Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich wurde männlich geboren und sollte am 21. April 2020 mit Hormonen beginnen, habe aber desistiert und will jetzt als Mann leben. Ich sprang ab, nachdem ich die Nebenwirkungsliste der informierten Einwilligung gelesen und gemerkt hatte, dass Herzkrankheiten und Diabetes in meiner Familie stark verbreitet sind, und das Gefühl hatte, Hormone wären „die längste und teuerste Form von Suizid aller Zeiten“. Ich erkannte auch, dass mein Transitionswunsch mit einem fetischistischen Wunsch, eine Frau zu sein, und mit tiefem Selbsthass zusammenhing, den eine Transition nicht beheben würde, und die Vorstellung, unfruchtbar zu werden, machte mir Angst. Ich bleibe kritisch gegenüber dem medizinischen Establishment und der Transition im Allgemeinen und verteidige das aktiv auf r/detrans. Ich bin ein desistierter Mann, der sich als Mann identifiziert.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male and had been planning to transition to live as a woman. I was scheduled to start hormones on April 21, 2020, but instead I desisted and decided to live and die as male. Before the appointment I was already having second thoughts, and I wanted to be sure my hesitation wasn't just nervousness. Several days earlier I had a dream about my future, in which I was a guy planning a move I intend to make later that year, and in the dream I met a girl and started dating her. That dream helped me realize I still had real aspirations as a guy and that transitioning would kill those dreams.
The decisive factor was the informed-consent paperwork the clinic emailed me. It contained a checklist of effects and side effects, and reading it frightened me: liver damage, stroke, heart attack, increased fat around the internal organs associated with increased risk for diabetes and heart disease, high blood pressure, and gallstones. I noted that this increases the risk for the #1, #5, and #6 causes of death in the United States. I know heart disease and diabetes run heavily in my family, with a lot of heart disease, so I felt that taking hormones would have been "the longest and most expensive form of suicide ever." I also believed the science showed hormones would be worse for my heart than red meat.
I had earlier considered the health risks of estrogen for male-bodied people, including a higher risk of blood clots, and noted that the large amount of heart disease in my family made that a major red flag for me. I was critical of doctors who, in my view, hand-wave those risks away because "it makes them feel better mentally," and I felt the truth about these risks is obscured by unconditional affirmation with nobody willing to say "stop don't do it."
I came close to being "ensnared" in transition myself and desisted because I knew for a fact I would ruin myself. I now say plainly that I find transition ruining for almost everyone and don't think people should do it, while also believing that someone can be ruined and then come back to catch greatness and worth. I described my own motivation bluntly: there is a ton about myself that I have always hated and I wish I could be way different than I actually am, and I realized transition would never have fixed any of that. The solution, I thought, was to find another way: a therapist or a priest, a new hobby, or figuring out how to strangle what I hate about myself. I acknowledged I still have trouble figuring that out.
On the fetish question, I said the fetish concern is a legitimate one and difficult to separate out, and that I had the same questions, which is what made me decide to desist. I described my desire for a woman becoming an unhealthy desire to be a woman, which if realized would have made sexual relationships more difficult rather than less, and I said the idea of becoming infertile scares the bejeezus out of me.
I also discussed medical realities for male-bodied people who do transition: breast tissue from hormones does not go away, whether erections and sperm recover depends on how atrophied the tissue is from not having had erections and on when hormones were started, and someone who started hormone blockers at 12 would have no penile development and therefore no male fertility. I recalled an article about a woman who quit testosterone and had massive withdrawals that landed her in hospital, with testosterone having caused weight gain and pre-diabetic state, and I advised staying in constant conversation with a doctor while coming off hormones because the body is having its hormones totally inverted once again.
I was active in r/detrans, defending the community against a critic. I argued it is completely natural for people there to feel betrayed by the doctors and psychologists who handed them hormones, and that the anger people call "gaslighting" is like that of exes towards each other—there was love there once. I said that if everything were hunky dory between these people and the trans community, almost all of them would still be trans. I also commented that r/mtf is really toxic even for trans Reddit.
I gave advice to others considering detransition, including telling someone that they will still have breasts since that tissue is not going to go away, and encouraging a young woman at university who felt she lacked social skills that many people her age feel the same way, suggesting therapy and telling her to hit on some boys she likes. I advised a partner of a person considering detransition to talk positively about their partner's penis, to say they will always be there if their partner detransitions, and to treat them more like the man in the relationship in positive ways. I suggested to someone that they could make fun of overcompensating men and talk about how lonely and insecure men are, to show that the grass is not greener on the other side. I told a detransitioned woman she should be proud to have been born with that sex, noting that people born male in the trans community would give anything to be born the way she was. I complimented a detransitioning woman's appearance, saying that in female-to-male timelines the before picture is a really cute girl and the after has ruined themselves, and that going in reverse was good. I also said I personally wouldn't call the underlying issues behind dysphoria biological, pointing instead to social factors like boys growing up poorly socialized as male without a father or with a poor relationship with him.