Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine desistierte lesbische Frau, die nie medizinisch transitioniert ist und kurz davor war, mich als trans zu identifizieren, bevor ich vor Hormonen oder Operationen stoppte. Ich wuchs als Mormonin in einem rein weiblichen Haushalt auf, entwickelte in meinen Zwanzigern körperliche Dysphorie, teils als Reaktion darauf, sexualisiert zu werden, und verstand meinen Drang zur Transition als Vermeidung zugrunde liegender Probleme statt als Lösung. Ich habe lebenslange Depressionen und eine komplexe PTBS durch einen gewalttätigen Vater, habe Obdachlosigkeit erlebt, eine verheerende Trennung, die mich Job, Zuhause und Freunde kostete, und Jahre des Wiederaufbaus von Selbstständigkeit. Ich schwanke zwischen einer Brustverkleinerung und einer vollständigen Mastektomie, halte mich aber zurück, skeptisch gegenüber der Schönheits- wie der Trans-Medizinindustrie, und sehe Transition heute durch eine Suchtbrille und die Trans-Community als eine Religion, die ich verlassen habe. Ich bezeichne mich derzeit als geschlechtsnonkonforme lesbische Frau und sehe medizinische Transition und Geschlechtsidentität sehr kritisch.
Vollständige Geschichte
I have never medically transitioned, and I never got very far down the social transition path before I came to grips with my physical dysphoria. I describe myself as someone who desisted — I came really close to identifying as trans and pursuing medical transition, but I stopped short of hormones or surgery.
I was raised in a virtually all-female household and raised Mormon, with my dad's occasional presence when he wasn't working overtime or watching TV. I never experienced physical dysphoria as a kid. What I did experience was a lot of pressure around traditional gender roles — I never felt attached to the idea of marrying a man and having his babies, let alone raising them, and I rebelled against those notions at a very early age, though only privately in my head. My father could be abusive — he would yell, throw tantrums, and I remember dreaming about running away from home when he would start.
Physical dysphoria didn't start until my 20s. A lot of that, I think, comes from how blatantly men sexualize me, even in casual situations. I've come to understand that when I feel the deep, irrational urge to change my body, to transition, it's rooted in wanting to run away from something — sometimes being treated as a sex object by society, sometimes things not going well at work, sometimes realizing I'm not doing anything with my life I actually want to be doing. Transitioning isn't the answer; it's the impulse, but not the solution. It's the giant red flag waving to alert me that there's a problem my primitive lizard brain wants to avoid rather than confront. Underneath a new identity is still me, with all the same baggage and problems.
What kept stopping me was the seriousness and irreversibility of medical intervention. I was surrounded by trans and queer people who encouraged me to try it, telling me it was mostly reversible and that if I had that much dysphoria I should give it a try — but this never sat right with me. I could never see it as something that would give me freedom, only something that would make me dependent on the medical system. My goal was always to be a complete, self-sufficient person, and I couldn't help feeling the trans path would prevent that. I'm naturally distrustful of people who claim to have easy solutions to your problems, particularly if those solutions cost money, so the more I got pressured into medicalizing myself, the more my 'spidey senses' tingled that something wasn't right. Sitting with my dysphoria for so long while holding off on treatment helped me learn that I can manage it without 'snake oil salesmen giving me their magic drugs.'
I've spent a lot of time sitting still with these feelings of dysphoria and talking with trusted friends. About a year before I wrote about it (so roughly 2019), I remember a lot of nights lying in bed wishing I could scratch my body off like a scab because I couldn't stand being in it — at the time I had nothing I was running from that I knew of, and a lot of things to look forward to. Those nights were valuable, because the longer I sat with it, I eventually recognized how it made me feel: anxious and afraid. Once I saw those feelings woven in around the dysphoria, it started clicking that they're linked. Two or three years before that I would have said I wasn't running from anything.
I have exceptionally large breasts relative to my frame and have never had positive feelings about them. I've been waffling between a reduction and a full mastectomy for a long time, and every time I think I've landed on one, something changes and I'm up in the air again. One of the big things holding me back is the sense of regret I hear detransitioners talk about — the phantom limb stuff, the sense of having done something wrong to your body, the grieving. I have a consult with a surgeon booked for later in 2021 to get information from a qualified professional that the internet can't give me. I'm very skeptical of both the cosmetic surgery industry and the trans medical industry, so I'm trying to take things slow and be mindful of the bigness of any decisions. My personal philosophy is minimal medical intervention to the degree possible, case by case, with a competent therapist who is open to both the possibility of being trans and the possibility of being a woman with internalized misogyny.
I have lifelong depression and C-PTSD, among other confounding factors, which mean I might never be able to know how much of what I'm feeling is distortion and how much is real. C-PTSD doesn't come out of nowhere. I have a therapist who is great overall — she's very anti-diagnosis beyond what insurance requires, more interested in talking through my experience than pathologizing it. She's open to discussing gender-critical ideas and is concerned by childhood transition herself, so I don't feel she's trying to pigeonhole me. She isn't the therapist who originally diagnosed me. I've had a hard time maintaining close friendships in adulthood but have one or two deep friendships I can count on, which makes a big difference in my healing. The biggest challenge outside dysphoria, depression, and anxiety has been finding balance with my family — cutting myself off wasn't the solution, so now it's about rebuilding relationships with healthy boundaries.
I was a high school dropout at one point. In my twenties I based my identity on a long-term relationship; after four years she broke up with me, and in a single weekend I lost my job, my relationship, and the place I lived because we shared a home, plus most of my friends since we had a shared friend group. I moved out of state to live with my father for several months — he had been abusive in my childhood and we have a tense relationship, so it was a bad situation. I let myself become homeless because I stopped being self-reliant. It took years to reframe that event in terms of my own responsibility. I've also been through a period of homelessness where my only transportation was my bicycle — I was teaching martial arts at the time, cycling around 18 miles a day, burning through more calories than I could afford in groceries. I've pushed through homelessness, hunger, and extreme physical training.
I trained and worked at an MMA gym in my 20s. The hardest part was watching men join and fly right past me in months while I had to push past my limits every class to keep up. Coming face to face with their raw power in partner drills and sparring was demoralizing, and seeing them promoted every month despite official gym rules, joining the boys' club with the gym owner who played favorites and ignored female employees. I'm a martial artist and an athlete, and I chafe at the limits of my body — I hate being small and weak and knowing I can never push myself hard enough to keep up with men. But I find respite in the physical act of pushing myself.
I'm a big fan of Stoicism and find its teachings help me cope. I've read the Enchiridion by Epictetus and Meditations by Marcus Aurelius in multiple translations, and contemporary works like The Obstacle Is The Way, though I have criticisms of Ryan Holiday's monetization of Stoicism. I've felt keenly the lack of gay, queer, or women's voices in philosophy and have a dream of someday starting a podcast exploring Stoicism from those perspectives, especially around using it as a coping mechanism for dysphoria, internalized homophobia, and discrimination.
I've never medically transitioned and describe myself as having desisted, coming close to identifying as trans. I now see trans people as members of a religion I've left, and a religion that has done great harm to me and others like me — much as I used to be Mormon and left the church but still deal with Mormons in my life. I no longer believe trans people are an oppressed category or in need of special attention, help, or support. I believe medical transition is a set of experimental procedures and that doctors have an ethical obligation to do no harm that is at odds with the experimental nature of what they offer. I believe there are better ways to manage dysphoria than exogenous hormones and surgery. The longer I've been outside the trans community, the more I see similarities between the rhetoric around needing transition and how addicts talk about needing their drug of choice — and I don't think people in mental distress who threaten suicide should be treated differently from addicts in terms of not being enabled. I view gender identity as similar to a soul — a metaphysical concept some claim to have but with no objective definition or evidence — while gender nonconformity is an observable description of behavior relative to constructed gender roles. I've said nonbinary has become a medically-pathologized substitute for quirky personality, and I've been skeptical of claims of neurological evidence for gender identity, noting there's no scientific consensus in neuroscience on where gender is located in the brain. I've also criticized what I see as the queer community's appropriation of 'two-spirit' terminology, and I was critical of a gender-critical author I initially had a positive impression of, whose ideas fell apart for me after hearing him speak confidently about self-diagnosed autism and invent micro-labels.
I'm gay — I've described myself as a gay woman. I've grappled with my own desire to use an unmistakably male name while still being a woman, noting I know women named Bobby and Ryan but feeling it's 'a line that I shouldn't cross somehow.' I have a buzz cut, wear basic t-shirts and jeans cut in straight lines, and no makeup, while my body is obviously biologically female — I see myself as gender nonconforming. I've been frustrated by what I see as erasure in spaces like butch lesbian communities where women's experiences of dysphoria get reframed to center trans identities, and I've expressed frustration at the lack of spaces where women can talk about their experiences without that reframing. I've also been critical of what I call casual misogyny in parts of the martial arts community.