Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte/desistierte männlich geborene Person, die sich als trans identifizierte und ab 13 als Mädchen leben wollte, aber im Juni 2019, mit 17, beschloss, nicht körperlich zu transitionieren. Ich hatte nie eine Operation und habe nie Hormone begonnen, ich hatte nur HRT geplant und kurzzeitig eine mentale Praxis angewandt, mir einzureden, mein Körper produziere Östrogen. Ich bin zu dem Schluss gekommen, dass ich mich mit keinem der beiden binären Geschlechter ganz identifiziere und lieber einfach als Mensch gesehen werde, und ich bin froh, nicht körperlich transitioniert zu haben. Online-Trans-Communities sehe ich heute kritisch und bezeichne sie als „den Trans-Kult“, und ich plädiere dafür, die psychische Gesundheit zu klären, bevor man eine Transition erwägt.
Vollständige Geschichte
I started questioning whether I might actually be a girl when I was 13. Before that I had small glimpses of what could be called trans behavior — imagining life as a girl, sympathizing more with other girls, and finding being a boy boring. The desire came in waves: during the off waves I was never fully comfortable being a guy, but at best neutral about my gender and could take it or leave it.
Treating myself as female gave me a certain euphoria, which I attributed to the sole fact that I was treating myself that way rather than to any secondary implications. Treating myself as a guy gave no such feeling. Enforcing the male sex on my body produced either no feeling or one that felt like I was holding something in, while enforcing the female sex made me feel more expressive, as if letting emotion out. I described myself as an empath and said I had felt that same "holding in" sensation in an FTM friend of mine before his transition.
I told the community that hormones and surgery were not things I felt I must do — simply living as a girl would keep me content. I said I was not currently depressed and did not suffer from self-esteem issues. I fantasized about having sex as a female but said sexuality did not play a big role in wanting to transition; I interpreted my body as "wanting to be female, similarly to how a body feels better upon a wound healing." I said the most I would want at that point was hormone blockers, because testosterone was actively shaping my body the opposite way, and that everything I had read showed I would just resume male puberty after going off blockers. I was okay with having a penis and no breasts, said dicks can be tucked, and that even if I went on female hormones I probably wouldn't get surgery. I said I had already lived as a guy for 17 years and wanted the full female experience.
I adopted what I called "a new sort of medication as of late": convincing my body that it was producing estrogen rather than testosterone. I said this was by a wide margin what made me feel most like a girl. Upon finding the detrans sub I began to question whether subconscious implications from society were at play, since gender roles are ingrained from birth and might have seeped into my subconscious.
I praised the detrans sub as "a great antidote to the toxic positivity and acceptance in the trans community," and described getting downvoted on r/mtf for telling a girl that treating her male body characteristics as evidence of being male would only fan the flames. I objected to solutions that were only transitioning or waiting for hormones.
About a month before my June 2019 post, I was doing inner work to accept my body and facial hair and realized I actually enjoyed growing hair everywhere. I found I didn't fully dislike many masculine body aspects but didn't fully like many feminine ones, and concluded the way forward was to identify with neither — as non binary — so I wouldn't feel pressured to conform to either binary gender's roles. I said I didn't like most non-binary-type labels and simply wanted to be seen as a person, and that realizing this gave me a sense of euphoria. I wrote: "I'm glad I didn't physically transition."
I said I never had plans for surgery because I was pretty neutral about my penis, but I had been planning on HRT. My main issues with hormones were that it would change and interfere with how my body was naturally constructed, and that it would enforce the idea that I needed something external to fully enjoy my life. I said I disliked taking medication, especially medication intended to help my mental state like an antidepressant. I added that I still wouldn't mind having been born female and looking like a typical woman, but not nearly as much as I minded being a man, and that I realized I wouldn't be fully happy as a binary woman either, even though it would be an improvement. I still said I'd rather not be a man — just a person.
I later reflected that I didn't think there was any one thing to blame, maybe society and many family members subconsciously enforcing gendered stereotypes on me, and added: "I'm just glad I didn't immerse myself into the trans cult or any online trans community until the last few months of thinking I was trans."
In giving advice to others I repeatedly emphasized getting mental health bases covered before transitioning, addressing the underlying problem of not being at peace with one's appearance rather than waiting for HRT to fix it, and being patient with one's body recovering from testosterone. I also commented that even at 13 I could tell a considerable chunk of the trans/non-binary population was assigned female, noting several trans guys at my school but only two trans girls, both of whom were unpopular.