Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die jahrelang in Detransitions- und geschlechtskritischen Reddit-Räumen anderen geraten hat, sich Zeit zu geben, irreversible Eingriffe zu stoppen oder zu vermeiden, Depressionen zu behandeln und ihr Leben neu aufzubauen, statt den verlorenen Jahren nachzutrauern. Ich vertrete geschlechtskritische Ansichten („Team Terf“), lehne aber Feindseligkeit gegenüber Detransitionierten entschieden ab und trete für ihre Unterstützung ein. Ich bin nicht pauschal gegen die Transition, denn ich habe jemandem gesagt, ich hielte die Retransition für richtig für ihn oder sie. Meine eigenen medizinischen Details, meine Familie oder meine Sexualität schildere ich in diesen Kommentaren nicht. Suizidgedanken, Selbstverletzung oder Suizidversuche werden nicht erwähnt.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and I have been active in detransition and gender-critical spaces on Reddit since early 2020, mostly offering advice and arguing with others rather than posting my own story. Early on I was protective of detransitioners, pushing back against hostility toward them: I told someone off for being aggressive, wrote that 'those detrans people need support and help, not your self-righteousness, contempt and needless aggression,' and defended a community member I felt was being harassed and chased out of a space that should have been hers. I also worried that gender-critical users who were not themselves detransitioned would get the subreddit deleted by Reddit if they flooded it.
I have given a lot of medical and practical advice to others considering or reversing transition. I told someone contemplating an orchiectomy to cancel it and give themselves time. I told someone who had stopped hormones that most changes would reverse on their own — hip fat would go away, hair would grow back, and only breast tissue might remain. I have asked people their ages, when they started HRT, whether facial hair could grow back, and whether they could stop puberty blockers on their own or speak to a doctor without their parent present. I have also been sympathetic to parents whose children were medically transitioned, saying medical professionals 'just follow the process they are told to follow' and didn't believe the child could change their mind.
On the question of regret and lost time, I have written to younger detransitioners in a reassuring, mentoring tone: 'You are still very young, young enough to reinvent yourself. Don't waste time and energy wishing for what could have been. This is a road to more depression. What's done is done, and plenty of people have a bad adolescence spent waiting for it to end. Don't romanticize the lost years, they probably would have been shitty if you didn't try to transition too.' I added, 'You are still basically a kid, so it's normal if you don't know who you are yet... Those years taught you things, and now you are free,' and urged them to prioritize recovery, treat depression with a doctor, and go find friends, hobbies and jobs. This suggests I see the pre- and post-transition period as difficult either way and that I frame recovery around moving forward rather than dwelling on regret.
I have also told someone who seemed to be re-transitioning that 'plenty of people transition for the first time in their late 20's and beyond and find happiness. You need to try again if you think that's the right path for you,' which shows I am not blanket-opposed to transition for everyone. At the same time, I identify with gender-critical views — in one heated exchange I said 'Honestly I am team terf' while calling the person I was arguing with hateful and delusional. I have argued that trans women who pass are not a practical concern in women's bathrooms ('If she passes you wouldn't even know'), while maintaining that bigger battles like males in women's sport and rapists in women's jails matter more. I have also made passing-focused comments to others, noting that in photos someone 'look[s] like a trans woman, so not passing,' and that face portraits under flattering lighting don't reflect women's bodies, voices, gait or hands.
I have been combative online: I have told people to 'fuck off,' blocked users I called passive-aggressive and vindictive, and accused others of being condescending, cult-like and toxic. I have argued against rigid ideas about reproductive value, defending gay and childless people by asking whether Da Vinci made society weaker. I have also critiqued gender essentialism, warning someone they were 'naturalizing and so excusing and perpetuating gendered violence and gendered inequalities' and that 'tolerance is not enough.'
I do not describe my own transition, surgeries, hormones, mental health diagnoses, family, sexuality, or the specific reasons I detransitioned in these comments. What is visible is that I am a detransitioned or desisted female who has spent five years in these communities advising others, that I hold gender-critical views while opposing cruelty toward detransitioners and trans people alike, and that I encourage others to give themselves time, seek medical help for depression, and focus on rebuilding their lives rather than mourning lost years.