Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die von 2019 (mit 27) bis Oktober 2021 (mit 29) Testosteron nahm, die Brust-OP absagte und nach einem Burnout mit dem Medizinsystem aufhörte; meine Periode kam etwa zwei Monate später zurück. Meine Transition folgte auf den Tod meines Vaters 2015, in dessen Verlauf ich mit Schuldgefühlen, zwei Suizidversuchen, starkem Trinken und Drogenkonsum kämpfte, und ich wurde von Tumblr- und YouTube-Trans-Communities beeinflusst. Ich identifiziere mich heute als Frau, bereue die Transition und will Stabilität, einen Job, einen Ehemann und Kinder, während ich mir Sorgen um meine Fruchtbarkeit mache und darum, es einem Mann zu sagen, den ich treffe. Ich sehe die Trans-Community, in der ich war, als sektenartig, bleibe aber offen für trans Menschen, die ehrlich über die Nachteile sind. Ich habe mich nicht formell engagiert, außer mit der Idee, die Klinik in Illinois herauszufordern, die an meiner Behandlung beteiligt war.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and grew up as the youngest child in an Irish- and German-American family. My father was a central figure in my childhood — I was, in his words, his youngest — and he groomed me to be a great artist in his stead, chopped my hair off, dressed me in boys' clothes, and called me "butch." My mother was often absent because she and my dad were at his appointments. My dad got sick when I was 15, and from that point on I shouldered a lot of guilt; my feelings and actions weren't my own but for the benefit of the family. I took up cooking and cleaning because no one else was around to do it. During his illness I turned on him in rage at being forced out of the home and forgotten, telling him I couldn't wait for him to finally die — and he chose that moment to tell me he was in palliative care. He died in 2015 at 56. I spent six years not forgiving him or myself, and it only hurt myself and others. I tried to take my own life twice during that period, and I drank a lot.
I was on Tumblr during those years, furious at losing my dad and wanting to make something right. Wokeism took off during that time and was, in retrospect, too comforting, too good to be true. I was political and combative but got nothing done. I started seeing trans people being lauded for mere words and got envious. I was lonely and the trans community felt like the popular kid table I was eager to join, because I thought if I was one of them I could make things right. I also recall a lot of drug use going on in trans circles — that was where most of my bad habits took off; I'd smoke and drink a ton, and while detoxing I'd feel awful about my body. I was very suggestible while under the influence, so testosterone seemed like a not-at-all-dangerous thing to put in my body.
I started testosterone in 2019 at age 27. I was prescribed through Howard Brown, where one appointment was enough and afterward I walked out with T. My endocrinologist kept me on 0.25 units while my period wouldn't go away and vaguely suggested bumping it up; I did my own research on typical doses, started at 0.50 and peeled down to 0.35, told my doctor, and she was fine with it and matched my prescription. About a year on T, I heard that detransitioners "are not like trans ppl, they're motivated by some sort of trauma," had a moment of "oh no..." but shelved it because I was already on the path and don't like to quit. I convinced myself I had gender dysphoria even as a child — the 5-year-old girl who threw a fit over having to get her hair cut short — and that I wasn't motivated by trauma.
Around a year or so into detransition I heard someone say detransitioners are motivated by trauma, and I also tried to mingle with TERFs shortly after detransitioning because it looked like they had my best interests at heart; what I found was more demands for conformity, and as soon as I disagreed they sent their follower attack dogs. "The enemy of my enemy is my friend" is not a good slogan to live by, it turns out.
I cancelled top surgery after being freaked out over it, mulled over the implications of surgically removing healthy body parts for a few months, and then quit T in October 2021 at age 29. It was also a case of being burned out with my involvement in the medical system and knowing I'd be in it for life if I wanted to keep this up. My menstrual cycle returned earlier in December 2021, about two months after stopping T (I had been on it for two years). I started feeling more normal shortly after my period came back. I said at the time: "it's not like estrogen was bad for my body, so why was i trying to keep it out?" and "nature and god already decided i do [a woman] by giving me femaleness."
After stopping T I experienced joint pain, fatigue, weight loss, eating problems, moles, and headaches, and worried these lined up with cancer — my family is, in my words, a batch of sitting ducks: cancer knocked out both my grandpas, my aunt has it, one of my sisters had a close call, and it killed my father. I was to wait until 36 to be screened for the same cancer that killed him. I also noted that the loss of my period really burned me and that without it I get forgetful and even more mean; my voice isn't that deep. I was off my psych meds (Lexapro and naltrexone) at one point, reasoning "fuck doctors if i don't need T then i don't need lexapro or naltrexone." I recently got into a fight with my mother, telling her her radfem views were equivalent to being a whore, and was castigated and tested and also forgiven.
I came to think of the trans community I had been in as resembling a cult, citing the BITE model, lovebombing on entry, being pushed to do more or not being enough, and outsiders labeled "cisgenders." I named YouTubers and Tumblr bloggers as influences. I also tried to pioneer a movement in Illinois against the clinic that let me do this to myself, reasoning that yes it was my dumb idea but they were the doctors and should have known better. I later reflected that I think of YouTubers as clandestine cult recruiters. I also came to distrust doctors more broadly, though I acknowledged I may have developed a codependent relationship with them because my life revolved around them and hospitals when my dad was sick.
I do regret transition. I think transition was a product of my wild 20s, looking for something risky to do that was mine and not my mother's. Now I'm 30 and want some stability, some transparency. I'm a woman, I'd like a job, a husband, maybe some kids. I took up laser hair removal to remove the beard growth for good, and also wanted it for my belly. In 2023 I experienced some bottom dysphoria after stopping weed, and connected drug use and suggestibility to my transition decision. I began seeing a man I liked who is Muslim, and worried about telling him about my detransition, my stubble, and my fertility — I said I took hormones and possibly smashed my eggs, and that I can give him kids but can't guarantee they'll be without developmental disadvantages. I described myself as a 31-year-old woman with a 51-year-old woman's burden and recently pulled a grey hair. I've never done anything with a guy. I have a co-worker who I felt was trying to prove me and this guy were a failed attempt. I currently work a customer-service-heavy job and have fostered resilience and fortitude from what I've been through; where before I let people push me around, nowadays I take it and sock it back to 'em.
I have been critical of trans ideology but not of every trans person: I believe trans people who approach their identity and the community with honesty are worth hearing out. I've been critical of trans women taking female conventions from anime as their model of womanhood, calling it misogynist. I've also expressed views skeptical of minors medically transitioning, and I've noted that I don't trust doctors anymore. I have not engaged in formal advocacy beyond the idea of pioneering a movement in Illinois against the clinic.