Alle Geschichten

Sechs Monate Östrogen, dann trotzdem die Mastektomie

Männlich · Detransitioniert161
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich wurde als Mann geboren, identifizierte mich als trans, begann mit 21 etwa 2018–2019 per informierter Einwilligung die HRT, erkannte aber nach 6–7 Monaten, dass ich keine soziale Transition wollte und die Wirkungen der HRT mich aufwühlten. Ich plante eine doppelte Mastektomie, während ich sonst mit androgynem Auftreten bei der HRT bleiben wollte, und ich beschreibe mich als Detransitionierten aus dem kleinen Prozentsatz, dessen schlechte Erfahrung mit wachsenden Brüsten und erektiler Dysfunktion schwerer wog als die Angst vor Maskulinisierung. Ich sehe sowohl Trans-Aktivismus als auch gender-kritischen Aktivismus kritisch und setze mich dafür ein, Transitionsentscheidungen als einzelne, praktische Entscheidungen zu behandeln und nicht als Identitätsfragen. Mitte 2020 war ich noch auf HRT und hatte die Mastektomie im Transkript noch nicht abgeschlossen.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born male, and I identified as trans for a while — I describe myself as "mtftm kinda," a baby detransitioner compared to some of the people I was talking to. I decided to transition a little over a year before early 2020, so around late 2018 or early 2019, and even then I had serious doubts about whether I was really trans. After 6 or 7 months of exploring things I realized a social transition wasn't something I even wanted, and that some of the effects of HRT were upsetting me as much as my masculine features used to. I started HRT through informed consent at a clinic when I was 21 — nobody walked me into that clinic but me — and my diagnosis at the time said "unspecified endocrine disorder." One of the biggest shocks was that the doctors told me finasteride was an antiandrogen; it took me a while to figure out that one. By early 2020 I was still on HRT but planning a double mastectomy. I posted asking other AMABs who had gotten top surgery about cost, insurance coverage, and whether breasts kept growing afterwards. I said I was still on HRT, getting my breasts removed but nothing else, and that my presentation was "pretty androgynous." I told people that breast tissue growth is permanent but that without estrogen the tissue will atrophy somewhat, and that after a double mastectomy focusing on breast tissue removal it won't regrow. I also noted that the only actual side effects a cis male would have issue with are erectile dysfunction/infertility, breast growth, and fat redistribution affecting figure and facial fat — the last of which I personally didn't care about. What I regretted was the growing breasts and erectile dysfunction. I said that only a small percentage of detransitioned males, "like me," end up having a bad enough experience with growing breasts and erectile dysfunction to outweigh the fear of masculinization and realize something is wrong. I originally transitioned for a reason — if I'd hated looking feminine I would never have mistaken myself for trans. I'd been online since I was about 10 and had "like 20 things people would call me"; my boyfriend used the androgynized version of my girl name because that's what I was calling myself when we met, but mostly people went back to my birth name. I also mentioned being introduced by a gender-neutral third name I didn't even use anymore when visiting a friend whose housemate had trans roommates, and said I wondered what other people thought of me — "it's kinda spooky." On causes, I attributed my transition partly to femboy memes on social media, boys in cartoons who wear skirts and makeup without it being a joke, and one character in one piece of media I could relate to about my body image issues who then solved them in a believable way — "one little twink kid" played up as pretty and desired rather than as the nerdy kid or jokester. I thought culture likes tomboys more than tomgirls, that both get gaslit into thinking they're trans, but there are more tomboys because it's more socially acceptable, and that anyone who gets gaslit eventually realizes and detransitions, which is why there are more female detransitioners than males. I did a lot of thinking and advising about how to decide. I told others to take it piecemeal — not to worry about whether they should stop transitioning as a whole, but to break it into discrete choices: should you stop T, should you ask close friends to refer to you as female, should you wear clothing you like instead of clothing designed to help you pass. I said whether you are trans is "not only impossible to divine without first hand experience, it is also inconsequential" — instead of asking "am I trans?" or "do I have dysphoria?", ask "what are the chances going on testosterone is a good thing for me, and what are the chances I'll regret it?" I distinguished real dysphoria ("not having a flat chest makes me uncomfortable") from discomfort rooted in sexualization ("having breasts makes people sexualize me which makes me uncomfortable"), and argued that ROGD is a meme but gaslighting isn't — that people convince you to misclassify things as gender dysphoria that aren't. I also said that when externally stressed — a hard test, a breakup, or even thinking you might be trans — your dysphoria and things you may misclassify as dysphoria get worse, and that I feel less comfortable with myself when my mental state is worse (not eating or sleeping, stressed, sick). I was critical of both sides of the discourse. I pushed back on a 60% detransition rate claim, noting the cited study was about desistance before hormones, and said pointing out detransition's high suicide rates was pointless since those are the same rates common in trans people who do NOT transition. I argued against blanket bans on medical transition for under-18s because some people do need HRT and would seek gray market sources, while acknowledging puberty blockers have more dangerous side effects than full HRT and that a lot of under-18s do regret transitioning. I said most detransitioners are tired of being used to prop up such arguments. I criticized r/detrans itself for having diluted subject matter — advice posts from people who haven't transitioned, GC ideology posts — and for having rules against TRA activists but none against TERF activists or ROGD parents with no firsthand experience of dysphoria. I was wary of r/gendercritical refugees "shitting up" the sub and said there's a difference between a detrans ally GC or radfem posting about detransition and being predatory of a space that doesn't belong to them. I also said most detransitioners are GC at least a little — "critical of the system that profits off of us." On sexuality and identity, I said I was still on HRT with an androgynous presentation, and that even if your identity changed it doesn't change how you are physically; the people into trans women and the people into GNC males have a large overlap, and most of the part that doesn't overlap is filled with dudes repressing their sexuality "that you should avoid anyway." I told someone that even with all the testosterone and surgeries, topping for them wouldn't ever be the same as a male topping. I encouraged people to read the full list of testosterone effects and decide logically rather than from gut instinct, and said if it has more negative effects than positive, it doesn't matter if you are trans or not: you shouldn't take it. I also told someone that ideology fucked them over once and not to let it happen again — you have two options, testosterone or estrogen, go over the pros and cons and decide from there. I don't have any explicit statements in this transcript about surgeries completed beyond planning the double mastectomy, about fertility outcomes for myself, about formal therapy, or about my current identity beyond being "mtftm kinda" and still on HRT as of mid-2020.