Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine desistierte Frau, die sich in meinen frühen Zwanzigern etwa drei Jahre als genderfluid/bigender/nichtbinär/FtM identifizierte, aber nie Hormone nahm oder operiert wurde. Ich desistierte, nachdem ich erkannt hatte, dass Weiblichsein die einzige Voraussetzung für das Frausein ist, dass auch cis Menschen ihr Geschlecht nicht „fühlen“ und dass die Trans-Ideologie erschöpfende gedankliche Widersprüche verlangte. Mit 25 wurde bei mir ADHS sowie Angst und Depression diagnostiziert, eine genetische Untersuchung zeigte eine hohe pränatale Androgenexposition, und ich sah eine Gender-Therapeutin, die mich nur bestätigte, statt meine Dysphorie zu erkunden. Ich habe weiterhin Restdysphorie im Genitalbereich und soziale Dysphorie, bin aber viel glücklicher und beschäftige mich nicht mehr damit, wie andere mich lesen. Ich identifiziere mich derzeit als Frau, bin gender-kritisch und bleibe kritisch gegenüber Transition als Behandlung von Dysphorie, während ich Sympathie für trans Menschen bewahre.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female. I realized I was bisexual at around age 12, and I never felt especially girly growing up. I always felt like I was failing somehow at performing femininity, and people told me I had a face that could pass in either direction. My in-person and online voice was gendered as male numerous times. I was teased a lot as a child and teenager for having more body hair than guys my age, for visible facial hair on my cheeks, neck, and chin, for a low voice (people told me straight up I sounded like a man sometimes), and for not having big enough breasts. I was also teased for my thick, dark body hair clashing with my skin. Despite all this I was a normal looking girl and had no issues finding men attracted to me as I got older, but it didn't keep me from being dysphoric. How could I simultaneously be a 'cute' girl and have all these 'boyish' traits?
I never felt discomfort with being female itself — I was actually proud to be a woman — but there was a buzzing undercurrent in the back of my mind with thoughts like 'i could pass for a guy if I tried' and 'i really want to be a man in my next life.' I'd had intense social dysphoria for a long time and found myself going to great lengths as a child and teenager to hide my gender so people couldn't tell whether I was a girl or a boy, because I hated that they would assume things about me either way. I'd always had bottom dysphoria — I've never been connected to my vagina, periods felt like a punishment, and I never wanted kids. Sex was nice only after I got past it being painful and uncomfortable. I also had what I describe as autoandrophilia for most of my life, but with zero interest in being a gay man — looking at gay male couples, yaoi, or gay porn did nothing for me sexually. I wanted a dick, but I wanted to use it with a woman. Because most online discussion said AAP either wasn't real or always came with autohomoeroticism, and that wasn't me, I thought maybe I was really supposed to be a guy.
At 12 I realized I was bisexual but preferred men. The only women I'd seen dress very masculine were butch lesbians or bi women who preferred women — there were no straight or male-leaning bi women who looked like that, so I figured I must be trans. I didn't see myself in butch lesbians, and performing femininity felt like 'putting on a shirt several sizes too small.' The genderqueer/trans community gave me a sense of belonging I couldn't get elsewhere.
Over about three years in my early 20s I struggled heavily with my gender identity. I identified as genderfluid, bigender, nonbinary, and FtM at various points. I came out to my friends and my mom as genderfluid — they were all supportive. I bought a binder, packed my closet with men's clothes, used male pronouns or no pronouns, packed, used the men's bathroom, and had a male persona in many online spaces before coming out in real life. I did everything except cut my hair (I wanted long hair regardless of gender) and never changed my name. I joined a support group and saw a gender therapist online. I was flirting with the idea of testosterone for a few years on and off, but I never went on hormones and never had any surgery, so I'm technically a desister.
What moved me toward desisting was mental exhaustion. A lot of trans ideology never sat right with me — I didn't understand the transracial comparison, or how people could say they 'felt' like a man or woman when they'd never been one. There was a lot of mental acrobatics required, believing in contradictions, and eventually it got so tiring. The support groups made my doubts louder. What really 'peaked' me was a conversation with a trans friend who said, 'Even if I'm not fully a boy I can still be more masculine' — and I thought, why can't you be a girl and be more masculine? The facade crumbled when I applied that thinking to myself. Reading claims from cis people that they didn't 'feel' like their birth sex, and reading study after study debunking sexed brains, helped too. I realized there was no difference between myself and them, even though I had dysphoria and still do.
I also saw a gender therapist who only affirmed me, insisting repeatedly that I was nonbinary or 'not a woman' somehow, and coddling me with 'you are valid' instead of getting to the root of my dysphoria. Later I found a grief counselor I'd clicked with and felt comfortable sharing my dysphoria with, but my free sessions ended. I'm currently seeing a therapist I can talk to about my dysphoria without her encouraging transition. Before desisting I was diagnosed with ADHD, anxiety, and depression — the ADHD diagnosis at age 25 surprised me, since my doctor said it can go undiagnosed in females for a long time. I'm not autistic as far as I know.
I also had genetic testing done which showed a very high probability I was exposed to high levels of androgens before I was born. I have a typically male ring finger to index finger ratio and a muscle composition more common in people with high testosterone. My trans friends pointed to this as confirmation I might really be a guy, but I now see it as just one of many diverse manifestations of female.
I desisted after about 3 years. I slowly stopped talking about trans things, told my non-trans friends I wasn't identifying any particular way anymore and that she/her pronouns were fine, and if anyone asked why I'd explain how my thinking had changed without leading with it. I never came out at work. I'm now in my late 20s and I identify as a woman, simply by virtue of being female.
I still have dysphoria — I still struggle with the urge to be seen as genderless or male at times, and I still feel like I should have a penis instead of a vagina — but I'm working on it. I'm desisted and comfortable with being female. I still have bottom dysphoria and social dysphoria since childhood, but I no longer despair over not being able to 'live as a woman.' I'm very happy now, no longer trying to be something I'm not and no longer hung up on how other people see me.
I have trans friends, including a close friend I met when we were both struggling with gender identity who is now FTM. Trans stuff turns my stomach now when it's brought up, but I haven't said anything about desisting because I don't want to ruin the friendship. I consider myself gender critical (GC) as well as desisted. I've been active in detrans communities, proposing wiki additions about social detransition and sharing my experience. I don't believe transition is a good treatment for dysphoria — I compare it to giving lipo to someone who thinks they're fat — and I'm critical of what I see as trans ideology, though I have sympathy for trans people and don't wish anyone ill.