Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine desistierte Person, die die Transition ablehnte, nachdem ich in Zeiten schwerer Geschlechtsdysphorie tief in Trans-Räumen und auf 4chan versunken war und mich mit der Forschung zum Gehirngeschlecht beschäftigt hatte, die ich als „genau die Argumentationslinie und Begründung, die mich desistieren ließ“ bezeichne. Heute sehe ich Transition sehr kritisch, beschreibe Trans-Räume als „Sumpf der Verzweiflung“ und argumentiere, dass die männlichen Körper von Transfrauen nicht mit weiblichen Körpern austauschbar sind. Trotzdem versuche ich, im persönlichen Umgang respektvoll zu sein, und plädiere dafür, andere so zu behandeln, wie man selbst behandelt werden möchte. Ich habe anderen Unterstützung angeboten, die überlegen, Hormone abzusetzen, oder mit Männlichkeit hadern. Operationen, medizinische Details oder eine aktuelle Identitätsbezeichnung über das Desistieren hinaus habe ich nicht offengelegt.
Vollständige Geschichte
I came to my views on transition through my own gender dysphoria, which reached deep points where I spent time on 4chan and immersed myself in trans spaces — I am friends with many trans people and follow both transgender and 'transsexual' accounts. That immersion became what I call my assessment of the situation: I came to see trans people as dissociated from truth, fixated on what I described as 'a false narcissistic identity wrapped in a byzantine web of unprocessed trauma,' constantly coping and needing to convince others they made the right decision or else their sense of self would collapse. For some I believe it is 'a bonafide fetishistic paraphilia.' I argued that transition is just as unhelpful as letting gender dysphoria fester — 'a psychological problem should be procedurally investigated rather than submitted to' — and that no growth comes from 'abandoning yourself and playing pretend.' I acknowledged this might be an insensitive sweeping generalization and asked for further perspective, but as I saw it these spaces were 'an inexorable constant... a cesspool of desperation, self-loating, and strident nonsensical gender stereotypes. In short, it is mentally ill.'
The reasoning that led me to desist involved brain-sex science: I noted that brains are 'a heterogeneous mosaic of male and female characteristics' that cannot be aligned to a strict continuum, while acknowledging sexually dimorphic areas like the preoptic area of the hypothalamus (POA) and bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BNST). I argued that having brain areas similar to the opposite sex would not make you the opposite sex, and that hormone therapy may itself alter trans people's brains. I said this line of reasoning was 'the exact line of reasoning and rationale that made me desist' and that I was called transphobic for suggesting it. 'All this to say, there is little logic behind transness to me.'
On trans women specifically, I argued that if they truly understood the reality of being a woman they would respect that 'their male bodies are not interchangeable with a females,' that they 'objectively experience a different reality and that they may, regardless of identity, pose a threat,' and that they would not encroach on cis women's boundaries or appropriate their struggles. 'That is why i feel that they aren't secretly women and never have been.' I also described a trans woman I know as fitting HSTS typology: 'very self centered, insecure, cluster-b personality homosexual male. attention seeker and always in competition with others, especially women.'
Despite these strong views, I try to be measured in person: I compared my skepticism of transness to my skepticism of religion, saying I rarely voice it because it could hurt religious friends whose faith connects them to culture, family, and collective resilience, and concluded 'just treat others as you'd like to be treated, even if you hold a diverted perspective about a topic from them.'
I have advised a long-term testosterone user to stop hormones if they want to stop being male-presenting, telling them to let their body 'readjust back to homeostasis of a female hormone cycle' and that being female-presenting doesn't require frilly dresses or a soft appearance, especially given masculine changes from long-term testosterone. I also encouraged a natal male struggling with masculinity, telling him many women prefer nontraditionally masculine men — 'i know i do, and i tend to gravitate to trans women and GCN men' — that 'if you are a natal male, you have nothing to prove. you're already enough,' and that many detransitioners learn this during self-discovery. I noted seeing a femboy video — 'makeup, feminization surgeries, and everything--who exclusively dates women.'