling one commenter 'Some people want to be victims so bad' and mocking a post that said 'half a decade ago' as meaning five years.
I'm now out of transition and say my life has gotten so much better already and I've become happy, though I still feel some residue of the haze. I want to continue improving my life and rekindle my relationship with my sister and the rest of my family. I've pushed back on the idea that some people benefit from transitioning, calling it a pervasive myth, and I've defended Catholicism against criticism in a thread about religion and mental health.