Alle Geschichten

Sechzig Jahre Butch, keine Transition zu bereuen

Weiblich · Desistiert941
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin eine heterosexuelle, gender-nonkonforme Frau, fast 60, die von Kindheit an ein Tomboy war und sich in meinen Zwanzigern in einen androgynen Look einfand. Ich hatte nie Geschlechtsdysphorie oder -euphorie, bin nie medizinisch transitioniert und benutze das Label „cis“ nicht – ich bin einfach eine Frau und Feministin, die sich nicht um Gender sorgt. Ich mache mir Sorgen, dass soziale Medien und TikTok GNC-Ausdruck mit trans Identität und Medikalisierung vermengen, und erwarte eine Welle von Detransitionierten. Ich rate den Leuten, ihren Geschlechtsausdruck nicht zu medikalisieren oder zu pathologisieren und Influencer zu meiden. Ich bin nicht trans, bereue keine Transition (da ich nie transitioniert bin) und identifiziere mich derzeit schlicht als GNC-Butch-Frau.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born and raised a tomboy. I was always looking for role models — among celebrities there were few, in sports a few more, and around me some. When I got older and LGB rights became more of a topic, I remember thinking future girls would have wonderful tomboy role models. I saw that for a long time: proud women dressed as they wanted, more women came out and went on with their lives. I was thrilled when my niece was born and turned out to be a tomboy from an early age, because I thought she'd have plenty of tomboy role models regardless of sexual orientation. I never experienced gender dysphoria or gender euphoria. I don't "feel like" anything — I just am. I've never understood what people mean when they say they feel like a particular gender, and I've never understood gender euphoria either. I don't feel any "phoria" (eu or dis) about my gender; it just is. I don't particularly feel like a woman — I just am. I'm GNC and straight. In my teens I tried to "dress like a girl," but in my 20s I settled into an androgynous look, and that felt right and got easier and easier over the years. I describe myself as a straight butch woman, nearly 60. I'm a tomboy and would have chosen that flair if it had been an option. I don't use "cis" to describe myself and I feel no need to add a label at this age to juxtapose with another label. I'm a feminist; I don't worry about gender, and my feminism has nothing to do with cis-ness or trans-ness. I never medically transitioned — there's no account in my posts of hormones, surgery, or a transition/detransition process. My involvement in this community has been as a gender-nonconforming woman offering support and perspective to others. I worry that the TikTok version of gender identity discussions may not celebrate GNC girls and women, and that it's forgotten or lost in FtM trans conversations. I've said "GNC does not need to equate with trans" and "GNC does not need to equate with dysphoria," and that stereotypes and gender-conforming ideologies are rampant on social media — much of it regressive/retrogressive. I've predicted there will be a surge of detransitioners, and that in 10 years there will be studies looking at the impact of social media trends and TikTok on gender identity. My advice to people questioning has been: don't do anything medical yet; try not to medicalize or pathologize your gender expression and sexual orientation and preferences; stay away from "influencers" and kids who are lost on social media; and educate people when we encounter ignorant stuff, because such things also ignore and dismiss the work previous generations did. I've also noted the overlap or connection between transness and autism can't really be ignored, while being nervous about an autism registry under the current US administration. I've been an active, encouraging presence: telling people they look great, at peace in their bodies, beautiful, happy; affirming "there's no one way to be a woman"; encouraging people to be butch, be masculine, be themselves; and telling people they're not responsible to the trans community and get to live their one life how they want. I've defended JKR as a feminist with strong opinions on women's spaces, not trans. I've also expressed concern about MAGA politics spreading to other countries. I've been confused by downvotes and by posts of mine being flagged as rule violations. I don't have children of my own mentioned, but I have a niece (11 as of late 2023) who told me she's trans, and her replies at 11 all revolved around clothing and toys she "should want" if she were a cisgendered girl, plus comparisons to what her 16-year-old sister likes to wear and do.