Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die als Mädchen geboren wurde, mit 24 nach einem Jahrzehnt Dysphorie und unbehandelter Angst mit Testosteron begonnen hat und etwa ein Jahr später aufgehört hat, als meine Stimme absackte und meinen Traum von einer Gesangskarriere zerstörte. Ich identifiziere mich heute als nonkonforme, etwas genderfluide Frau und bereue die Transition nicht mehr, während ich lerne, meine Androgynität zu akzeptieren, auch wenn ich um meine verlorene Stimme und die verlorene Zeit trauere. Ich glaube, dass meine „Dysphorie“ größtenteils unbehandelte Angst, Körperdysmorphie, verinnerlichte Frauenfeindlichkeit, Angst vor männlicher sexueller Aufmerksamkeit und affirmationsverzerrte Geschlechtertherapie war. Meine Stimme und mein Körper haben sich in den knapp zwei Jahren seit dem Absetzen von T deutlich erholt, und ich berate aktiv andere, nicht in die medizinische Transition zu hetzen. Ich war kurzzeitig grenzwertig suizidal, als meine Geschlechtertherapeutin mich fallen ließ, aber seitdem habe ich keine Suizidgedanken mehr gemeldet.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and grew up always androgynous and gender nonconforming. I had two major depressive episodes in my teens, largely tied to internalized Christianity and my unrequited love for another girl; it was bad enough that I flunked out of school. I never got a diagnosis or treatment at the time because my mother was poisoned against psychiatrists and medication, and because she feared a therapist would encourage me to embrace my sexuality, which she couldn't accept then.
Dysphoria waves started for me at 15 and never went away. I went to a gender therapist convinced I was trans at 22. Over the next two years with her I constantly exhibited symptoms of severe anxiety, obsessive thoughts and paranoia, but nothing was ever connected for me. When I finally asked her if she thought I had a mental condition, she casually said, 'well I definitely think you have some generalized anxiety.' I had also been scared beforehand that a diagnosis would hold me back from accessing transition if that was what I needed, so I was relieved rather than alarmed.
I pursued medical transition at 24, after 10+ years of varying confusion and dysphoria, arriving at certainty through deductive reasoning plus affirmation from friends and my gender therapist, who never helped me explore the origins of my feelings. I was on testosterone for a year altogether, slowly upping my dose, only seeing noticeable changes in the last 3 months; I swapped from topical to 75mg weekly shots for the last 2 months and gained about 15lbs of muscle. My arms and traps got very big, partly because my job (grocery stocking) had me bent over pulling crates for long periods. I passed 100% for about 6 months.
I now believe I arrived at transition from a cluster of factors: discomfort over having noticeable breasts (which I'd wanted to 'shrink into invisibility' since puberty, and which I now frame as dysmorphia rather than dysphoria); fear of and discomfort with straight male attention, including fear of being raped; experiences of being passed over for men in love, which made me feel my femaleness was a problem; internalized stigmatization of butch women; alienation by other women for being androgynous and nonconforming (misgendering in bathrooms, belittling of my masculine attributes); internalized misogyny (blaming my female hormones for making me weak, emotional, indecisive — which I later understood as symptoms of underexamined anxiety); affirmation-biased therapy that dismissed my anxiety and paranoia as irrelevant and treated my dysphoria as a 'guiding light'; exposure to pseudoscience about a 'transgender brain'; and finally an inability to locate a 'feeling of womanness,' which produced full-blown imposter syndrome whenever I was read as female. I also partly went on T to 'cure' my androgyny because I was tired of having zero control over how I was read minute to minute, and I subconsciously hoped male features (like a beard) would make me look my age — I was constantly mistaken for a high schooler in my mid-twenties, which was humiliating, especially in an age-gap relationship. I was also fully aware of wanting to be off the radar of men: I grew up in the shadow of #metoo and my sister having been raped repeatedly, and my mother raised me with projected fear; I believed transition would make me safe enough to finally become an independent adult.
My voice dropping was what made me realize transitioning was the wrong path. I was a self-taught singer-songwriter of 10 years with an expansive repertoire, right on the edge of pursuing it as a career, and T dropped my voice an octave (averaging 125hz) into what I called 'an unrecognizable nightmare.' That loss sent me spiraling into depression and led me to this community. I quit T shortly after my voice broke. I'm now 5 months, then later nearly 2 years, off T.
Post-T physical changes and their reversals: I lost all the muscle mass within about 2 months of stopping (depression cut my appetite). By 3.5 months off I was back to pre-T proportions. Facial and body hair thinned noticeably — the teen stache and happy trail receded, random dark chin and chest hairs disappeared. About a month after stopping, my breasts grew larger than pre-T (a rebound effect that made me want to bind again, which I resisted because I wanted to be female-passing). I developed shedding hair loss that only started after stopping T, which I theorized was telogen effluvium triggered by the shock to my body. My larynx/cartilage and bone mass grew on T; bone mass diminished after stopping but the larynx did not. I never developed a noticeable Adam's apple. I never had top surgery.
Voice issues: my voice got sore after normal use for almost 6 months after stopping T, mostly resolving by 8 months off. I saw a speech pathologist about refeminizing my voice but found speaking in a forced higher pitch made me feel no better — my voice was completely androgynous before and is now completely mannish, consistently gendering me male unless I strain it. I gave myself 7 years before seriously considering vocal surgery, since that's how long the body takes to fully replace tissues, and I've advised others to give time and training a chance and treat surgery as a very last resort. By nearly 2 years off, my singing voice had improved tremendously: I can use a range from bass-baritone to soprano, regained access to my whistle register around the 1.5-year mark, and can imitate Michael Bublé and LP. I learned from a doctor and an ENT that it's common for steroid-induced edema to take 2 years to fully subside. My practical advice: sing every day, focus on songs you don't know by heart to build new muscle memory, and use breathiness and diaphragmatic resonance to make speech read more feminine.
Mental health: I was never formally diagnosed before transition but suffered depression in my formative years and then severe untreated anxiety, which I now blame for blowing my dysphoria out of proportion and impairing my decision-making. I now believe what I called dysphoria was really misdiagnosed dysmorphia and internalized misogyny. I was borderline suicidal the last time I saw my gender therapist, who then dropped me like a hot potato when I expressed discontent with the transition she'd affirmed; it's been six months without even a text to check I'm still breathing. That left me with deep trust issues and resentment toward therapists. I've been seeking proper psychiatric help and a new therapist.
On detransition and recovery: I transitioned only partially. I'm now firmly female-identifying, though I've accepted my gender fluidity and have 'girl days' a month where I opt for more female presentation (drapier clothing, how I speak and carry myself, hair, dangly earrings — makeup is rare for me). Passing as female is still often a struggle; at nearly 30 with silver hairs I'm still read as a minor, which makes dating feel impossible (only teenage girls or creepy older men hit on me). I shaved my head in a fit after a 'mature' short haircut only made me look like a 15-year-old boy. I've relinquished the fight over how strangers gender me: pronouns no longer cripple my self-worth, and I throw comebacks at people who harass me in bathrooms. I no longer regret my transition as I learn to accept my gender fluidity, but I still grieve what T took from me. In May 2020 I wrote: 'There is nothing that will give me back the time and authentic self-expression that hormone therapy took from me. The rest of my life feels like an arduous journey of making the best of a damned existence. All I want is to go home to myself, but that person is no longer there.' I described being in a 'maimed state of being' over my voice and some largely permanent body changes, and said the loss of my singing career dream has caused me to reassess my personal values and life path as a whole. I have zero trust and much more resentment than love for myself at that point, and I've only told my closest friend about detransitioning because I don't want people to see how confused and ambivalent I feel. Still, I've said the good days are getting better, that reclaiming my voice is a choice, and that releasing blame is paramount — 'You found your way out, and that alone is a great achievement.' I've gone back to Stoic philosophy (recommending Sharon LeBell's 'The Art of Living') for centering, and I found the butchlesbians subreddit a great space for dysphoric female people. I also suspect I have Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, which runs in my family, and have gone through the pre-diagnosis hypermobility/skin-stretchiness screening for a genetic testing referral.
Sexuality: I identified as bi before and during transition; I was attracted to women and feminine men, and I flex my masculinity to appeal to bisexual men and feminine women, occasionally adding feminine flair for more macho males — a dynamic I did not consciously recognize for a long time.
On transition for others: I'm critical of how transition was offered to me. I wrote that 'all gender therapists are simply trained to affirm and validate, not ask pertinent questions,' and that my anxiety was wrongly treated as a consequence of untreated dysphoria. I'm opposed to 'trans egg culture' — memes that treat defying one sex stereotype as proof of being trans — calling it 'as statistically unsupported as it is psychologically invasive' given trans people are ~2% of the population. I distinguish intersex conditions (biological, usually diagnosed by a doctor) from trans identities, which I say lack substantial evidence of biological basis, while saying I'd happily support further research and would update my view if science validated the trans experience. I've come to see gender identity and social dysphoria as incongruence with worthless sex stereotypes, and I've had an epiphany that believing one was 'meant to be' one sex implies a kind of destiny that only exists for generations with access to gender transition — which contradicts the biological-basis theory of gender identity. I've also noted that the trans community's framing of 'you're trans' as the most likely explanation for nonconformity is unsupported. I do advocacy in the sense of writing long, detailed accounts for questioning people, urging them to carefully consider what they want and why before going further than they can come back from, and I offer direct mentoring and DMs to others struggling with voice loss.