Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich wurde als Junge geboren, hasste es von Kindheit an, ein Junge zu sein, transitionierte sozial und nahm fast 2 Jahre Östrogen, bevor ich einige Monate vor September 2022 detransitionierte. Ich identifiziere mich heute als detransitionierter Mann, kämpfe aber noch damit, Männer zu hassen und mich selbst dafür, dass ich einer sein wollte. Ohne Hormone verändert sich mein Körper zurück (Brüste und Hüften schrumpfen, Gesichtsbehaarung kehrt zurück) und ich fühle mich körperlich viel besser, bereue aber die bleibenden Stimmveränderungen und die Schäden an meinem Bart durch die Haarentfernung. Suizidgedanken oder Selbstverletzung habe ich nicht erwähnt, aber ich trage anhaltende Reue über verlorene Zeit und einen ruinierten Körper mit mir, neben etwas Mitgefühl mit mir selbst. Ich bin vorsichtig und kritisch gegenüber der Transition anderer und rate zu möglichst geringem körperlichem Schaden und klarem Denken.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male and grew up hating being a boy — it felt like it made me worthless, like if I had been a girl I would have had friends and people would like me. I now think being neuotypical probably would have been a more effective solution to my problems than transition. I had my first girlfriend at 14 (her best friend basically had to tell me to ask her out) and I loved her a lot, but over the year we dated I realized I hated being a boyfriend; straight relationships felt lopsided and unfair and I wished we could both be girlfriends. At 16, when my moustache turned into a full beard, people started acting more deferential to me, calling me "sir" and "boss," and it felt awful. When it all got to be too much and I broke down in public (which happened a lot at one point in my life), nobody ever cared — nobody gave me a hug, no one even asked what was wrong. It felt like being a man meant getting meaningless respect I didn't deserve and no love, while being a woman seemed more fun and emotionally healthy.
I had about a year of private exploration (crossdressing phase) before going publicly trans for almost 3 years, and I was on hormones for almost 2 years. I ended up injecting estrogen, and my breasts ballooned to be larger than my sister's and my mom's. The queer community gave me a bunch of neurodivergent friends and strangers treated me much warmer — it felt like I'd solved a riddle whispered in my ear my whole life. But then I started passing and things changed: first I felt The Fear that women talk about, starting with walking alone at night in dark streets and eventually making even being alone in my own apartment feel unsafe. When I broke up with the girl I was dating during my exploratory crossdressing phase, I realized how limited my dating options as a trans girl were; seeing that girls were far more interested in men when I was trying to scrub that "stain" off me turned my vague misandry into a deep hatred of men I'm still dealing with. The wave of attention from men I got after my breasts grew amplified that hatred, even though I was literally bisexual and had enjoyable experiences with men pretransition. I started to hate what my body had become — it felt viscerally off, almost like I was wearing a suit with my real body stuck inside. I tried presenting butch, which felt silly and didn't help. I realized I was experiencing something more like how other trans people describe gender dysphoria than anything I'd felt before, so I decided to go off hormones.
It's been a few months since stopping hormones (as of September 2022) and I feel a lot better. I kept presenting feminine for some time but in fits and spurts started trying to look more masculine. I feel great about how my body is changing off hormones — my breasts and hips have shrunk and some facial hair has returned — but the idea of being a man socially still feels awful. I think I'd rather just be a cis man than go back to trying to fit myself into a gender that isn't for me; I wish I could be neither, but most people will read you one way or the other. I still hate men and hate myself for wanting to be one. I've never had a positive male role model — my dad was very distant growing up and I was never close to any male teachers. I can't remember a man I've known whom I'd like to be like; everyone I've really admired has been a woman, and any man who seems happy or attractive in a masculine way fills me with rage and jealousy. Masculinity feels like a neverending competition — to make it as a man you have to be better than the other men — and I'd rather hide behind a feminine disguise than drop out of the rat race.
I have feelings of having ruined my body and wasted my time, but I remind myself I've learnt a lot about myself and society, that I've had typically female experiences most men never will, and that my body can still be beautiful even if it doesn't fit standards of masculinity or femininity. I also remind myself that if someone can't stick around for a change of gender they weren't much of a friend. I do my best to stay away from GC spaces generally, since I already hate myself for being male enough, and I note a worrying amount of unexamined lesbophobia in straight GC spaces.
Voice has been a significant concern: my natural voice is a deep bass, but when transitioning I trained it to sound extremely feminine using voice training (resonance, openness, and consonant pronunciation being the key factors). I recognize the voicebox is permanently altered and voice change is essentially a one-way street, with possible permanent huskiness. I also express regret about damage I did to my beard through hair removal, though I've never regretted body hair removal otherwise. As of mid-2023 I describe myself as a guy with breasts and wide hips who usually gets perceived as a woman until he speaks, and then feels like "just a freak," though I'm starting to appreciate the look of shock I give some people.
My attitude toward others considering transition is cautious and harm-reduction oriented: I advise not getting caught up in terms of gender identity, that nobody "really is" trans or nonbinary, that there is just gender dysphoria which is a mental illness, that you can't change your sex, and to do as little violence to your body as possible while thinking clearly about the problem.