Alle Geschichten

Wegen Mädchenhaftigkeit für trans gehalten – und nie aus seiner Stadt herausgekommen

Männlich · Desistiert263
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein detransitionierter/nie transitionierter heterosexueller Mann, männlich geboren, der sich nie als trans identifiziert hat, obwohl ich mädchenhaft bin, gelegentlich Crossdressing mache und immer wieder von anderen als trans oder schwul bezeichnet wurde. Begriffe wie „cis“ und „nichtbinär“ lehne ich als Beleidigungen ab und bestehe darauf, ein zu 100 % normaler Mann zu sein, der einfach er selbst ist. In meiner Kleinstadt wurde ich körperlich angegriffen, weil man mich für schwul hielt, und ich vermeide es, mit meiner Familie über Religion zu sprechen. Ich sehe die Trans-Bewegung kritisch, besonders medizinische Transition bei Kindern und das, was ich als Progressive sehe, die traditionelle Geschlechterrollen verstärken. Es geht mir nicht schlecht, und ich habe nicht vor, etwas zu ändern; ich will nur anderen helfen, sie selbst zu sein.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born male and I have never identified as trans — I'm a straight man who has always been girly. Growing up in a small town, I hung out with boys and was 'the weird kid'; as we got older and they got girlfriends, I was still the odd one out, but whenever games split by gender, their girlfriends always included me as one of the 'girls' and my male friends went along with it. I got along with women better, and both women and men generally assumed I was gay, except my real friends who knew I was straight and just knew I was weird and/or a diva. I like to dance, decorate, and be a diva, and I occasionally wear women's clothing and act as a woman — I've considered drag performances but I don't like going places alone, especially dressed as a woman, since straight people don't want to go with me and gay people don't think I'm sincere. I've been jumped several times for being 'gay' and have been persecuted and rejected for who I am in a small town. What frustrates me most is that because of the trans movement I get 'support' for being trans, which I find fucking disappointing. I hate having to say I'm not trans, I just like roleplaying as a woman sometimes; their response is either hate or 'support' telling me it's ok to not feel like the right sex. My response is: NO FUCK YOU! I'm weird, quit trying to label me as something else. I've never thought of myself as female or born in the wrong body. I don't deny my sex — I'm 100% a normal male. 'Cis' is a slur to me, and so is 'non-binary'; all these labels just label and marginalize people. I identify as myself, that's it. I accept that I can't change my body, and I accept that I am ME. I do whatever the fuck I want as long as it doesn't harm others. My big internal conflict has been with religion. It started when several different Catholic priests answered the same question differently; I had already questioned religion based on science, and then religious leaders gave me contradictory answers. I'm not struggling with religion now — it's just something I don't talk about with my family. It's easier to avoid the topic to keep everyone happy. They were also against me smoking weed until I moved to Colorado, and now they ask if I have enough medicine when we talk; changing states didn't change morality, but in their opinion it's OK for me to get high now. I feel the 'progressive' side is actually reinforcing traditional gender roles, and I'm tired of being labeled trans. Men and women have different (dis)advantages. People are people and everyone is different; science and biology are not disputable. Just because I act and dress differently than standard gender roles does not mean I am the other gender, nor do I believe it. I made my post to support others and was astonished at the support and kind words because I'm not struggling. I don't need support for being myself, but I may read it anyway — it may help me help others, which is all I really care about. I have no intention of changing; I'm being the change I want to see in the world — that people can be people. On the topic of children and medical transition, I looked up the UK court case after seeing it mentioned and read a BBC article noting lawyers arguing children cannot give informed consent to puberty-delaying or transition treatment. My reaction was '#WTF — Lawyers have to argue that children cannot make informed medical decisions. This is fucking crazy. Kids can't make medical decisions. That right there is a rock solid case.' I also argued that trans can't simultaneously be accepted and considered a mental illness — if it's a mental illness it can be cured; if it's to be accepted it's still non-normative, and non-normative people will be made fun of just like mathletes, choir, band, goths, preps, rich, or poor. Being different isn't easy.